movie doom vs movie magneto

[web-king]

who wins here ? doom or magneto from the movies

 

[web-king]

i think doom was cooler. but magneto can control dooms body just like he did wolverines.

 

[DACrowe]

Well Magneto in the first two movies is MILES BETTER. I mean McKellan is an awesome actor and gives a brilliant performance. Machmon is a decent actor but Ian McKellan is on another level as one of the greatest British actors to ever live (see him play MacBeth or King Leer).

His Magneto is iconic and only second to Jack Nicholson's Joker in terms of movie villains (of superhero films). However, in the third X-Men movie he seemed rather bored. Only in his scenes with Patrick Stewart (who seemed equally bored in the non-McKellan scenes) did he liven up and give a stirring eccentric scene. But he seemed to know the script sucked this time and I doubt Ratner gave very good direction (he and Singer went back to Apt Pupil, another good performance for him) and other than that he only had second rate actors like Rodreguiez to work with as they steal his partner in crime (Rebecca Romjin) from him in this movie and betray a character relationship he built in the second.

However, with all the bumbling Ppenn and Ratner and Kinberg did with his character (almost ruining him) he still had an authenticity and a charisma at his most phone worthy send in. On the other hand Dr. Doom was screwed up from day one as a poor Green Goblin (comparetively he doesn't even match Willem Dafoe's brilliant and superb turn as the Green Goblin, which Kinberg copied and ripped off for his mediocre Fantastic Four script) with no depth or menace.

He was boring and compare Magneto's speech about no tolerance or land of peace to rogue in X1 or his defiance towards the X-Men in Lady Liberty's Head to....Marco Polo.

Case closed, then.

 

[DACrowe]

Oh and for a fight, movie Doom is a big piece of metal who he will rip into a thousand pieces too though.

 

[web-king]

if they fought just hand to hand no powers then doom kicks his ass for sure. you saw how hard he punched.

 

[Ben Urich]

Is this even a question?
The movie Magneto is just as powerful and deep as his comic counterpart; the movie Doom is a metal skeleton with stupid electricity powers which do not even REMOTELY compare to the immensely layered, interesting and powerful DOOM from the comics.

 

[web-king]

Is this even a question?
The movie Magneto is just as powerful and deep as his comic counterpart; the movie Doom is a metal skeleton with stupid electricity powers which do not even REMOTELY compare to the immensely layered, interesting and powerful DOOM from the comics.

comics magneto is much more powerful then the one in the movies

 

[hippie_hunter]

Movie Magneto would rape Movie Doom

 

[Wyrminarrd]

Movie Magneto was miles ahead of Movie Doom. Magneto was made into a powerful and believable character while Doom was just a generic everyday villian

 

[Marvel Man]

I'd Say Magneto because in eht movie he could just tear doom apart since doom has a metal body.

 

[Doctor Octopus]

Movie Magneto of course.

 

[xii22_loop]

well doom is younger, and magneto is like 100 years old lol

 

[web-king]

well doom is younger, and magneto is like 100 years old lol

doom is older. FF came out before xmen

 

[Ben Urich]

well doom is younger, and magneto is like 100 years old lol

Doesn't change the fact that movie Doom is made of metal, which Magneto wields control over no matter his age.

 

[hippie_hunter]

doom is older. FF came out before xmen

Magneto was born at least 12 years or more before the Holocaust. I don't think that Doom was born before then

 

[DACrowe]

Well how about the fact that we should see Doc Ock in this instead. Ock is a great movie villain (so is GG....but too metall centric to survive unless he went unarmed....he could win....maybe) and his arms ARE RESISTANT TO MAGNETISM in the movie.....interesting, no?

 

[web-king]

Well how about the fact that we should see Doc Ock in this instead. Ock is a great movie villain (so is GG....but too metall centric to survive unless he went unarmed....he could win....maybe) and his arms ARE RESISTANT TO MAGNETISM in the movie.....interesting, no?

true. magneto cant control his arms but doom would still be able to shock the hell out of him.

 

[Dr.Dude]

In the movies = Magneto.

Now, if we were talking about the comics = Doom.

 

[dpm07]

In the movies = Magneto.

Now, if we were talking about the comics = Doom.

That pretty much sums up my view as well.

 

[lokisixnine]

movies magneto (since they made doom blow) everywhere else DOOM

 

[Cyclops]

Absorbing Nick Nolte would come in and beat them both to a fine pulp.

 

[Chris Wallace]

Obviously Magneto, since Doom's not only made of metal but his main power would only feed the magnetic field trapping him.

 

[Cyclops]

Since when can movie Magneto generate force fields? All I've ever seen him do is levitate stuff.

 

[xwolverine2]

MAGNETO WOULD TEAR APART DOOM

 

[Chris Wallace]

Since when can movie Magneto generate force fields? All I've ever seen him do is levitate stuff.

I didn't say anything about force fields. But obviously Magneto would have to generate a powerful magnetic field to immobilize Doom, & magnetism IS a form of electricity.