World Rank all the Superman films

[Kevin Roegele]

1. Superman (1978) 10/10
2. Superman Returns (2006) 9/10
3. Superman II (1980) 9/10
4. Superman III (1983) 7/10
5. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987) 5/10

I believe the Richard Donner version of Superman II will become either 1 or 2 when it's released.

 

[Orko Is King]

That's pretty much how I'd list them.

 

[Mr. Walters]

You know, mine come in the order they were released...

Superman
Superman II
Superman III
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace
Superman Returns

 

[The Chairman]

Superman II 10 / 10
Superman Returns 10 / 10
Superman: The Movie 9 / 10
Superman III 3 / 10
Superman IV: The Quest For Peace (so bad I shut it off) 1 / 10

 

[Dr.Dude]

- Superman Returns
- Superman: The Movie
- Superman II
- Superman III
- Superman IV

 

[elvislennon2005]

Superman The Movie 10/10
Superman Returns 10/10
Superman II 9/10
Superman IV 8/10
Superman III 8/10

 

[Lord Blackbolt]

1. Superman (1978) 10/10
2. Superman Returns (2006) 9/10
3. Superman II (1980) 9/10
4. Superman III (1983) 7/10
5. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987) 5/10

I believe the Richard Donner version of Superman II will become either 1 or 2 when it's released.

Same for me too

 

[matthooper]

Superman
Superman 2
...and a distant third
Superman Returns

Superman 3 and 4 are so bad they don't belong in the Superman Universe.

 

[OzzMosiz]

Superman The Movie 10/10
Superman Returns 10/10
Superman 2 8.5/10
Superman 3 6/10
Superman IV 4.5/10

 

[griffolyon12]

1.)Superman Returns - 10/10
2.)Superman 2 - 9/10
3.)Superman:The Movie - 8/10
4.)Superman 3 - 6/10
5.)Superman 4:Quest for Peace - 1/10

 

[KaptainKrypton]

Superman: The Movie
Superman: Returns
Superman: IV
Superman: II
Superman: III

I place IV higher up because it was never truly finished. Kevin and I have had a couple of discussions on this film before. I'm in the small minority who thinks the film would be damn good if given the proper overhaul.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

Superman: The Movie
Superman: Returns
Superman: IV
Superman: II
Superman: III

I place IV higher up because it was never truly finished. Kevin and I have had a couple of discussions on this film before. I'm in the small minority who thinks the film would be damn good if given the proper overhaul.

Superman IV is bad but likeable. I agree that the potential was there. Sidney J Furie did direct The Ipcress File, he has talent. Reeve was emotionally involved in the story, and you can see it in his final speech at the UN. The original ideas for Nuclear Man - with Reeve playing him - were far better than what ended up onscreen.

BUT.....you can't rate what could have been, only what there is. Superman IV is not finished, but we can only rate what their is to rate. And that comes well below Superman II and Superman III in my opinion.

 

[Bad Superman]

Superman The Movie
Superman II
Superman Returns
Superman III
Superman IV

 

[lordofthenerds]

Superman Returns (9/10)
Superman: The Movie (7.5/10)
Superman 2 (7/10)
Superman 3 (2/10)
Superman 4: The Quest for Peace (1/10)

 

[nite-owl]

1. Superman the movie
2. Superman Returns
3. Superman 2

 

[Bad Superman]

Let's see how these rankings change once Donner's Superman II comes out.

 

[BH/HHH]

Superman - 9.5/10
Superman Returns - 9.2/10
Superman II 8.5/10 (Donner cut may surpass top 2)
Superman III - 5/10 (5 is for the junkyard scene)
Superman IV - 2/10 (was still better than Batman & Robin plus I loved it when I was like 4)

 

[nite-owl]

Let's see how these rankings change once Donner's Superman II comes out.

When does it come out again?

 

[kal-el1990]

1)Superman Retrns
2)Superman;The Movie
3)Superman 2
4)Superman3
5)Superman 4:The Quest for Peace

 

[DarKush]

1. Superman 2
1. Superman
3. Superman Returns
4. Superman 3
5. Superman 4

 

[Zor-El]

I think Superman: The Movie and Superman Returns are tied for me. I liked Superman Returns, and i think it was the best sequel to S:TM to date, but I have sort of a soft spot for origin stories...
so:
S:TM/ SR
SII
SIV/SIII
IV and III are tied as both are pretty watchable to me, but not so great

 

[Kevin Roegele]

1. Superman (1978) 10/10
2. Superman Returns (2006) 9/10
3. Superman II (1980) 9/10
4. Superman III (1983) 7/10
5. The Batman/Superman Movie (1998)
6. Superman: The Last Son of Krypton (1996)
7. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987) 5/10

Yet to see Brainiac Attacks.

 

[casketmouth]

Superman 78
Superman 2
Superman In my mind that I've always wanted made
Superman Tim Burton that never lifted off
Superman Returns
Superman 4
Superman 3

yup!!!

 

[mcflytrap]

My favorites are:

S:TM
SII
SIII
Superman Returns
SIV

 

[Superbaty77]

1.uperman the movie (Best Superman movie and dont you forget it.)
2. Superman 2 ( Chris Reeve acting alone makes this better then Returns. I bet Donner's cut is even Better.)
3. Returns (Only because Superman 3&4 were so bad. Overall its a Souless movie.)
4. Superman 4
5. Superman 3.