More details on alt. endings!

[The Ones]

GUYS I'M NEW HERE. SORRY THIS IS OFF-TOPIC A BIT, BUT CAN ANY1 ACTUALLY TELL ME HOW 2 MAKE SOME1 REALISE THAT X3 WAS GOOD?? SORRY AGAIN 4 AN OFF-TOPIC POST. OH, AND THANX 4 THE SPOILER!!

Your first problem is that X-3 was crap, so you will have a tough job.

 

[chaseter]

^X3 wasn't crap...it was ok.

 

[La_She-Beast]

^that's the problem, it was just ok.

 

[MoPlaYa]

The Wolverine one made no sense really, as Wolverine had found a home with the X-Men.

But yes, the Beast and Rogue ones should have been these, not the ones we got.

I agree

 

[Snikt]

The Wolverine ending is fine, but depressing. I liked the original ending because it finally showed that he found a family and a place where he belongs

 

[The Ones]

The Wolverine ending is fine, but depressing. I liked the original ending because it finally showed that he found a family and a place where he belongs

How dare you give the X-mansion a bad name. Wolverine belongs in hell

 

[_BB_]

How dare you give the X-mansion a bad name. Wolverine belongs in hell

BLASPHEMY!!

 

[Halcohol]

The big problem I have with the fact that the bar scene was removed is that it takes Wolverine back to the true essence of his character. He's NOT one of the foundations of the mansion. He's NOT one of the leaders of the team. He's a loner, and especially now that his presence is not utterly necessary to the survival of his teammates, he's off doing his own thing.

Someone else said it best in a review of why Whedon's Astonishing X-Men was so good: because Whedon understood that Wolverine is at his best when he's used sparingly. Wolverine is a great character when used in small doses. That's how he retains the qualities most central to his character.

The movie-version of Wolverine was screwed up from the beginning of the franchise, but I don't really see that Singer had much else of a choice. Wolverine IS the most well-known X-Man and his status as an outsider made him an ideal vehicle through which to first view the universe.

This ending would have righted all the wrongs made in the trilogy regarding his place on the team.

Ah well.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Affirmative Commander... oops my bad, that was my star wars side talking.

-sighs- when will we see these deleted scenes?

 

[Halcohol]

Affirmative Commander... oops my bad, that was my star wars side talking.

....what?

-sighs- when will we see these deleted scenes?

Sooooon... 5 days or so

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

....what?


Sooooon... 5 days or so

I love yur avvy.

I wish Wolverine went back to his old place...where he belongs

 

[Halcohol]

Why thank you. I HAD been hoping that X3 would give us at least a good minute or so of iced-up Bobby from which hundreds of beautiful avatars could be made... alas.

Ever notice how all we do is b_tch about the movie? Ah well. It could have been grand.

 

[PeRfEcT_StOrM]

I got this from another forum, from (in my eyes) a reliable source:

hmmm i guess a little storm is cool in that one.

 

[ThE_PhOeNiX]

Why thank you. I HAD been hoping that X3 would give us at least a good minute or so of iced-up Bobby from which hundreds of beautiful avatars could be made... alas.

Ever notice how all we do is b_tch about the movie? Ah well. It could have been grand.

Its true. The movie could have been so much worse. We should be gratefull... and still think Ratner sucks.