The Amazing Spider-Man Keep the ORGANICS or WEB SHOOTERS???!!!!

[Agent 194]

If we're rebooting...I say go with mechanical. Wow. And now this site has come full circle. Weird.

 

[MessiahDecoy123]

besides giving away the formula would mean giving up his identity as Spider-man.

Parker would never do that after his uncle's death.

 

[BillyZaned]

besides giving away the formula would mean giving up his identity as Spider-man.

Parker would never do that after his uncle's death.

he wouldn't be spiderman....

but, if Peter was smart enough to create web shooters... I don't even think he'd be going to a public HS... he'd either be in a private school, or even college....

 

[MessiahDecoy123]

we've seen organics. Been there, done that.

Now let's see a Spider-man who calibrates his webshooters or adjust his web formula to fight Electro, Sandman, or Mysterio.

 

[BillyZaned]

we've seen organics. Been there, done that.

Now let's see a Spider-man who calibrates his webshooters or adjust his web formula to fight Electro, Sandman, or Mysterio.

yeah, that will be fun... spiderman trying to find his socket for his ratchet so he can adjust his web shooters...

 

[MessiahDecoy123]

he wouldn't be spiderman....

but, if Peter was smart enough to create web shooters... I don't even think he'd be going to a public HS... he'd either be in a private school, or even college....

Maybe he wants to go to the same school as Mary Jane.

but it's not out of the realm of possibility that a prodigy goes to public school. Stranger things have happened.

 

[Spidey-Quad]

wow 2 to 10

WOW, that brought a lot to the discussion! 2 to 10 what? Your thoughts? Talk about a cry for minimum post restriction. Perhaps Blankman would be more apropriote.

 

[MessiahDecoy123]

yeah, that will be fun... spiderman trying to find his socket for his ratchet so he can adjust his web shooters...

I meant calibrate them at home not in mid-battle.

 

[BillyZaned]

I meant calibrate them at home not in mid-battle.

Reporter: "where is Spiderman"

Cuts to Aunt Mays house

Peter in the garage, looking for his lost tools

Peter "aunt may, have you seen my socket set"

Aunt May "maybe if you kept better care of them, you wouldn't have trouble finding them. What do you need them for anyways?"

 

[Nathan]

Has anyone ever seen this?

[YT]z2oEP3RWppA[/YT]

If we can have someone build that in real life, then we can have someone build freaking webshooters in a fantasy Movie.

 

[Batspider77]

I say both.
Let Peter have the Web coming out of his wrists just like in Raimis Version,but he has to create the Webshooters to be able to shoot and form the Web.

 

[BillyZaned]

Has anyone ever seen this?

[YT]z2oEP3RWppA[/YT]

If we can have someone build that in real life, then we can have someone build freaking webshooters in a fantasy Movie.

that guy used to have hair...

plus, I think the cavemen created fire... not organic webbing

 

[Nathan]

that guy used to have hair...

plus, I think the cavemen created fire... not organic webbing

The web fluid is a whole different matter. Webshooters shouldn't be a big deal to build in a fantasy movie. As for the web fluid, as I said before, the Ultimate books handled that quite well. Or as others mentioned, a combination of organics with webshooters used to aim and control.

I just don't understand the idea of being against webshooters when there's been crazier stuff done in Movies.

 

[Mister J]

I just don't understand the idea of being against webshooters when there's been crazier stuff done in Movies.

There's crazier stuff done in the past Spidey franchise. Some people refuse to allow that to register out of personal preference and act as if it's a proper condemnation.

 

[ultimatefan]

I got so sick of this argument at this point I just don´t care anymore.

 

[Mister J]

Thanks for sharing.

 

[comicman]

Oh no....please not this again

 

[Backdrifter]

I think main issue with web shooters is that the whole concept is very dated and stems from Peter getting his powers from a radio-active spider. The story has moved beyond that into genetic alteration which seems more realistic, thus organic webshooters are a logical choice.

 

[Boom]

What I want: mechanical webshooters.
What we'll get: organic webshooters.

 

[Daybreak_st]

What's the point of re-booting the franchise and yet keeping everything the same? Why do it then? You might as well go with mechanical webshooters, at least then there's an avenue to delve into the scientist part of peter parker. Ultimate Spider-man handeled it nicely with his dad having develped but not perffected the formula. Have peter finish the formula. And yes he's suppose to be smart, maybe he just cant afford private school so he has to settle for going to public school.

I honestly don't care one way or the other over the webs as long as they come out of his wrist. My point is don't do a reboot then keep everything the same. At least with mech webshooters you can do the spider tracers and a whole host of other gadgets he invented, like impact webbing and stingers, etc.

 

[Crook]

I think main issue with web shooters is that the whole concept is very dated and stems from Peter getting his powers from a radio-active spider. The story has moved beyond that into genetic alteration which seems more realistic, thus organic webshooters are a logical choice.

Please read through the previous 4 pages, then come back and say it's "logical" in any shape or form.

 

[Kent]

Since they're *sigh* rebooting this I guess I'd prefer the mechs. Though I think they could probably make it a bit more plausible if they used the idea I believe Stan Lee put forth in an interview once, namely have Peter struggle with the formula before being bitten by the spider and after the bite he all of a sudden has an intuitive feeling of how the formula should work.

 

[Jick]

I never understood Peter not having the most distinct characteristic of the spiders anyway...

Oh well...I don't think I care anymore.

 

[Nathan]

The organics are just as silly as the webshooters. People say the organics would be more logical. Well, let's talk "logic" then. If Spidey would indeed have organic webshooters, they'd still eventually run out. The body can't produce unlimited supplies of webbing. He'd have to consume adequate amounts of food in order to replenish them. But we've never seen him do that. He gets organics and suddenly his webbing is limitless.

 

[Immortalfire]

Doesn't matter to me, really. But I know that badly joker MATT is going to show up and say that ORGANICS are the greatest thing ever