I don't think this is a parody or a spoof. I liked it. Not because it's a particularly good movie. I am keenly aware of its flaws. It's a dark action comedy. I'm not surprised it's getting panned. But I can't bring myself to call this film mediocre. It's not a great film, but there's a lot to like about it. It never pretended to be anything more than what it is. A pretty basic story about an irresponsible, pampered man who wants to be a hero and his partner. The character development and the story perhaps were medicore, but the film itself was very well made. I don't remember the Green Hornet ever being anything but fun and kind of interesting. That's not to say it couldn't be deeper and more relevant...but it doesn't have to be, either, to have value.
I see a lot of talk that the source material just serves as an excuse for comedy. I don't know that I agree with that. I think there's a comedic, almost satirical approach to certain elements, but there's also a sense of reverence to the trappings of Green Hornet lore. The car, the gas gun, the costumes, the partnership, etc. I don't think a hero calling something "cool" is poking fun at it. I think its acknowledging how cool it is. I saw a lot of the humor as darker humor. I thought it was interesting that there a select few pulp elements to be found, too.
I am relatively certain that Britt Reid being an over the top *****e was a choice made by Rogen, who is not a great actor, but also not stupid enough to just be loud for an entire film for no reason (beyond his natural voice, which is pretty intense). You were supposed to dislike Britt Reid. He's a nice guy, and he's not a responsible guy. And they weren't subtle about it, because Seth Rogen isn't subtle. He's not a very expressive actor, either. It's just who he is. But he got the point across, and he got the job done. He didn't play another handome leading man, he turned Green Hornet into the everyman. I think he took Britt Reid far away from Batman and Iron Man as he could, and that's pretty much what was to be expected. And whether that was the right move can be debated, but he pretty much nailed that aspect of the performance. Britt is a normal guy. So that's how Seth played him. I don't think this movie was going to get made without Seth Rogen, so he gets credit for a lot of that.
I don't think The Green Hornet was played entirely as a joke in this film, either, even when he bumped about. I think it recognized the absurities of the concept of a man suddenly becoming a masked vigilante, but also dealt with some of the ramifications, without turning him into a Batman clone.
There is character development in the movie, its just awkwardly executed. Kato's frustration and anger, and the fight that it culminates in is probably the best part of the movie, 80's movieish or not. I don't think Green Hornet was portrayed as dependent on Kato because that's the perception after the series. I think that was this films approach to a man who doesn't know what he's doing trying to become a superhero. It struck me as logical. He did what he could, which really wasn't a lot early in the game.
The Black Beauty was amazing. Beat the living piss out of The Tumbler from the new Batman movies.
There is some fantastic action in this movie. It really has a lot of nice action beats, creative action, and creative resolutions. I can't bring myself to hate the fact that the gas gun was played for laughs, because it was also used to fantastic effect.
The score is actually pretty good, too.
I think, had the film allowed Britt to have a few more serious moments, the reaction would be much better.
I don't know much about Kevin Smith's take, and haven't read his GH comics, can someone fill me in?