Batman film Vs. Batman film

[returntovoid]

This is a thread to match up two Batman films against each other. I'll post the first match up in a while.

 

[returntovoid]

The Dark Knight Vs. Batman Returns:

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

 

[Ipodman]

The Dark Knight Vs. Batman Returns:

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

Yippeee

 

[returntovoid]

-Film: Batman Returns
-Director: Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine
-Main Villain: The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batmobile
-Batsuit: Batman Returns
-Gotham City: Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Returns

 

[theMan-Bat]

-Film: Batman Returns
-Director: Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batmobile
-Batsuit: Batman Returns
-Gotham City: Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Returns

 

[The Joker]

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

 

[akfj]

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

 

[ChocheTheHero]

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

 

[Cain]

-Film: The Dark Knight
-Director: Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Love Interest: Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batmobile
-Batsuit: Batman Returns
-Gotham City: Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight

 

[SuperFerret]

The Dark Knight Vs. Batman Returns:

-Film: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Director: Christopher Nolan or Tim Burton
-Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale or Michael Keaton
-Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough
-Main Villain: The Joker or The Penguin
-Side-Villain: Two-Face or Max Shreck
-Love Interest: Rachel Dawes or Catwoman/Selina Kyle
-James Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod or The Batmobile
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight or Batman Returns

Batman Returns
Neither
Neither
Gough
The Joke
Max Schreck
Catwoman
Oldman
Batmobile
Neither
Neither
Batman Returns

 

[TruerToTheCore]

Everything except bat-vehicle, love interest, batsuit and butler goes to TDK.

 

[returntovoid]

The second match up.

Batman: The Mask of Phantasm Vs. Batman Begins:

Film: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins
Director: Eric Radomski & Bruce Timm or Christopher Nolan
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy or Christian Bale
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr. or Michael Caine
Villain: The Joker or Ra's Al Ghul
Love Interest: Andrea Beaumont or Rachel Dawes
Batmobile: The Tumbler or The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins

 

[theMan-Bat]

Film: Batman Begins
Director: Christopher Nolan
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Christian Bale
Alfred: Michael Caine
Villain: Ra's Al Ghul
Love Interest: Rachel Dawes
Batmobile: The Tumbler
Batsuit: Batman Begins
Gotham City: Batman Begins

 

[returntovoid]

Film: Batman Begins
Director: Christopher Nolan
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy/Christian Bale Tied
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr.
Villain: The Joker/Ra's Al Ghul Tied
Love Interest: None
Batmobile: The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm

 

[akfj]

Film: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins
Director: Eric Radomski & Bruce Timm or Christopher Nolan
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy or Christian Bale
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr. or Michael Caine
Villain: The Joker or Ra's Al Ghul
Love Interest: Andrea Beaumont or Rachel Dawes
Batmobile: The Tumbler or The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm or Batman Begins

 

[The Joker]

Film: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Director: Eric Radomski & Bruce Timm
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr.
Villain: The Joker
Love Interest: Andrea Beaumont
Batmobile: The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm

 

[Doc Ock]

Film: The Mask of Phantasm
Director: Eric Radomski & Bruce Timm
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr.
Villain: The Joker
Love Interest: Rachel Dawes
Batmobile: The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm

 

[returntovoid]

The third match up.

Batman Begins Vs. The Dark Knight:

-Film: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Main Villain: Ra's Al Ghul or The Joker
-Side-Villain: Scarecrow or Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Tumbler or The Batpod
-Batsuit: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Gotham City: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight

 

[theMan-Bat]

-Film: Batman Begins
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Tumbler
-Batsuit: Batman Begins
-Gotham City: Batman Begins
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Begins

 

[returntovoid]

-Film: Batman Begins
-Main Villain: Ra's Al Ghul
-Side Villain: Scarecrow
-Bat-Vehicle: The Tumbler
-Batsuit: Batman Begins
-Gotham City: Batman Begins
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Begins

 

[TheFuture]

-Film: Batman Begins
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Tumbler
-Batsuit: Batman Begins
-Gotham City: Batman Begins
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Begins

 

[david icke]

-Film: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Main Villain: Ra's Al Ghul or The Joker
-Side-Villain: Scarecrow or Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Tumbler or The Batpod
-Batsuit: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Gotham City: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight
-Action/Fight Scenes: Batman Begins or The Dark Knight

 

[Cain]

The second match up.

Batman: The Mask of Phantasm Vs. Batman Begins:

Film: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Director: Eric Radomski & Bruce Timm
Batman/Bruce Wayne: Kevin Conroy
Alfred: Efrem Zimbalist Jr.
Villain: Ra's Al Ghul
Love Interest: Andrea Beaumont
Batmobile: The Batmobile
Batsuit: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm
Gotham City: Batman: The Mask of Phantasm

The third match up.

Batman Begins Vs. The Dark Knight:

-Film: The Dark Knight
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight
-Gotham City: Batman Begins
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight

Oh yeah I think Nolan did a better job directing on the second one than he did on the first. The performances from all the players came across more genuinely the second time around. Where as in the first people like Murphy, Wilkinson and Holmes' performance seemed unbalanced and forced to me partly cause of the directing.

 

[The Joker]

-Film: The Dark Knight
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: The Batpod
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight
-Gotham City: Batman Begins
-Action/Fight Scenes:The Dark Knight

 

[Doctor Octopus]

-Film: The Dark Knight
-Main Villain: The Joker
-Side-Villain: Two-Face
-Bat-Vehicle: Tumbler
-Batsuit: The Dark Knight
-Gotham City: The Dark Knight
-Action/Fight Scenes: The Dark Knight - Nothing tops the the armored car and Joker truck sequence