jaydawg said:I love Spidey as much as the rest of you guys, but realistically, thats pretty much what would happen. Tony Stark could find a way to screw his spidey sense. It's happened a bunch of times before. Hell the Green Goblin did it with some chemical and i dont think they ever explained how he knew Spidey had a Spidey sense in the first place.
Iron Man, in pretty much every suit for a couple decades now, is at a class 80 strength minimum. With the amount of times he's taken on so many bruisers, he'd have to. I do think its rediculous that Parker was Tony's ***** for so long, but lets be honest here. One of Starks beams could easily take out Pete if he was distracted, which he clearly was. Hell, that one punch would have been enough. If anything, that fight in ASM was bull****.
Lt. Figgnuts said:Okay, as logical and realistic as all of the arguments for why Spidey or Iron Man would win are, let's look at it this way...
It's IRON MAN'S book. Are they going to have him get his ass handed to him by Spider-Man?
I should think not.
I mean, say what you will about the fight between Spidey and Iron Man in ASM #536, but Spidey didn't lose that fight. Maybe he didn't necessarily win it, but he didn't lose it.
Dragon said:SBut- Stark should never be able to repleicate the spider sense. That's just ridiculous.
Dragon said:Spidey gets his ass stomped in his own book all the time.
But that's not really the point. No question, Spidey would and should have his hands full against Ironman. IM has several times Spidey's strength and very dangerous weapons. Spidey's only real hope is outsmarting Stark. But- Stark should never be able to repleicate the spider sense. That's just ridiculous.
Yes one punch from just about any Iron Man suit could realisitcally take Spidey out. I'm not saying it makes for a great fight, or that Spidey shouldnt be able to dodge that punch, but in practically any IM armor, Stark is, minimum, eight times stronger than Spidey.ragingdemon155 said:One punch? Come on now. Spidey has taken punishment from Hulk and other heavy hitters in the Marvel Universe. One punch from Iron Man isn't knocking out Spider-man. Granted I think that Iron Man would obviously have the upper hand in a fight between the two. Saying that Iron Man would easily win?
Thats ridiculous
jaydawg said:Yes one punch from just about any Iron Man suit could realisitcally take Spidey out. I'm not saying it makes for a great fight, or that Spidey shouldnt be able to dodge that punch, but in practically any IM armor, Stark is, minimum, eight times stronger than Spidey.
reallyoldspideyfan said:Hello,
Even from the earliest issues, Peter always goes in prepared. He may get his ass kicked the first time but will go in prepared the second. He did this against Doc Ock, The Lizard, Rhino and many others the second time.
In a fair fight: Peter would put up a good fight but would lose.
If Peter prepared: Peter still might lose but IRON MAN would need a new set of armour.
Point is, IRON MAN is well above SPIDER-MAN in power levels but that has not stopped SM from beating opponent's more powerful than him. Difference is, most of his more powerful opponent's were either less-intelligent or full of anger. Tony is neither of these things so will make a more dynamic opponent.
Tony's armour has limits...SM's heart does not. Perhaps that is the advantage.
DN
PS: I am an older collector and it's one thing to see IRON MAN kick Spidey's ass but it is another to see CAPTAIN AMERICA worry and get shots in on Spider-man. The guy can dodge bullets (many bullets) and has Spider Sense. He is also WAY faster and stronger than CAP and has, in my opinion, a faster healing factor. No matter how good a fighter is, SM can sense the move coming. Silly. Am I missing something about CAP's powers?
jaydawg said:Yes one punch from just about any Iron Man suit could realisitcally take Spidey out. I'm not saying it makes for a great fight, or that Spidey shouldnt be able to dodge that punch, but in practically any IM armor, Stark is, minimum, eight times stronger than Spidey.
jaydawg said:Oh please. Stark has produced way more "bull****" level strategies than figuring out how to beat a Spider sense. The Green Goblin did it during Lee's run. If he figured out how to beat Nitro in practically the same way he figured how to take out Spidey's Sense, its very possible. The guy had weeks worth of data on Spidey from the Iron Suit. I don't understand why people are being so hard headed about this. Spidey was distracted. The sense was telling him about another direction. He already had a punch in the face, which was more than capable of KOing him. An beam following up would certainly be enough to take him. Like I said earlier, the ASM fight which Pete won was far more bs than anything from IM14.
And no, Iron Man is stronger than both Venom AND Carnage. Carnage is in the 50 ton range. Like I've said before, the minimum amount of strength any IM amor has is in the 80 ton range. And yes, I know Spidey's beat Hulk more than once. Doesn't change the fact that none of those fights make any logical sense.
Dragon said:Dude- NO WAY. No way Stark can replicate the spider sense. It's not merely a chemical-neurological process that Stark can replicate in his labs. It isn't even something that can be clearly explained. And no, the Goblin dulling the Spider sense isn't the same thing. What the Goblin did was essentially to effect the spider sense chemically the way a virus attacks attacks an immune system, decreasing its strength. But weakening it is a far cry from replicating it and moreover controlling it. If Stark were merely weakening it as the Goblin did, fine.
And I agree with you that Spidey beating the Hulk is ridiculous. But that's not what we're talking about here. We're talking about a one punch knock-out, that wouldn't happen. Spidey, like any other superhuman has a level of durability. You can also factor in the flexibility of Spidey's muscle and skeletal frame which would make him somewhat "rubbery" and thus resilient to massive blows. There was a case a few years ago of a newborn baby who fell several stories into a muddy patch of land, and the baby survived due to his bones still being soft. Spidey is similar to that.
ragingdemon155 said:Spidey beating the Hulk? I don't really recall this happening. Spidey has out witted the Hulk a few times here and there. But without some sought of gimmick, he's never beaten the Hulk in a straight up fight. That's never happened.
Themanofbat said:Well, I'm going to think "outside the box" for a moment and let's all suppose that Marvel is making Spidey lose a lot of fights on purpose.
Let's face it... over the years, as Spider-Man has become more and more popular, people began expecting to win his fights, because he was Spider-Man. In the same manner that Batman went from a detective/crime-fighter to an almost undefeatable character in the DC Universe who could even defeat Jesus on a bad day, maybe (I said maybe here, folks...) Spidey had achieved some weird similar type of status in the Marvel Universe.
Having said that, we all know that Marvel plans on returning Spider-Man to his more popular role as a vigilante type hero in the Marvel Universe where even the other heroes don't really trust him... maybe they want to re-create a victorious fighting style Spider-Man that can oversome incredible odds to come out on top... only to have the Spectre of Spider-Man wreck his personal life.
And it would be harder to do that if we expect him to win EVERY fight.
I'm really grasping at straws here folks... but it's possible that the dumbing down of Spidey's fights is the direct result of returning our favorite wall-crawler to his grassroots.
![]()
![]()
![]()