Sequels Should Carnage be the villain in Spidey 4?

[Hellion]

Carnage with Calypso controlling him!

 

[Venom 1988]

Carnage with Calypso controlling him!

Todd Mcfarlane presents Spider-Man: Torment Part 2

Double the visuals!
Still no plot!

 

[Metal Spidey]

Are you kidding? The Lizard, Kraven, Electro, and Scorpion to name a few. And they all have more dimension than Carnage does. And are all far more worthy of being immortalized on screen.

Carnage is awesome, but I strongly disagree with your post. Lizard, Kraven, Vulture, Electro, Mysterio, Scorpion and others are very worthy of being in a Spidey film. Go check a couple of the Issues of Amazing Spider-Man and see how some of the classic Villians stories are and how great of a challenge they create for Spidey.

Ok, ok. I take back what I said about Carnage. But you still have to think about the people who aren't comic book fans. They still make up some of the ticket sales and most of them had no idea that Galactus wasn't a cloud.

 

[Venom 1988]

^^^^^
Usually most people can usually tell if a character has substance or are just there for eye candy.

 

[Superhero 101]

Well i want carnage but then i don't want carnage because he is more of a venom baddie then he is of a spidey.

 

[Spider-Fan]

The Lizard is definately next in line. Carnage is a shallow character, but he would be an instant money maker, so he will come eventually (even us who hate Carnage have to admit it). However, we need to at least see The Lizard before Carnage.

 

[Spidey-Quad]

heck NOOOOOOOOOOO

 

[OddBob]

No.

Leave Carnage to the Venom spin-off.

 

[RaZaTrOn]

No i don't want to see Carnage *****fied for a PG-13. Lets hope for a R rated Venom and have him in there.

 

[scifijunky]

gotta b lizard next, just lizard. SM3 had far too many bad guys to do any of them justice (esp venom). lets just have a lizard vs spidy battle to the death for SM4 then think about reviving the symbiote storyline for SM5 or 6. and to those who say u cant do carnage cos it wud 2 b r rated? look at Heath Ledgers' Joker?!

 

[Nightmare]

No, venom was done horribly im S-M3. How bad would they do carnage. NO!

 

[scifijunky]

just cos they done venom bad in SM3 doesnt mean another director cant do carnage in SM 5 or 6?

 

[RaZaTrOn]

gotta b lizard next, just lizard. SM3 had far too many bad guys to do any of them justice (esp venom). lets just have a lizard vs spidy battle to the death for SM4 then think about reviving the symbiote storyline for SM5 or 6. and to those who say u cant do carnage cos it wud 2 b r rated? look at Heath Ledgers' Joker?!

Carnage is far far worse than the Joker. Joker likes to play games. Carnage... well just look at his god damn name. Never should he step foot in a film aimed towards a young audience.

Look up the definition of Carnage and thats precisely the level of violence that should follow this villain... pure pure Carnage.

 

[comic_book_guy]

i would love to see carnage in a spiderman movie but i dont think it will ever happen.... carnag has a very graphic gory background...how would they pull that off without it ending up being a poor horror movie? i think they want to keep the movies rated PG-12 because of the money they get from kids watching etc.
i said no...

 

[scifijunky]

does any1 actually have any credible news about spidy 4. iv been lookin round online 4 ages but not found much

 

[Venom 1988]

does any1 actually have any credible news about spidy 4. iv been lookin round online 4 ages but not found much

James Vanderbilt (Zodiac, The Rundown) is writing the script and theres only going to be 2 villains. Thats pretty much all the confirmed information.

 

[Mutagen]

No he shouldn't. He should be a villain saved for a Venom spin-off, and Venom should get a more mature rating anyway.

 

[omid17]

Never read any of the comics but doesn't Aunt may find out who spidey is, after peter gets effed up by Carnage? He was like lying on the bed, badly wounded and aunt may comes in right?

 

[Gotham22]

is this Venom spin-off actually getting made?

 

[Obi-Wan]

yes

 

[Grievous]

tell me what you think.

maybe idk I kinda want the Lizard more and because of Sam I would not get my hopes up of a whole SM movie with just Carnage.

 

[The Shadow]

I say yes. It will fit right in, on spidey 4 they can show a piece of the symbiote got away and went to its next "host", Cletus Kasady.

 

[Jick]

maybe idk I kinda want the Lizard more and because of Sam I would not get my hopes up of a whole SM movie with just Carnage.

true, but remember that Raimi is not in control of the script anymore.
Vanderbilt is, so he'll decide who the villains are going to be.

 

[Metal Spidey]

I was all for Carnage but after watching the movies over again, he'd be best for a Venom movie.

 

[red hood 4]

I know this has been said but Carnage better in Venom or not at all