World Eliminations Ten (Round One)

[Specter313]

Millar -
Claremont +

1. Chris Claremont 15
2. Mike Carey 10
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 11
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 11
8. Peter A. David 19

Remember to judge on their entire bodies of X-work, not just recent material.

 

[Kira]

Remember to judge on their entire bodies of X-work, not just recent material.

X-Treme X-Men.

I can't get over that.

 

[Iceman]

Mark Millar +
Mike Carey -

1. Chris Claremont 15
2. Mike Carey 9
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 11
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 19

The minus points are already impossible to allocate

 

[Darren Daring]

Davis +
Claremont -

1. Chris Claremont 14
2. Mike Carey 9
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 12
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 19

 

[Iceman]

Chris Claremont +
Mike Carey -

1. Chris Claremont 15
2. Mike Carey 8
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 11
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 19

 

[Darren Daring]

Chris Claremont -
Davis +

1. Chris Claremont 14
2. Mike Carey 8
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 19

You stole a point from Davis in your last post there

 

[Iceman]

You stole a point from Davis in your last post there

You pass the test. You can keep Burkina Faso

 

[LEX]

Chris Claremont -
David +

1. Chris Claremont 13
2. Mike Carey 8
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[CrypticOne]

+ Chris Claremont
- Mike Carey

1. Chris Claremont 14
2. Mike Carey 7
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 13
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Iceman]

+ Lobdell
- Mike Carey

1. Chris Claremont 14
2. Mike Carey 6
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Darren Daring]

+ Davis
- Claremont

1. Chris Claremont 13
2. Mike Carey 6
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 14
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Specter313]

Davis -
Claremont +

1. Chris Claremont 14
2. Mike Carey 6
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 10
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Jennifer Walters]

Claremont +
Vaughn - (Runaways forgiveth me!)

1. Chris Claremont 15
2. Mike Carey 6
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Ebil Gig]

Claremont +
Carey -

1. Chris Claremont 16
2. Mike Carey 5
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[Iceman]

Claremont +
Carey -

1. Chris Claremont 17
2. Mike Carey 4
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 20

 

[squeekness]

David +
Carey -

1. Chris Claremont 17
2. Mike Carey 3
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 21

I'm sorry, but Milligan had to go for screwing up Gambit.

 

[CrypticOne]

+ Chris Claremont
- Mike Carey

1. Chris Claremont 18
2. Mike Carey 2
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 14
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 21

 

[Kira]

+ Lobdell
- Mike Carey

1. Chris Claremont 18
2. Mike Carey 1
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 15
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 21

 

[Iceman]

+ Lobdell
- Mike Carey

1. Chris Claremont 18
2. Mike Carey 0
3. Ed Brubaker 11
4. Scott Lobdell 16
5. Alan Davis 13
6. Brian K. Vaughn 9
7. Mark Millar 12
8. Peter A. David 21

 

[Ebil Gig]

+ Claremont
- Brubaker

1. Chris Claremont 19
2. Ed Brubaker 10
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 13
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 12
7. Peter A. David 21

 

[Specter313]

David +
Davis -

1. Chris Claremont 19
2. Ed Brubaker 10
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 12
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 12
7. Peter A. David 22

 

[Ebil Gig]

Claremont +
Brubaker -

1. Chris Claremont 20
2. Ed Brubaker 9
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 12
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 12
7. Peter A. David 22

 

[Ebil Gig]

Claremont +
Brubaker -

1. Chris Claremont 21
2. Ed Brubaker 8
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 12
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 12
7. Peter A. David 22

 

[Mister J]

Claremont +
Alan Davis -

1. Chris Claremont 22
2. Ed Brubaker 8
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 11
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 12
7. Peter A. David 22

 

[Specter313]

David +
Millar -

1. Chris Claremont 22
2. Ed Brubaker 8
3. Scott Lobdell 16
4. Alan Davis 11
5. Brian K. Vaughn 9
6. Mark Millar 11
7. Peter A. David 23