moraldeficiency
Maxwell's Demon
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2007
- Messages
- 9,471
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
Im bored and trying to keep my mind off my upcoming engagement so I decided to grab a bunch of the interviews on BND/OMD/SOS and put them together rather than the scattered way their all over the place. These are the opinions of either writers or Marvel employees. I tried to get as many varied opinions as possible, then listed my thoughts on them. Note they are my thoughts, not fact, just my opinion (agree, dont agree, it doesnt matter). I tried to get the most recent interviews but if I missed something or misrepresented an interview, please correct it. If you know another interview by someone not on this list, post it up with your opinions on it (keep them reasonably short), but try not to get too personal because it just makes you look like an @sshole whos opinion shouldnt matter.
Keith Geffen: http://www.comicbookresources.com/columns/?column=27
My thoughts: This is about on line with my opinions, I dont mind undoing the marriage, just the way it was done. I also like that he called out the writers for not taking ownership of anything.
Erik Larson: http://www.comicbookresources.com/columns/?column=20
My thoughts: About the same as Geffen. Its not about the change of status just the way it was done and the confusion it brought about. Good alternate ways it could have gone.
Mark Millar: http://forums.millarworld.tv/index.php?showtopic=76856
My thoughts: He skipped over actually talking about the issue other than saying, This is by far the greatest work of his career so far and probably the best illustrated Spider-Man comic since Steve Ditko was still talking to Stan Lee. I'd go as far as to say it was the best-drawn book of the past twelve months and, believe me, I am the snobbiest art-***** in the industry. Come the @uck on! Sorry but that was just a sad level of @ss kissing. Hey I liked the art too, but best ever? Maybe if Joey Q could draw a face that didnt have that silly putty effect I might consider considering him as a great artist, for now Ill just say hes hit or miss.
Peter David: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005921.html
follow up: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005924.html
follow up: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005926.html
My thoughts: I think this is both honest and careful. He does work for marvel. He doesnt hate the idea just how it was executed. He also knows what its like to feel the hate over a creative decision (though I was for the majority a fan of his FNSM).
Dan Slott: http://comics.ign.com/articles/844/844895p1.html
My thoughts: I like Dan. I have nothing against the man. I love, repeat love, his AtI (best avengers book out there and the only one you should be bothering with). Hes in a tough situation with for the first time having the majority of comic nuts not on his side. Still I think he handled it well and didnt talk down to anyone. He loves Spider-Man, thats obvious, and right now hes jazzed to be part of this. I think hell write some great classic stories, but I think he like everyone else cant answer jack as far as any real questions regarding Petes past, so well see if they even mention any past events in spider-man (I doubt it) and I think hes lying about explaining things in the book (beyond a brief MJ and Harry point or two I doubt itll be mentioned).
Steve Wacker: http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=141937
Part two: http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=142504
My thoughts: Steve is the perfect man for this job. Hes handling things well IMO. Hes the right guy to keep ASM coming out on time (something that could be a coffin nail to this book if they slip). He goes into a bit of a rant and I think some of this pressure might be showing, but he comes off pretty good. I like how he mentioned Kravens Last Hunt as his favorite story (one of my favorites too).
Tom Brevoort: http://www.marvel.com/blogs/Tom_Brevoort/
My thoughts: Nice try, the youth thing didnt ring nearly true but the positivity point did have some valid statements. Personally I always thought Pete was about responsibility over everything else. Its about making a mistake and being man enough to not only recognize it but do something about it (now you can see how a devil dealing Pete just pisses me off to no possible end).
Wacker/Brennan: http://www.marvel.com/blogs/Spider-Office/ (scroll down)
My thoughts: Cute, and especially with the gale thing in the beginning and then wacker stepping in to defend nay saying fans but youll have to do some more fancy devil dealing magic to make that sound less contrived. For the Top Five reasons at the bottom:
1. I would be very happy to not have another ninja mentioned in comics for the rest of the year.
2. Bigger supporting cast? Im a fan.
3. Dont care.
4. Yeah, thats what makes this boycott hard.
5. ??
Joey Q: http://www.aintitcool.com/node/35318
My thoughts: Complement sandwich time.
What I like about you: I love most of your changes, you and Bob Harris really did bring Marvel back around with new and creative ideas that reinvigorated the status quo and brought Marvel back to something written for the fans.
What I dont like about you: Quote: Lets take Aunt May off the table for a second, lets just say it was some random woman.
Mephisto pops up and says to Peter, See that woman over there, she was hit accidentally by a bullet that was intended for you because you unmasked yourself and someone wanted you dead. Look, I know you dont know her, a perfect stranger, but I can save her life, I just want your marriage.
How would we all feel if Peter said, nah, sorry, let her die. End Quote. That would work unless you fill that in a little more. Lets include the fact that the woman was shot as a result of one of her decisions, lets also include that the woman ASKED TO DIE. Then lets finally include that Pete used to be depicted as pretty smart so if the devil pops up and makes an offer most smart people understand that when you make that deal evil always comes out on top. But I digress .
What I like about you: You hire some great talent (except Hudlin and Bendis)
Keith Geffen: http://www.comicbookresources.com/columns/?column=27
My thoughts: This is about on line with my opinions, I dont mind undoing the marriage, just the way it was done. I also like that he called out the writers for not taking ownership of anything.
Erik Larson: http://www.comicbookresources.com/columns/?column=20
My thoughts: About the same as Geffen. Its not about the change of status just the way it was done and the confusion it brought about. Good alternate ways it could have gone.
Mark Millar: http://forums.millarworld.tv/index.php?showtopic=76856
My thoughts: He skipped over actually talking about the issue other than saying, This is by far the greatest work of his career so far and probably the best illustrated Spider-Man comic since Steve Ditko was still talking to Stan Lee. I'd go as far as to say it was the best-drawn book of the past twelve months and, believe me, I am the snobbiest art-***** in the industry. Come the @uck on! Sorry but that was just a sad level of @ss kissing. Hey I liked the art too, but best ever? Maybe if Joey Q could draw a face that didnt have that silly putty effect I might consider considering him as a great artist, for now Ill just say hes hit or miss.
Peter David: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005921.html
follow up: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005924.html
follow up: http://peterdavid.malibulist.com/archives/005926.html
My thoughts: I think this is both honest and careful. He does work for marvel. He doesnt hate the idea just how it was executed. He also knows what its like to feel the hate over a creative decision (though I was for the majority a fan of his FNSM).
Dan Slott: http://comics.ign.com/articles/844/844895p1.html
My thoughts: I like Dan. I have nothing against the man. I love, repeat love, his AtI (best avengers book out there and the only one you should be bothering with). Hes in a tough situation with for the first time having the majority of comic nuts not on his side. Still I think he handled it well and didnt talk down to anyone. He loves Spider-Man, thats obvious, and right now hes jazzed to be part of this. I think hell write some great classic stories, but I think he like everyone else cant answer jack as far as any real questions regarding Petes past, so well see if they even mention any past events in spider-man (I doubt it) and I think hes lying about explaining things in the book (beyond a brief MJ and Harry point or two I doubt itll be mentioned).
Steve Wacker: http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=141937
Part two: http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=142504
My thoughts: Steve is the perfect man for this job. Hes handling things well IMO. Hes the right guy to keep ASM coming out on time (something that could be a coffin nail to this book if they slip). He goes into a bit of a rant and I think some of this pressure might be showing, but he comes off pretty good. I like how he mentioned Kravens Last Hunt as his favorite story (one of my favorites too).
Tom Brevoort: http://www.marvel.com/blogs/Tom_Brevoort/
My thoughts: Nice try, the youth thing didnt ring nearly true but the positivity point did have some valid statements. Personally I always thought Pete was about responsibility over everything else. Its about making a mistake and being man enough to not only recognize it but do something about it (now you can see how a devil dealing Pete just pisses me off to no possible end).
Wacker/Brennan: http://www.marvel.com/blogs/Spider-Office/ (scroll down)
My thoughts: Cute, and especially with the gale thing in the beginning and then wacker stepping in to defend nay saying fans but youll have to do some more fancy devil dealing magic to make that sound less contrived. For the Top Five reasons at the bottom:
1. I would be very happy to not have another ninja mentioned in comics for the rest of the year.
2. Bigger supporting cast? Im a fan.
3. Dont care.
4. Yeah, thats what makes this boycott hard.
5. ??
Joey Q: http://www.aintitcool.com/node/35318
My thoughts: Complement sandwich time.
What I like about you: I love most of your changes, you and Bob Harris really did bring Marvel back around with new and creative ideas that reinvigorated the status quo and brought Marvel back to something written for the fans.
What I dont like about you: Quote: Lets take Aunt May off the table for a second, lets just say it was some random woman.
Mephisto pops up and says to Peter, See that woman over there, she was hit accidentally by a bullet that was intended for you because you unmasked yourself and someone wanted you dead. Look, I know you dont know her, a perfect stranger, but I can save her life, I just want your marriage.
How would we all feel if Peter said, nah, sorry, let her die. End Quote. That would work unless you fill that in a little more. Lets include the fact that the woman was shot as a result of one of her decisions, lets also include that the woman ASKED TO DIE. Then lets finally include that Pete used to be depicted as pretty smart so if the devil pops up and makes an offer most smart people understand that when you make that deal evil always comes out on top. But I digress .
What I like about you: You hire some great talent (except Hudlin and Bendis)