most accurate spidey comic 2 movie transfer

[spider-neil]

which was the most accurately portrayed item/person from the spidey movies

also give marks out of ten for the below
10 - perfect representation
0 - nothing like the comic at all

strength
spider-sense
web swinging
wall crawing
speed
agility
wise cracks
peter parker
mary jane
supporting cast
villans

 

[spider-neil]

I may as well start

strength - 3
spider-sense - 5
web swinging - 10
wall crawing - 10
speed - 7
agility - 5
wise cracks - 2
peter parker - 9
mary jane - 5
supporting cast - 10
villans - 5

 

[SpideyZERO]

strength - 7
spider-sense - 5
web swinging - 10
wall crawing - 10
speed - 7
agility - 7
wise cracks -3
peter parker - 8
mary jane - 3
supporting cast - 9
villans - 6

 

[Mr Jide]

3 for all categories.

 

[Eggyman]

I find this hard to do -- Spider-Man's powers, the supporting cast, the villains, everything, differ greatly from comic to comic, writer to writer, and artist to artist. I don't mean to be awkward, sorry.

 

[Harry Goblin]

i didnt think the characters were as close to comic book as they could have ben. i mean like harry was done great imo, rosemary harris was brilliant, but mj? man nothing like the comic imo. also i dont think topher was good at being like eddie brock but to me i was fine with it because he was entertainint. isnt that what actors are supposed to do anyway? but stuff like dock ock, i didnt like.

i couild live with everything they did in the movies tho but im most dissapointed in teh costumes. green goblin was so off, even tho i liked it sometimes i felt it was too off and so i have mixed feelings when i actually watch the movie. dock ock was decent. sandman u dont have much to work with. new goblin to me was a good change. i mean it looked more suitable to me but i still think the mask needs work. venom to me had the best costume. he had almost everything the comic did except the long tongue which wasnt in it at first and the webs which i liked. basically costuems = bad

 

[OcStat]

i picked agility in the poll.

the burning building scene in sm1 and the crane scene in sm3...those really show off the way spidey can move.

 

[Kirk Langstrom]

Supporting cast. Especially JJJ.

 

[DACrowe]

Supporting cast. Harris, Simmons and Franco being t he stand outs. You can also lump Norman Osborn and Dafoe into this category too.

 

[*ANTHONY*]

Supporting Cast. Especially JJ. Think about it. HE looks exactly like JJ is supposed to look. He sounds and acts like it, too. He deserves a LOT of credit.

 

[Web-Head408]

strength-6
spider-sense-9
web swinging-10
wall crawing-10
speed-7
agility-8
wise cracks-3
peter parker-10
mary jane-4
supporting cast-9
villans-8

 

[spider-neil]

strength - I don't think the movie has shown peter is ridiculously strong the only two times I can think of is when he holds the tram (SM1) he stops the train (SM2) and rips up the drain grill (SM3) would have been nice to see him lift a car or some thing
> 3

spider sense - nicely done in the first one, where they show all the threats in the school corridor (fly/spit ball/flash's fist) after that it was done with just a sound effort and in 3 it seemed to be ignored all together
> 5

wall crawing - no complaints they've done this quite well
> 10

web swinging - best comic to movie transfer imho. perfect. the end sequence at the end of SM1 was simply jaw dropping
>10

speed - nicely down in spidey 1, where they show flash and the pumpkin bombs moving in slow motion but spidey moving at normal speed
>7

agility - brilliantly shown in SM3 in the crane sequence and also when spidey creates the cage to capture venom, awesome
> 7

wise cracks - poorly handled. you can argue it would break up the flow of action but it still a big aspect of spidey's personality they seem to disregard. wise cracks against bone saw and then after that you get one line (if you're lucky) againts all the other villans
> 3

Peter Parker - love his portrail in the movies, the fact he's broke and has loads of problems, his role at the bugle my only problem is they have actually shown his genius apart from some nerdish talk. good not perfect
> 9

MJW - bears little relation to the comic character
> 5

Supporting cast - brilliant. aunt may - dead on, JJJ - dead on, harry has changes but the essense of the comic is there
>10

villans - bears little relation to the comics characters but in some cases (doc ock) they were improved from their comic version
> 5