Are there some villains who just don't work on the Silver screen?

With the exception of really ridiculous guys like the hypno hustler.....no I don't think so. Just about any problem can be overcome, provided that they're willing to put the time & thought into it.

I'm with this, a villain is only as good/bad as the person writing them.

Case in point, even the mighty doom can come off as subpar.

and bankers like magneto and the joker could also be messed up in the wrong hands.

I think most villains could be tweaked to at least work in a group if not stand alone as threats.
 
Guys like Stilt Man and Paste Pot Pete (trapster) are possible, but not for a large roll.....just an opener, and a WTF moment?

Like .....the hero would have to be come on?!?! What are you doing, and defeat them easily.
 
Electro would only work if his costume in no way resembled its original comic book design. That lightning bolt mask is the stupidest looking thing I've ever seen, even by comic book standards.
 
Electro would only work if his costume in no way resembled its original comic book design. That lightning bolt mask is the stupidest looking thing I've ever seen, even by comic book standards.

electro is tricky, because litterally every costume they'd try to change him to has sucked. Part of his charm is that he looks like an idiot... but is deadly none the less.

if they made his "mask" be living electricity (same shape) when powered up, or a sleak, metal mask. It could work.
 
Yeah, that might be okay. A chrome mask might work, or like you said, actual electricity that makes a similar (though indefinite) shape, that could look really cool.
 
Some villains are charmingly ridiculous and so altering them for the screen so they are 'believable' is possible with good writing/design but would take away the only things we love about them. I wouldn't want to see The Kangaroo attempted, for example....

That said, I'm willing to watch any studio lose millions if it means putting MODOK on screen!!
 
Personally I kinda feel like people are starting to lose their imagination when they say "Oh you couldn't do this" or "That just wouldn't work", etc. I feel like you can do anything in a movie, even if it has a more real-world tone, it's still a fictional real world, where anything is possible. I think people underestimate the audience, and put unnecessary restraints on what people will and won't accept. I think if you do it with quality and care, people will buy into anything you sell them.

A Kirby inspired Galactus can be done. There are so many extremely talented and creative people out there, there's really no reason they couldn't bring that to life if they actually put in the effort instead of being afraid and playing it safe.

MODOK. Yes, he's a ridiculous looking character in the comics, but I don't think that makes him impossible to do. You could easily do something really creepy with him, and you don't necessarily have to shy away from him looking ridiculous. Go ahead and let there be some humor about it. Marvel characters always take shots at MODOK's appearance in the comics, why not bring that attitude to the films as well. People will be okay with him looking weird if the film acknowledges it as well.

I think the only villains who wouldn't work aren't because of their looks, but because they're just quality characters to begin with. Hypno Hustler, Typeface, Gamecock, Leapfrog, THOSE are villains you couldn't make work, even if you made them look awesome they're just lame concepts.
 
Kangis hard to do without completely changing his appearance..

Take this...

Iron-man-pose2.jpg


turn the red parts a dark purple, turn the yellow parts green...give him distinguishable facial features in the helmet...and there's your Kang movie costume.

also his son Marcus's version of the Scarlet Centurion armor

190268-114238-scarlet-centurion_large.jpg


with these colors would work.

250px-Kang_youngavengers5.JPG
 
Actually I think Kang would work as he is in that 3rd picture in a movie. Better than having him in a robot suit or crazy armor. I think his design is pretty cool as is. Of course they should alter it to make it look a bit more complicated and detailed, but I don't think they should do too much to change his general look if they put him film.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"