The Razzie's overwhelmingly make their "pick's" based on whatever will get them the most press and more on the movie than the performance, which is why you never hear them "nominating" small films that few people have heard of and extremely rarely if ever nominate people from great movies.
The fact that Evangeline was nominated for 2 awards that noone has ever heard of (one of them being a sci-fi type of award organization) when she's the lead actress in the best new show to come along in years only reenforces my argument. Award organizations people have heard of (Emmy's, SAG, Golden Globes) genuinely can't give nominations away fast enough to whatever lead actress is on a show the caliber of which Lost belongs too, but she never even received nomination buzz. Name a worse actor playing a regular (other than the black kid) on the show. A case could be made that Josh Holloway is as bad as her, which is probably why the episode most involved with the 2 of them was the worst of the series.
Evangeline being a natural redhead really has nothing to do with the argument I was making. She's a brunette on Lost, Kate has Brown hair. It's extremely doubtful that the show would allow her to do a role which requires her to alter her appearance like that. I know of people on alot of different shows playing characters who aren't stuck on a desert Island who have to maintain the same hair and general appearance.