• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Was music better 10 years ago than today?

I'd say music was worse 10 years ago. Rock was nearly dead because of pop "artists" who were more like manufactured characters. Now they have grown up, broken from their masters leash, and are actual artists now.
What I've seen is a rise in independent music. You never hear about managers like the fat guy in charge of all those Jive records artists who swindled them out of money. It's about the artist more. I've seen artists doing what THEY want to do, instead what people want them to do. Even the American Idol people eventually move out from the manufactured crap that is their first two albums.
 
There's still manufactured music. It's just better now.
 
I grew up in the 80's so my tastes will lean towards that era of music of New Wave, Michael Jackson, Rick Astley and the one-hit wonders even if it sounds dated.

My thinking is whatever music you listened to growing up is the music that will stay with you as favorite.

I listen to the radio and like certain songs but not enough to go out and buy their CD's.
 
I'm a fan of the range from 1994 to 2005. After that I stopped listening and when I started up again, I didnt like what I was hearing.That said, there are a few newer bands that I do like.
 
Katy Perry is the polar opposite of Gaga. She's the anti-Gaga. Ke$ha is going for the whole drunk ****ty blonde image which has nothing to do with Gaga. So, I don't where you're getting the Gaga rip-offs from. Are you talking about Nicki Minaj? She's more of a goofball than anything else.

.....which is why I said "Some form or another". You act like i said they're carbon copies.
 
I think music was worst 10 years ago than it is today but then it depends really what music your into.

Alot more musical variety these days I think.

When I think back to mainstream music of aound 2000 it was Euro trash dance music, novelty pop, manufactered boy band/girl bands/solo singers, Nu-Metal, Pop-Punk and a few rock bands hanging around from the 90s.
None of that stuff I was a big fan of.

Rap music was better then though except Ja Rule he was never good.
 
Some music is worse, some is better.

I'm 33 so grew up with a lot of 80s and 90s music. And nowadays, when I listen to older stuff like some of Michael Jackson's 80s tunes, I think ............ singers now just don't make songs with those kind of unique melodies any more. Of course there's always exceptions to the rule, but a vast majority of the chart/pop music I hear on the radio is quite forgettable and all sounds very similar. It's not as catchy. And that's just one artist - there are thousands of other artists in the 80s asides from MJ who also produced very innovative, catchy music. Why is it like that? Well for one thing, I think the music industry exerts more control now and artists have less means to pursue their individuality in their musical style. They opt for safe (a beat or hook that works) rather than different.

However, I will admit that Rap has got much much better than the MC Hammer and Vanilla Ice pop-rap we were subjected to at one time lol.

Can't vouch for R&B or the like as I'm not a big fan; a lot of it sounds identical to me. But I'll admit that could just be down to me having little interest in it.

I started playing guitar when I was 16 and progressively got into rock music in a big way - all styles, pop rock, hard metal, punk, glam, grunge. It's still by far my favourite kind of music and I still play very often. I think Rock has come the opposite way of pop music and has improved immeasurably. 70s and early 80s rock was characterised by big hair, epic riffs, power ballads ........... all quite cheesy. I think rock nowadays is much more serious (a good thing in my book) and the songs have got better and deeper as a result.

I'm a huge lover of Muse, and I like the way they have started out as a very simple 3-piece band doing typical guitar/drum/bass songs, but as they've got older have evolved into this arena-filling group who can make so much noise from so little. I still think it's hard to beat the buzz of seeing a real band making real music as opposed to watching another Justin Bieber type singing about things he's never experienced whilst worrying about his haircut. Even if I go to a bar now, my face lights up if there's a band there with a guitar and drumkit and not just some guy with a few backing tracks and a microphone.

As for the Internet and the huge changes it's wrought on the music industry ................. I still don't know if that's a good thing or bad. More freedom for artists publishing themselves, less money for established artists and the record companies which means less risks taken on new and exciting acts, bigger show ticket prices for us as a result. But more proliferation of good music for us, all of which is instantly accessible. Pros and cons all round!
 
I don't know, I may be in the minority here, but I feel like music from all genres were much better, specifically from the range of 1999 to 2004. I guess the same can be said with every decade based on how much music changes, but does anyone else feel this way?

It was better during that time, but music was at it's best through out the 90s.

10 years ago, pop mostly consisted of boy bands and pop princesses. Now we have Lady Gaga. That's an improvement.

Is it? Is it really?
 
Yes, it is. Despite all the bizarre costumes and bizarre personality, Lady Gaga's actually very talented. She was piano prodigy when she was younger and some of her non-singles (such as Speechless) are better than her actual singles and they showcase her skills better.
 
Agree to disagree. Everything I've ever heard of hers, single or not, has been just god awful.
 
Meh. I just wouldn't call her untalented because she's definitely not untalented, but yeah pop music can overshadow talent.
 
Access to music has greatly improved, both legally and illegally. Seriously youtube is fantastic, as much as vevo annoys me the bands do collect revenue from hits to their youtube hits, huge amounts of concert footage out there too, smaller bands can get their music out their even more easily than the days of myspace. Even if you hate whats playing on the radio, you can find things you like.
 
Music is always better 10 years ago. Even 10 years ago music was better 10 years ago. And 10 years from now, music today will be far better than the music of 10 years from now. That......is Science.
 
Agree to disagree. Everything I've ever heard of hers, single or not, has been just god awful.
I'm not a fan of Lady Gaga, but I think some of her earlier singles from a year or two ago, while I never liked them at the time, I can sort of listen to now, but I think its more of a case of a song/beat getting stuck in your head long enough that you learn to enjoy it.
 
I'm not a fan of Lady GaGa's music too, but you know what? She's unique, and different, and has a very individual 'sound'. And that should be applauded, whether you love her or loathe her, because too many singers and bands follow the same format nowadays. She's being different, and she took risks by being different, but it's paying off.
 
I really don't think GaGas music is really at all different from anything thats been done before, neither are her antics.
 
I really don't think GaGas music is really at all different from anything thats been done before, neither are her antics.

I agree Grace Jones been doing what Lady Gaga's been doing for the last 30 years
 
the most shocking thing she could do now is just wear some pants.
 
I really don't think GaGas music is really at all different from anything thats been done before

Originality is very rare. Someone ALWAYS did it before. That's why it's best to judge how good the music is as opposed to how original it is.
 
I agree Grace Jones been doing what Lady Gaga's been doing for the last 30 years

same with Roisin Murphy

4336x.jpg
 
As of late, music has become too much of an assembly line process. Almost every artist in every genre does some sort of europop electronic dance beat, with an auto tune voice effect. To that end, I listen to a song by Lil Wayne or Niki Minaj (or however you spell her name) and it sounds like the same songs I hear from Justin Bieber, Usher or Lady Gaga.

Rock has also gone down hill. Everyone puts their guitar in drop C # or drop B, and goes to town with very simple chord progressions that consist of nothing but power chords. "Solos" are usually played along a single string and are very brief and unimaginative.

Though, there are some exceptions. I heard a song by Selena Gomez & The Scene called, "I Won't Apologize." Not only was it not lyrical garbage with a repetitive verse (I'm sure everyone here has heard one of these modern songs where people basically chant the same word ten times, e.g. "baby baby baby ohhhh"), but the guitar riff is actually solid. It sounds like a late 80s/early 90s rock song...almost like something made by a softer version of No Doubt.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"