I thought it was great last year for the first time since Madden 05. After that it was as if EA wasnt even trying. There was ZERO emotion to the game. No atmosphere. The presentation was non existent. After a handfull of games, the title became stale. For some odd ass reason EA refused to take a cue from 2K(arguably the best sports title ever) and incorporate what made that title so much fun(Sports center type presentation, half time shows, post game shows, weekly wrap up shows etc etc) up until last years Madden. With this years title, they havent really advanced anything they set up in last years game. Its as tho they took half the year off, and focused the rest on making the game more casual.