Linderman has to be Claire's father

[fletch1076]

As I posted in a different thread, Linderman has a connection with every hero so far. Every hero except Claire. In a TV guide interview, the creator of heroes said we will be surprised to find out who Claire's real farther is.

 

[3 Dev Adam]

Now tell us who dies.

 

[AssMan]

I made a thread with the interview

 

[Eros]

Yea I think he is her real father to.

 

[Avalanche]

Well, Linderman is probably connected with HRG, in which case he's connected to Claire.

But I wouldn't rule it out. We're supposed to be very shocked by the revelation after all.

 

[Specter313]

My guess? Papa Petrelli. In interviews, the creators have vehemently denied that they will ever have Claire and Peter hook up, and what better reason against that than to have them be half-siblings?

Plus, everyone is saying Linderman since he's the first mystery guy to come to mind, but the creators say it will be a huge shock, and Linderman is too obvious.

 

[Abaddon]

That was my first thought, but Papa Petrelli is dead

 

[The_Raven]

My guess? Papa Petrelli. In interviews, the creators have vehemently denied that they will ever have Claire and Peter hook up, and what better reason against that than to have them be half-siblings?

Plus, everyone is saying Linderman since he's the first mystery guy to come to mind, but the creators say it will be a huge shock, and Linderman is too obvious.

I think you're on to something.

I don't think Linderman is Claire's dad.

Step-sister to Nathan/Peter sounds right. Pops Petrelli had his ties to Linderman....it works for me.

HRG could very well know all this. maybe that's why he was all "RAPTAPTAP" in the hospital when Claire and Peter were talking. He didn't want them to get too close.

 

[Specter313]

That was my first thought, but Papa Petrelli is dead

Doesn't mean it couldn't revealed through a flashback or photo or something. He doesn't need to be alive now since he would have fathered her in the past.

 

[3 Dev Adam]

I think Linderman is Uluru, and that makes Claire... Ulurina?

 

[Mysterio]

My guess? Papa Petrelli. In interviews, the creators have vehemently denied that they will ever have Claire and Peter hook up, and what better reason against that than to have them be half-siblings?

what better reason than statutory rape? she's in high school.

HRG will be her biological father. heck, the guy had his wife mindwiped repeatedly.

 

[Felix Fangor]

I think Claire's father will be Claude...but it's supposed to be really shocking when that's revealed...so maybe it's one of the least obvious people.

 

[Omega214]

didnt it say that its someone we are familiar with?

Linderman isnt a familiar character, he's still very much a mystery. Im thinking Nathan Petrelli

 

[He-Man]

didnt it say that its someone we are familiar with?

Linderman isnt a familiar character, he's still very much a mystery. Im thinking Nathan Petrelli

I was kind of thinking the same thing but wasn't sure of Nathan's age . Claire is supposed to be 17 or so ?

 

[Lurk]

Along the same lines, I thought Peter might be the father. I really don't believe this is the most likely outcome, but the writers have set up the two for some kind of relationship and she's too young to date him. I think they've already confirmed he's not her brother, but I'd have to find the interview. Then again, Peter is probaby way too young - how old is he?

 

[Omega214]

how funny would it be if Hiro was her father, after travelling back in time and meeting her mother....

kinda like Fry being his own grandfather in futurama

 

[Crev-3]

I was kind of thinking the same thing but wasn't sure of Nathan's age . Claire is supposed to be 17 or so ?

Actually Claire is 15. And I'm also thinking it's Nate. Meaning Peter is her uncle.

 

[Mysterio]

1 - HRG was "working" with Claire's mother, correct?
2 - They had some type of relationship (in any sense of the word)
3 - HRG obviously cares a great deal about Claire.
4 - We know Claire is adopted.
5 - We know HRG has his wife's mind wiped repeatedly.
6 - Claire's real father is supposed to be a surprise/shock.

What's more surprising than to find out HRG is really her father? Think of the conflict that creates. What better way to explain a daughter from someone else than to erase your wife's memory and say, "honey, don't you remember we adopted her? here are the papers!"

 

[Maniacbob]

Nah that would be lame
Thats really just copping out
Its gotta be something deeper more shocking
Her adopted father being her real father just isnt cool
In fact if the HRG was her father I might just stop watching
That would be the show dying a quick painful death at the height of its life

 

[AssMan]

This is crazy speculation here but if we are supposed to be shocked with who Claires father is what if Nathan is her father ? We know he likes to sleep around with women. He could have met Claires mother before the whole congressman thing & Claires mother could have been in a similiar situation to how Jessica & Niki was when she met Nathan. Also if it was publically known that Nathan slept around with women & had a daughter it could hurt his public image & would create drama between Nathan, & Peter & their mother.

 

[3 Dev Adam]

Micah is Claire's father. THAT would be shocking.

 

[Felix Fangor]

New theory:


Linderman is the name Peter Petrelli's FUTURE SELF goes by after borrowing Hiro Nakamura's powers.

That could mean Peter Petrelli will turn evil.

 

[fletch1076]

Wow, I think you guys are really starting to reach now. Everyone believes Nathen because he sleeps around. Nathen was never a cheater until after his wife's accident. He isn't some playboy, he's a man with needs damit.

 

[Lurk]

What if Linderman is actually Lender-Man since he seems to be lending money to everyone?! What if he's actually Hiro's father?! The lady blackmailing Nathan on Linderman's behalf at the hotel was Ms. Nakamura, I believe. That must be it.

 

[Demon Within]

Nathan

Edit: or HRG with another woman who he chose so this could happen.