Brave and the Bold Casting Thread

He'd be a great batman of zur-en-arrh if anything
latest
Yeah there is a certain type of insanity Morrison's Batman has that I feel Gyllenhaal might be good at capturing, even tho he's not really my favorite and I'd rather have Pace who I think can also play that intense when given the opportunity.
 
If this new WB/DC has the balls to cast an out gay man as Batman then I'm all for Pace, something tells me most of their diversity casting will still stick to supporting roles or race swaps.
 
If this new WB/DC has the balls to cast an out gay man as Batman then I'm all for Pace, something tells me most of their diversity casting will still stick to supporting roles or race swaps.
I really don't think Gunn would care about the actor's sexuality at all. "We can't cast a gay actor for Batman" seems like the old style Hollywood exec mentality that seems to be completely against Gunn's line of thinking.
 
I agree about Gunn and as much as I would like to believe he has full authority...we've been down this road too many times.
 
Martin Sensmeier (Westworld, Wind River, The Magnificent Seven, 1883) for Batman. Age 37. He's actually 32 in these pictures, so he looks a little older now. But I wanted to use pictures from this photoshoot because of how Bruce Wayne-y his hair looks. He's in good physical shape (he was going to play Jim Thorpe in a biopic Angelina Jolie was making, but I guess that fell through, because it never happened). He seems like someone that could pack on a lot of muscle.

MARTIN_MFP

MARTIN_MFP
 
I really don't think Gunn would care about the actor's sexuality at all. "We can't cast a gay actor for Batman" seems like the old style Hollywood exec mentality that seems to be completely against Gunn's line of thinking.

I agree about Gunn and as much as I would like to believe he has full authority...we've been down this road too many times.

Pace apparently goes "both ways" like Ezra Miller. And to my knowledge, Miller's role (as the Flash) hasn't been adversely affected by that particular aspect of his life — just everything else! :funny:

So, it's really just Pace's age that might present an issue, which would be unfortunate, as he really does look (and sound) the part.
 
I agree about Gunn and as much as I would like to believe he has full authority...we've been down this road too many times.

He's co-CEO of a new studio and DC has never been its own studio like that I don't think. I'm pretty sure that hasn't been the case in the past with heads of DC.

And this slate so far is pretty him-driven with characters like Damian and The Authority and Creature Commandos being used, but you're still right. We'll have to see how it goes and especially how they react to the reception they receive when stuff actually releases.
 
He's co-CEO of a new studio and DC has never been its own studio like that I don't think. I'm pretty sure that hasn't been the case in the past with heads of DC.

And this slate so far is pretty him-driven with characters like Damian and The Authority and Creature Commandos being used, but you're still right. We'll have to see how it goes and especially how they react to the reception they receive when stuff actually releases.
I kinda think that, even if you don't buy the fact that Gunn and Safran have 100% authority over DC, the casting over a character as important as Batman is something that neither of them would budge on especially if the rationale to reject it is "We can't have an LGBTQ actor". You could say I'm giving them too much credit but that's something that I do believe they'd fight very hard for to have it go their way.
 
I kinda think that, even if you don't buy the fact that Gunn and Safran have 100% authority over DC, the casting over a character as important as Batman is something that neither of them would budge on especially if the rationale to reject it is "We can't have an LGBTQ actor". You could say I'm giving them too much credit but that's something that I do believe they'd fight very hard for to have it go their way.

Oh without a doubt. I guess I was going on a tangent and just talking in general, but nothing tells me they'd be against a LGBTQ performer as Batman. If Pace is the right pick in their eyes, or whomever, that aspect of them as a person outside of the work won't matter.
 
It would be wonderful to see another LGBTQ+ performer following in the footsteps of Kevin Conroy. And in live-action to boot.

Sadly, I don't think we're there yet.
 
Pace apparently goes "both ways" like Ezra Miller. And to my knowledge, Miller's role (as the Flash) hasn't been adversely affected by that particular aspect of his life — just everything else! :funny:

So, it's really just Pace's age that might present an issue, which would be unfortunate, as he really does look (and sound) the part.

Just to be clear Pace is married to Matthew Foley (who works for Thom Browne which is why you'll typically see Lee in Thom Browne clothing on red carpets.) The goes "both ways" stuff was the way he responded to that question early on, as well as telling reporters it was none of their business and he was there to talk about the work. He's pretty much quit dodging it these days and I respect him a ton for doing so, we can probably thank his friend Matthew Bomer for that...
 
It would be wonderful to see another LGBTQ+ performer following in the footsteps of Kevin Conroy. And in live-action to boot.

Sadly, I don't think we're there yet.
He reminds me a lot of Kevin Conroy in a lot of ways. Not just because of the LGBTQ thing, but because of his Juilliard training, his baritone voice, and seeing a lot of his interviews he has a very similar demeanor as he did, not to mention the baritone voice. Truly believe he may be the only actor that'd succesfully pull off that type of Batman in live action while also giving it his own unique spin.
 
Just to be clear Pace is married to Matthew Foley (who works for Thom Browne which is why you'll typically see Lee in Thom Browne clothing on red carpets.) The goes "both ways" stuff was the way he responded to that question early on, as well as telling reporters it was none of their business and he was there to talk about the work. He's pretty much quit dodging it these days and I respect him a ton for doing so, we can probably thank his friend Matthew Bomer for that...

I was mostly going off of information, where Pace not only referred to having been in relationships with both men and women, but also self described as "queer." Not sure how his marriage to Foley negates any of that. Now, if he was being disingenuous with his remarks for whatever reason, fair enough; but I can't really speak to that.

Whatever the case, my point still stands: Miller's sexuality hasn't jeopardized his role as the Flash. Why should Pace — a considerably more accomplished actor — be any different, especially when he comes with far less baggage?
 
Martin Sensmeier (Westworld, Wind River, The Magnificent Seven, 1883) for Batman. Age 37. He's actually 32 in these pictures, so he looks a little older now. But I wanted to use pictures from this photoshoot because of how Bruce Wayne-y his hair looks. He's in good physical shape (he was going to play Jim Thorpe in a biopic Angelina Jolie was making, but I guess that fell through, because it never happened). He seems like someone that could pack on a lot of muscle.

MARTIN_MFP

MARTIN_MFP
I like his look. Can't really speak on his acting though, since I don't remember him from Westworld. I will say that I do think for this incarnation there may be a slight chance a PoC actor gets cast, since it'd be an immediate way to set themselves aside from Pattinson. Haven't seen many PoC suggestions though, and I can't really think of many off the top of my head.

Speaking of Westworld, I saw some Brandon Sklennar of 1923 suggested on Twitter. I didn't really pay much attention to it since I saw some pics of him clean shaven in red carpets and thought he looked a bit ridiculous, but then I saw his small appearance on Westworld and I can kinda see it now:

2023-03-06 23_45_25-FlixTor.png


a3958bb2a374ba226253e55819d8cdad27109508.gifv


He's 30 but looks like he could play older and more mature (in fact you could've told me he was 40 based on these images and I'd have believed it lol) he seems to have a decent enough voice, he's 6'2. Only thing is that I feel he'd have to bulk up a lot to be fully convincing as this type of Batman, but I guess it's not unreasonable to expect that DCU actors will probably go through the same MCU type of transformations.

Not really into it, feels like a better Hal Jordan or something, but it's an option if they really wanna go younger I guess. Wouldn't surprise me to see him in contention for Superman either actually, though he doesn't feel quite right for that either. Something about his eyes.
 
I like his look. Can't really speak on his acting though, since I don't remember him from Westworld. I will say that I do think for this incarnation there may be a slight chance a PoC actor gets cast, since it'd be an immediate way to set themselves aside from Pattinson. Haven't seen many PoC suggestions though, and I can't really think of many off the top of my head.

Speaking of Westworld, I saw some Brandon Sklennar of 1923 suggested on Twitter. I didn't really pay much attention to it since I saw some pics of him clean shaven in red carpets and thought he looked a bit ridiculous, but then I saw his small appearance on Westworld and I can kinda see it now:

View attachment 62860


a3958bb2a374ba226253e55819d8cdad27109508.gifv


He's 30 but looks like he could play older and more mature (in fact you could've told me he was 40 based on these images and I'd have believed it lol) he seems to have a decent enough voice, he's 6'2. Only thing is that I feel he'd have to bulk up a lot to be fully convincing as this type of Batman, but I guess it's not unreasonable to expect that DCU actors will probably go through the same MCU type of transformations.

Not really into it, feels like a better Hal Jordan or something, but it's an option if they really wanna go younger I guess. Wouldn't surprise me to see him in contention for Superman either actually, though he doesn't feel quite right for that either. Something about his eyes.

Sklennar's got a whole different vibe on 1923, where he initially portrays a big game hunter (you've gotta watch the show to see what I'm saying). He has a somewhat more athletic build now as well. But yeah, a character like Hal suits him better.
 
Last edited:
Sklennar's got a whole different vibe on 1923, where he initially portrays a big game hunter (you've gotta watch the show to see what I'm saying). He has a somewhat more athletic build now as well. But yeah, a character like Hal suits him better.
I just watched some clips of the show and I get what you're saying. His athletic build is good but I feel that, considering the fact that Pattinson is already a Batman with that type of build, it'd be better if DCU Batman had a really distinct look from that, plus I think it'd kinda help him to look more imposing overall and be easier to sell as this Batman that hangs out with gods and stuff; that's part of why I'm extremely sold on Pace right now as well, he's a 180 degree turn from Robert but in a way that fits the character and what they presumably want to do with this version.
If they did cast him I'd be in a very "wait and see" mode since he doesn't really convince me right now, but depending on how much they open the casting call for this he'll probably at least audition.
Weirdly enough seeing his clips I also get the sense that if Gunn was making the first GoTG now he might've cast him, reminds me somewhat of Chris Pratt in some ways.
 
R.c2f15c8b45214bb1c3715954c567f94c
R.c2f15c8b45214bb1c3715954c567f94c
TreyTucker.jpeg Trey-Tucker-5.jpg


Here's a name that got mentioned in the Superman thread and that might be worth taking a look here as well. Trey Tucker.

To call this guy an unknown would be an understatement, but this is the sort of guy I'd expect them to go with if they're intending to go for a Batman in his 30s.

He's only ever had a recurring role in a Starz TV show, and he's only been in really cheap B-movies, but he's got a great look, he's 6'3, and to this guy's credit, I feel there's some potential with his acting:

He seems to have some charisma (tho he plays a total goofball in this)



But also some degree of dramatic potential.


R.1ca7daa5e7137c1eb576244b4d01f4a6

R.1ca7daa5e7137c1eb576244b4d01f4a6
The only thing is that I cannot find what this guy's actual age is. Some sites have him listed as 38, others have him listed at 33. If he's 33, then yeah he's the perfect encapsulation of what I'd expect them to go for. Some dude that looks just like comic Batman that hasn't had anything even remotely notable yet.

He also seems to be friends with Gary Oldman, for some bizarre reason, and shares the same manager (who only represents him and Paul Hogan), so sooner or later those connections might pay off.
 
Last edited:
I bet they're not gonna cast a B or C lister like Jensen Ackles or some other TV actor. Keaton, Bale, Affleck and Pattinson were already pretty well known..
 
I bet they're not gonna cast a B or C lister like Jensen Ackles or some other TV actor. Keaton, Bale, Affleck and Pattinson were already pretty well known..
Things change a bit when you're trying to lock an actor up for ten years and intend on them appearing across different media (movies, television, animation, video games, etc).

Not saying you can't get an A-lister who'd be willing to do all that, but I'd say it narrows the pool quite a bit.
 
I bet they're not gonna cast a B or C lister like Jensen Ackles or some other TV actor. Keaton, Bale, Affleck and Pattinson were already pretty well known..
Kilmer was a huge name too thanks to Top Gun & Tombstone (and had a role in Mann's HEAT the same year as Forever), and Clooney was a huge name thanks to ER and had just done a film written by Tarantino. West is the only Bat-actor who wasn't a big name prior to being cast, so I can't really see that trend breaking.

Things change a bit when you're trying to lock an actor up for ten years and intend on them appearing across different media (movies, television, animation, video games, etc).

Not saying you can't get an A-lister who'd be willing to do all that, but I'd say it narrows the pool quite a bit.
Cumberbatch was a big name who wound up signing onto a huge number of projects with Marvel while still being able to do smaller work on the sides, so I can see them going for someone in that level of fame. If they get Gyllenhaal, the job security of 10 years of Batman would actually encourage him to do a smaller film again in-between haha
 
I bet they're not gonna cast a B or C lister like Jensen Ackles or some other TV actor. Keaton, Bale, Affleck and Pattinson were already pretty well known..
Ì agree, which is why I don't think they'll go for an actor in their 30s; they'd genuinely have to look for an unknown to find someone that 100% fits in that age range.
 
I can think of many actors in their 30s who would be a good Batman
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"