I understand that opinion for Gangs of New York, I have always found that a difficult film which spins wildly in all directions from revenge plot to love plot to history lesson to U2 song. But The Aviator is vintage Scorsese. It's focuses on the portion of the life of an obsessed, uncompromising individual who is not only an aviator-billionaire-eccentric but a filmmaker. The directing is chock-full of Scorsese-touches. The flying, swooping cranes, the longtakes, the quick flash-bulb cutting, the adrenaline-fuelled airplane scenes down to the oldschool music Scorsese even uses in his modern-day movies. I think it's an ultimate Scorsese movie, one of the reason I love it so much (top 5 easily); it encompasses nearly all of what makes Scorsese Scorsese. And it's a damned fascinating story and subject. I'll admit is has flaws, I do not think DiCaprio is always as believable as the older Hughes, but most scenes he pulls of flawlessly. The best piece of acting in the film might be the ''show me all the blueprints'' scene. So unnerving, and DiCaprio's performance there makes the viewer feel the impact of that scene in the gut. I also will have to add I love the colour grading in this thing, I know that this is also controversial, but I loved the gradual colour-build-up throughout the movie, from blue grass on golfcourses to vivid Technicolor. And Alan Alda's performance I love, Cate Blanchett is pretty amazing.