• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Horror 'The Witch': A new horror movie from A42

Let me preface by saying that "scary" is not the word I would use to describe this film. Unsettling, disturbing, and eerie - any of those seem more appropriate. Honestly, throughout the film you're just waiting for things to get worse and worse. Eggers does a masterful job of not letting up the suspense.

Couple of quick hits:

- The use of animals in the film is some of the best I've seen, particularly for this genre. Eggers made a rabbit unnerving. Seriously. **** that rabbit.

- The acting is top notch - child actors included. The movie has one of the most disturbing possession scenes I've ever watched - because it comes from such a real place. No voice modulation, no fancy special effects. It's all in the boy's performance. Held my breath throughout the entire scene - and it ends on such a crushing note.

- Black Phillip steals the show by the end. The final scene between him and Thomasin, if Eggers had filmed it any other way, it would've come across as laughable. Instead, it's the scene that probably sticks with me the most. Eggers gives you just enough to have an understanding of what is happening, and lets your mind do the rest.

- The score is perfect. Among the best I've heard for a horror film.

- I was raised Roman Catholic, and while I'm not exactly a practicing Catholic at this point in my life, certain aspects of this film got under my skin. To see this family trying desperately to serve God faithfully and unyieldingly, only to see their prayers ignored as Satan ****s all over them, it's tough to watch from a religious point of view.

- There are actual witches. They're basically natural-looking women - albeit nude, haggard, bloated, and wrinkled. Oh, and they fly on brooms.

- The dialogue is a bit hard to get through at times. It'll take multiple viewings, and I for one will be greatly served by subtitles on DVD.

I loved it. Again, I wouldn't call it scary. But Eggers builds up atmosphere and suspense masterfully, and it all leads up to a very disturbing final ten minutes. Gorgeously shot, exquisitely written, brilliantly acted, fearlessly directed. It's a horror film I see myself watching time and time again. Cannot wait for what Eggers does next.
 
Last edited:
Let me preface by saying that "scary" is not the word I would use to describe this film. Unsettling, disturbing, and eerie - any of those seem more appropriate. Honestly, throughout the film you're just waiting for things to get worse and worse. Eggers does a masterful job of not letting up the suspense.

Couple of quick hits:

- The use of animals in the film is some of the best I've seen, particularly for this genre. Eggers made a rabbit unnerving. Seriously. **** that rabbit.

- The acting is top notch - child actors included. The movie has one of the most disturbing possession scenes I've ever watched - because it comes from such a real place. No voice modulation, no fancy special effects. It's all in the boy's performance. Held my breath throughout the entire scene - and it ends on such a crushing note.

- Black Phillip steals the show by the end. The final scene between him and Thomasin, if Eggers had filmed it any other way, it would've come across as laughable. Instead, it's the scene that probably sticks with me the most. Eggers gives you just enough to have an understanding of what is happening, and lets your mind do the rest.

- The score is perfect. Among the best I've heard for a horror film.

- I was raised Roman Catholic, and while I'm not exactly a practicing Catholic at this point in my life, certain aspects of this film got under my skin. To see this family trying desperately to serve God faithfully and unyieldingly, only to see their prayers ignored as Satan ****s all over them, it's tough to watch from a religious point of view.

- There are actual witches. They're basically natural-looking women - albeit nude, haggard, bloated, and wrinkled. Oh, and they fly on brooms.

- The dialogue is a bit hard to get through at times. It'll take multiple viewings, and I for one will be greatly served by subtitles on DVD.

I loved it. Again, I wouldn't call it scary. But Eggers builds up atmosphere and suspense masterfully, and it all leads up to a very disturbing final ten minutes. Gorgeously shot, exquisitely written, brilliantly acted, fearlessly directed. It's a horror film I see myself watching time and time again. Cannot wait for what Eggers does next.

This has my hyped beyond belief! I'm glad to hear it has your stamp of approval. (Especially since we both seemed to be on the fence about this/trying not to get our hopes up.)

I'm perfectly fine with it not being "scary". I think unsettling/disturbing/thought provoking (I hear it kind of touches on the culture from the 16th and how women were treated) goes a much longer way than scares. More so it leaves an impression on you and you're bound to think of it afterwards.

I'm getting my friends together to go see it Saturday night. I look forward to hearing everyone's thoughts on this film.

Thanks for your insights, Boom.
 
It's hard to watch at times. It's bleak. And really, some of the film's scarier moments come from the family's reactions to the tragedies that befall them. Grief, anguish, confusion, rage, hysteria. The supernatural aspects are alarming in their own right, but really it's watching the family unravel that keeps you locked in a vice grip of dread. The film really does feel like a spiritual successor to The Shining in that regard. But whereas that film chronicled a man's descent into madness, this chronicles a family's descent into soul-crushing hopelessness.

I am looking forward to you guys seeing it. Really cant wait to discuss the last ten minutes.
 
Last edited:
My kind of horror has always been people doing horrific things to one another. It's why my favorite horror to this day is The Mist.
 
Just got back from seeing the movie. First I must say I am very happy a film like this can get a wide release.
Festival releases have a tendency to become very hyped as bloggers feel the need to advocate for the movie to help get the word out and help it get distribution. Thankfully more recent interviews with Eggers kind of set my expectations straight. Not to say that the movie isn't high quality and worth seeing but rather some of the early reports and descriptions of a few scenes really give the wrong impression of what kind of movie this is.
To say this movie is a slow burn doesn't quite capture how it feels. Rather it a is slowly ratcheting and claustrophobic press of tension. The most similar film I can think of "A Field In England" isn't particularly illustrative as most people haven't seen it.

In many ways the film resembles the Shining but I think in others it is actually a more successful in its aims than the Shining was. Kubrick has often been quoted referring to the Shining as the story of a family "Slowly losing their minds together." The problem I've long had with the Shining is that Jack Nicholson just seems nuts from the opening interview on.

This film I think actually does a better job of showing how a family under stress falls apart how tension and struggle can bring old resentments and growing suspicions to the forefront.

Obviously saying anything is "Better than the Shining" is hyperbole to the point of silliness but this movie draws heavily from it (Eggers openly admits this in a recent slashfilm article) but I'd say he took the best possible lessons from Kubrick and built upon what that earlier film did.

Witch movies set in this era are kind of a complicated issue I think. Either you make essentially a Salem Witch Trials movie and there are no witches and its just scared Puritan ass****s finding a scapegoat and oppressing women... or witches are real and the scared Puritan ass**** were quite justified.
This film sort of tries to have it both ways. It is the story of a family growing suspicious of a girl/young woman's growing feminine power ... but then there are also just straight up Witches.

In some ways I think the movie either should have had no real witches or rather somewhat more than it has. As it is it neither has the paranoid suggestibility of the Blair Witch Project nor the exploitative pleasures of a gorier horror film. That isn't to complain. The sparing use of the witches really sells their impact. I like what the film does but I can understand if there are people that get a little left on the wayside by this movie.

Go see this movie. It is practically guaranteed to be unlike any other film you'll see in theaters this year.

8/10
 
I had no idea that Eggers and this film was influenced by the Shining. But that's great to hear, because The Shining is one of my favorite films.
 
Going to see this later today. First movie I'm going to see in a theater in 2016.
 
Been waiting to see this and love hearing that it's good. Seems like the early BO returns are promising too: per mojo it made $630k in preview screenings last night.
 
With a $3.5 million budget they're on track to make a pretty penny on this. Although, if they dropped $20 million on marketing that may be a bit tougher.
 
Has anyone seen Black Phillip's (the goat!) Twitter account? Lol.

https://***********/blackphillip
 
I was planning on seeing Deadpool this Sunday but I'll see this instead. Forgot that I had been waiting for this ever since it was shown in festival circuits. Can't wait.
 
Just got back from seeing this. This was stunning. The performances were great, especially the eldest son (Caleb?) and the parents, and the atmosphere was horrific. I'm definitely going to keep tabs of Eggers from here on out. Isn't he doing a remake of Nosferatu at some point?
 
Just got back from seeing this. This was stunning. The performances were great, especially the eldest son (Caleb?) and the parents, and the atmosphere was horrific. I'm definitely going to keep tabs of Eggers from here on out. Isn't he doing a remake of Nosferatu at some point?

I read an interview where he said that was taken out of context. He said he'd love to, but that isn't his next project at all.
 
Going to see this movie later tonight. Can't wait!
 
I thought it was fantastic but not nearly as scary as some have said. There was definitely an eerie atmosphere throughout the entire film but nothing truly "scary" per se. Great things ahead for Eggers and Taylor-Joy though!

Here's my full review:
http://otlnews.net/2016/02/19/the-witch-review/
 
Just got home from seeing this and for me this is true horror. Unsetlling subject matter and themes mixed with good character and disturbing mood, atmosphere and imagery. Boo scares come and go but stuff like this stays with you.
 
That scene with Black Phillip tho.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"