Joaquin Phoenix Or Barry Keoangh ?

[Elayis]

I wasn't a fan of Joker, as a film or Phoenix's Arthur Fleck, so it's a pretty easy decision for me, even if I'm still somewhat mixed on Keoghan's version.

 

[Ryan]

I'm up for anything aside from leto and joaquin's joker so for now i'm going with barry.

 

[antsman41]

One played Arthur... the other played Joker, so Barry - easy.

 

[Doc Samson]

One played Arthur... the other played Joker, so Barry - easy.

Exactly. I like Joker for what it is but at no point in time did Arthur really embody the character.

In one deleted scene Barry's version seemed way more intelligent so I'm going with that.

 

[InCali]

Given all of the Jokers we've seen, why just these 2?

I wasn't a big fan of the Joker movie, but recognize a well made movie with a terrific performance. IMO, Ledger's Joker has yet to be touched. Phoenix is a very, very talented actor and I would have to see him full on Joker before putting him in the conversation.

 

[metaphysician]

Keoghan because Phoenix is not even a joker (in my opinion)

This. I'll take one brief scene of Joker actually acting like Joker in Arkham, over an entire movie of over-indulgent apologia any day.