def28
Avenger
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2008
- Messages
- 12,746
- Reaction score
- 184
- Points
- 75
There will have to be heavy creative license as usual but if this was adapted your talking Wolverine, Deadpool, Nightcrawler, Psylocke, Archangel and Fantomex. With Horsemen, Shadow King, Mystique, Sabartooth, Daken and Apocalypse playing into it as well. That's a pretty legit roster of characters. It would be looked at as a major X flick into the series with tons of fan favs. So I can see Josh8's point of view here.
As far as the rating, be it X-Force or X-Men we won't get the graphic gore and violence. But it's not like the series doesn't deal with dark tones and violence. Wolverine has been slicing people up non stop in these flicks, so having a team led by him that kills bad guys in order to save the world like himself ain't that far off. The X-Men have never really had a serious sit down talk with Logan about how he can lay low on the killing with much effect, even though that's a big issue with Prof X.
If they make a film that has to deal with the heavier ramifications of members committing murder to villains or potential ones (be it preemptive or self defense) it wouldn't be out of range for the series imo. It's an interesting subject when dealing with powerful villains who can destroy the world regardless of the X title. Batman's explored the theme in TDK as does the Deadpool script, and even Big Hero 6 a bit. When they play the killing is wrong hand hand with Magneto the audience expects it cause he's looked at as a bad guy, but Logan gets a free pass with the X-Men most the time as Deadpool always likes to point out. UXF takes it to a whole other level and asks more questions. Obviously the X-Men shouldn't encourage killing but when it involves a character like Aoocalypse, that conversation should at least come up. Plenty of the X-Men have killed at some point in the books.
That said I'd prefer it be X-Force for it to stand out, expansion/character development and separate Logan from the main team. Shoving in too many characters to one property has been an issue. It should be recognized by featuring the more edgy characters of the X characters like the books do.Film wise It can also lead to an interesting story for future conflict between both teams.
As far as the rating, be it X-Force or X-Men we won't get the graphic gore and violence. But it's not like the series doesn't deal with dark tones and violence. Wolverine has been slicing people up non stop in these flicks, so having a team led by him that kills bad guys in order to save the world like himself ain't that far off. The X-Men have never really had a serious sit down talk with Logan about how he can lay low on the killing with much effect, even though that's a big issue with Prof X.
If they make a film that has to deal with the heavier ramifications of members committing murder to villains or potential ones (be it preemptive or self defense) it wouldn't be out of range for the series imo. It's an interesting subject when dealing with powerful villains who can destroy the world regardless of the X title. Batman's explored the theme in TDK as does the Deadpool script, and even Big Hero 6 a bit. When they play the killing is wrong hand hand with Magneto the audience expects it cause he's looked at as a bad guy, but Logan gets a free pass with the X-Men most the time as Deadpool always likes to point out. UXF takes it to a whole other level and asks more questions. Obviously the X-Men shouldn't encourage killing but when it involves a character like Aoocalypse, that conversation should at least come up. Plenty of the X-Men have killed at some point in the books.
That said I'd prefer it be X-Force for it to stand out, expansion/character development and separate Logan from the main team. Shoving in too many characters to one property has been an issue. It should be recognized by featuring the more edgy characters of the X characters like the books do.Film wise It can also lead to an interesting story for future conflict between both teams.
Last edited: