Qoèlet;11350956 said:
You don't seem to get it: what you're faced with here is the typical elitest rational any PRIDE fan has. Namely, simply fighting in PRIDE makes a fighter superior to talent elsewhere. Calling UFC a b-level show when UFC washouts just decisively beat PRIDE's overprotected lightweight champ and welterweight GP champ a couple weeks ago, saying that Arona would expose Liddell when stylistically that's an awfully good matchup for Liddell, that sort of thing. It's not logic at all, it's just embracing his own glaring bias. Additionally, citing mmaweekly rankings as evidence of anything is proof of a thoroughly unbalanced individual.
mmaweekly is a good mma website for you newbies out there.....
Pride does have the better fighters, but that's not an opinion. You research the websites out there with mmaweekly.com and mmaranks.com, etc...take a look at their top ten and see who they all fight for. Pride wins because their HW, LW, and LHW divisions are STACKED with top ranked fighters, where as UFC lacks.
UFC does have a better WW division with GSP, Hughes, and BJ Penn. Their MW is equal to pride because of Anderson Silva. Franklin, Marquardt, Lister and those guys are legit, but Pride has Denis Kang, Dan Henderson, and the number one MW in the world, BRAZILIAN TOP TEAM'S UNDEFEATED PAULO FILHO!!!!!!!
The fact is Shogun and Vanderlei already proved their number one rankings because they fought the best and beat the best. UFC protects Chuck and makes him fight the same people he's already beaten to make him seem like he is the best LHW 205 pounder in the world, but it's all Dana white and UFC hype...
If you are a casual fan and watches Spike TV for UFC, don't believe the hype. Do your own homework and come up with your conclusion.
But take it from me, someone who has been into the sport of MMA since the 90's, Shogun is number one in the world. If you watch all of Chuck's fights and all of Shogun's fights from Meca Vale Tudo, Bushido, and Pride, you will probably draw the same conclusion as me....
So when you talk about Liddell, you shouldn't assume he's the greatest just because he KO's the same people over and over.
The best example of Liddell in the top 5 is when people were wondering about the best LHW. The names included Quinton, Vanderlei, Arona, Rogerio Nogueira, and Shogun Rua.
No one knew where to rank Chuck in this division since all the fighters fought for Pride in 2003 (at that time, Pride clearly was number one while UFC was struggling). Arona was impressive, Rogerio was unstoppable, etc...
So out of all those top 5 Pride fighters, Chuck DID face one of them in 2003, he fought Quinton Jackson. Chuck got his ass handed to him...Chuck was on the ground helpless. Quinton clearly dominated and showed Liddell was nowhere near Arona, Quinton, Vanderlei, Rogerio or Shogun.
Then Quinton went on to lose to Vanderlei TWICE, therefore making Liddell look even worst. He can't even beat the Pride number two guy, no way he beats Vanderlei and Arona who were tied at number one.
You have to go beyond UFC if you really like the sport of MMA and then come up with your own logic, imo....