Batman Elimination Game: Round 23 - Most Significant Moment

[trustyside-kick]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 24
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 9 (-)
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 24
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 17 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 24
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8 (-)
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 25 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 17
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Fledermaus]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 24
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11 (-)
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 25
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

This one is tough. I'm having a hard time deciding what to vote against.

 

[Iceman]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 25 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 7 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 25
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

Yeah, these are all very significant moments for Bats.

 

[Mister J]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 25
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12 (+)
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 6 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 25
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 25
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 9
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 5 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 26 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Fledermaus]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 25
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 8 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 5
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 27 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Iceman]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 26 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 5
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 27
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[CrypticOne]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 4 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 27
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Mister J]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 12 (+)
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 3 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 27
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[JTStarkiller]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13 (+)
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 2 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 27
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[JTStarkiller]

In Identity Crisis. He then created Brother I and it was hijacked basically and misused. That is why Infinite Crisis occured.

I didn't think he ever found out in Identity Crisis. I remember Green Arrow saying something like, "he's a detective, he'll always have an idea." But that he didn't actually find out in that book.

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 1 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 28 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 18
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Fledermaus]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 8
The revelation of Hush's identity 0 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 28
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 19 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

I"m not sure when Bats found out about the mindwipe, but I just re-read "Crisis of Conscience" in JLA. And he definitly knew then.

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 7 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 29 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 19
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Ebil Gig]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 6 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 30 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 19
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Mister J]

I"m not sure when Bats found out about the mindwipe, but I just re-read "Crisis of Conscience" in JLA. And he definitly knew then.

That was my best guess, in CoC. Somewhere around JLA #115 or so.

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 13
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 7
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 5 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 30
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 20 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Fledermaus]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14 (+)
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 6 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 5
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 30
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 20 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 27
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 5 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 5
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 31 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 20
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Kraven]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 28 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 4 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 5
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 31
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 20
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Mister J]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 28
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 4
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 4 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 31
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 21 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[LEX]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 28
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 4
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 3 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 32 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 21
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Fledermaus]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 10 (-)
Bane breaking his back 28
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 4
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 3
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 32
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 22 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[Iceman]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 9 (-)
Bane breaking his back 29 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 4
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 3
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 32
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 22
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14

 

[CrypticOne]

The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 14
The death of Jason Todd 9
Bane breaking his back 30 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 3 (-)
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 12
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 3
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 32
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 22
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 14