Comics Can we shake up the X-Men rosters a bit please!

[Colossal Spoons]

I think Firestar, Aurora and Hepzibah already checked into limbo so you're free from them at least for now

The Starjammers should be X-Limbo. Hepzibah and Ch'od can go rescue Raza from that symbiote that lives in him and they can go away. Hooray.

 

[katie_girl09]

X-Men(drop the "Legacy"): Rogue, Gambit, Xavier, Havok, Beast, Rachel, Korvus, Bishop

As much as I like "Romy", I would love to see Rogue and Gambit in different books for a while.

 

[Manic]

I want to know how exactly Bishop would get around to rejoining the X-Men in Spoons' world.

 

[UraniaChang]

Apologize and admit he was wrong in witch-hunting the kid, I'm sure the X-men can understand why he was so desperate in changing the future and, maybe not forgive, but relent enough for him to rejoin them.

 

[Havok83]

I want to know how exactly Bishop would get around to rejoining the X-Men in Spoons' world.

clones...I hear they are all the rage

 

[Colossal Spoons]

I want to know how exactly Bishop would get around to rejoining the X-Men in Spoons' world.

Nobody's beyond forgiveness. And Bishop has a damn good reason for doing what he's doing. I could see all this being smoothed over with a really good apology.

 

[Manic]

That would have to be one damn good apology. He's attacked the X-Men and their students several times, all without ever actually saying why he needs to kill the girl.

 

[Havok83]

That would have to be one damn good apology. He's attacked the X-Men and their students several times, all without ever actually saying why he needs to kill the girl.

Not to mention that he's spent so many years with the X-men and didnt trust any of them with the information he had. He's shown that he will kill them if necesary to achieve his goal. Its ironic that he came to this timeline to stop a traitor from within the X-men, but thats exactly what he's become.

 

[Colossal Spoons]

We're talking about the same X-Men who actually voted on whether to allow Mystique into the X-Men. Yeah, Mystique

 

[Havok83]

We're talking about the same X-Men who actually voted on whether to allow Mystique into the X-Men. Yeah, Mystique

haha and looked how well that turned out for them

 

[UraniaChang]

Not to mention that he's spent so many years with the X-men and didnt trust any of them with the information he had. He's shown that he will kill them if necesary to achieve his goal. Its ironic that he came to this timeline to stop a traitor from within the X-men, but thats exactly what he's become.

He grew up in a concentration camp, that affects his ability/wiillingness to trust people, and he probably even viewed the X-Men as too weak in their method.

He obviously puts the "future" as his priority, anything else falls behind, but he isn't a bad person, otherwise he wouldn't help with the 198 trapped in the abandoned base, cause he had a fair amount of chance dying should he fail.

 

[Jake Cassidy]

I wish Cable would just kill Bishop and get it over with.

 

[Havok83]

I wish Cable would just kill Bishop and get it over with.

you and me both. Bishop has been trying to kill him and the girl for almost 10 years now in comic book time. Bishop must really be annoying at this point

 

[Jake Cassidy]

10 years? He's pretty ****in' useless, isn't he?

 

[Havok83]

10 years? He's pretty ****in' useless, isn't he?

Its been less time for Bishop as he keeps using a time device to jump but for Cable its been close to 10 years as he's watched that baby grow up and has been dodging Bishop for about that long now

 

[Manic]

Bishop is taking so long to kill that kid, she's already learned how to kill stuff herself.

 

[Colossal Spoons]

I don't see Bishop as a "bad guy" in this whole mess. If he and Cable could get it through their heads that Hope doesn't necessarily have to grow up to be a destroyer or messiah; they can leave her alone and be friends again.

 

[Specter313]

But considering how bull-headed both of them can be, that's a very hard thing for either of them to admit.

 

[Jennifer Walters]

Bishop will never be able to rejoin the X-Men. He's done far too much. They'd be better to let Wolverine gut him, Cyclops blast his head off, or Cable to put a bullet between his eyes.

He has much of a right to be on the X-Men as Mystique now.

 

[Manic]

Hope should kill him. She's spent her entire life running from him. Maybe the next time he sees her, she's old and hardened enough to fight back.

 

[Havok83]

I don't see Bishop as a "bad guy" in this whole mess. If he and Cable could get it through their heads that Hope doesn't necessarily have to grow up to be a destroyer or messiah; they can leave her alone and be friends again.

I dont think Cable is the one with an issue here. Hope can grow up to be whatever she wants but that wont happen if she doesnt get the chance. And she wont get a chance if Bishop had been succesful in killing her. At this point, its 100% personal for Cable. This girl is his daughter. He's loved and cared for her since she was a baby and its about some man trying to kill his child. He may have gotten involved for different reasons, but its evolved into a father doing whatever it takes to protect his daughter

 

[Jennifer Walters]

Which will be every bit of bizzare if said little girl becomes a placeholder for Jean Grey when she comes back, but that's outside of the subject.

The fact of the matter is Bishop tried to killed a little baby like it was Apocalypse. He's officially gone far past the hero stage at this part.

 

[Manic]

I'd still like to know how exactly this girl is destined to both save the world and kill millions of people. In all this time, neither Bishop nor Cable has bothered to explain it. Maybe knowing Bishop's story would allow me to sympathize for him instead of viewing him as some baby-killing maniac. And if it's some bullcrap that could be changed simply by bringing her up differently (ie. going back in time and telling a notorious dictator never to get into politics when they're younger), then maybe Bishop really does deserve a bullet between the eyes for being so stupid.

 

[Havok83]

I'd still like to know how exactly this girl is destined to both save the world and kill millions of people. In all this time, neither Bishop nor Cable has bothered to explain it. Maybe knowing Bishop's story would allow me to sympathize for him instead of viewing him as some baby-killing maniac. And if it's some bullcrap that could be changed simply by bringing her up differently (ie. going back in time and telling a notorious dictator never to get into politics when they're younger), then maybe Bishop really does deserve a bullet between the eyes for being so stupid.

Cable doesnt know as it wasnt from his timeline. Bishop however does know about the girl but hasnt exactly been clear about what happens. What I dont get is, what caused his dark future. Was it Onslaught or Hope? This is a big hole in the story for me

 

[Specter313]

I'd still like to know how exactly this girl is destined to both save the world and kill millions of people. In all this time, neither Bishop nor Cable has bothered to explain it. Maybe knowing Bishop's story would allow me to sympathize for him instead of viewing him as some baby-killing maniac. And if it's some bullcrap that could be changed simply by bringing her up differently (ie. going back in time and telling a notorious dictator never to get into politics when they're younger), then maybe Bishop really does deserve a bullet between the eyes for being so stupid.

Hmm, was that Bishop mini supposed to explain that for him? Well, if it was, Marvel certainly didn't care for people to read it considering that they let Stroman draw it.