This is the first time as a Superman fan that I haven't been very excited about an upcoming Superman movie. Still tying to get over the fact that Gunn got rid of Cavill. Gunn refused to allow Cavill to finish his arc, not even be part of Elseworlds? How is that fair? Gunn just doesn't want competition, that's why. The reason he also asked Superman & Lois to end its series. Funny how Gunn cast Supergirl when the movie doesn't even have a director yet. I was divided about Snyder's Superman, but still thought Cavill was the best Superman we had and he deserved way better. I honestly can't forgive James Gunn, especially since he was going to keep his favorites (Jason Momoa, Zachary Levi and...frickin' Ezra Miller) Corenswet looks like Pepsi standing next to Coca-Cola (Cavill). No disrespect to Corenswet.
As a filmmaker, I think Gunn is a genius filmmaker. I loved Guardians of the Galaxy 1 and Volume 3. Not volume 2 so much. I like The Suicide Squad and Peacemaker. Having said that, my concerns about Superman may be that it will be too hard on the jokes. Hope it's not silly. The fact that Otis is even in this movie raises eyebrows for me. Plus Miss Tessmaucher. And Scooby-Doo was pretty bad, granted I know Gunn only wrote the story, but it was pretty bad. I hope the tone of this Superman isn't like Spider-Man: Homecoming or Far From Home. Those films weren't serious enough and both films were comedies.
Gunn has a lot to live up to. Gunn is going to have to really impress me if he wants my support after not hiring Cavill and adapting the horrible, dreadful New 52 costume and the Alex Ross inspired Kingdom Come logo. I mean why would you want to start with the Kingdom Come logo? For me, that's not even a Superman logo. It's not even an 'S'. Looks like a backwards Z to me. The S is so iconic, and one of the most recognized logos in the world, but the Kingdom Come logo is less recognizable to the general audience, and in terms of marketing, I think that is a really bad idea. Something more classic should have been adapted. I don't want the KC logo to define the image of Superman for the next generation. I wasn't against it, I just think that could have been earned to do the Kingdom Come story in 10-15 years time should this new DCU be successful.
Ultimately the new 52 inspired look and Kingdom Come logo really stand out as a huge distraction for me, and Gunn is going to have to do a lot to impress me. The suit doesn't even look better than Cavill's suit. So far, my expectations are not high. I want Superman to be taken seriously and not be portrayed as silly or goofy. I want something epic. A story where the people look up to Superman or potentially will. I personally didn't care for Superman vs The Elite. Not that it was a bad story, but for a lot of people that say Superman is too clean cut, or too good, so I think that story may not suit a general audience in my opinion or where Superman talks to a priest (Superman For Tomorrow) got to admit, that was boring. Ideally I think Superman should have a one man show down with Lex Luthor's power suit or another villain. I know Gunn is a fan of using lesser known and unique characters, but I hope he doesn't go for something goofy.