I've travelled from Glasgow, Scotland to the San Diego Comic-Con these past two years. This year was a bit more special, as I brought a few black-and-white rough copies of
The Standard, the comic I've been working on, to hand out to various creators and editors in hopes of feedback and generating interest in the book. Here is the report on my efforts I sent as an email to my artist and editor when I got home:
WEDNESDAY
Preview Night. I thought this would be the best day to get as much of my trawling the floor and pimping the book done as possible. My first stop was at the Image booth, where I found Jim Valentino sitting down for a signing. At the time I went over, no one else was in line to get an autograph or anything, so I figured this quiet moment would be the best time to approach him. I went up, shook my hand and introduced myself, and asked him if I could give him a comic I'd written to look at. I told him that I had still to prepare a full submission package (and could possibly be coloring the book), but I was interested in submitting to Image, and that after reading
After the Cape, I thought his Shadowline imprint could be a great fit for the title - as
The Standard was both similar enough to that book to interest that book's readers and different enough to be its own thing. I asked if he could take a look at it and maybe get back to me when he could, maybe offer any advice and tell me if he thought it was worth proceeding with a submission. He said he would. I then said that, though I knew it was a big ask and it was alright if he was too busy, would he able to meet up with me at any point later in the convention to discuss the book. He said that he was awfully busy during Comic Con weekend and it wouldn't be possible, and I said that was fine. He passed the book over to Kristie Simon, who was sitting next to him, and she opened it and started reading it as I was leaving. So I shook Jim's hand and made sure to shake hers too as I took my leave.
My next stop (after struggling for a while to find it) was Avatar Press. I found William E. Christensen talking to a couple of distributors. Once he was done talking to them, I introduced myself and we shook hands. I then gave him a copy of
The Standard and said I was interested in submitting it to a few places, including Avatar, and was interested in hearing his thoughts on the book before I prepared a full submission, to see if it was worthwhile proceeding. He put it in his bag and said he'd take it back to the office with him, and take a look at it after Comic Con. I said that would be great, thanked him, shook his hand, and moved on.
After that, I went to the Arcana Studios booth. I found Sean O'Reilly, introduced myself and gave my spiel on
The Standard. He said that I should give the book to his submissions editor, and walked me over to the other side of the booth and introduced me to the submissions editor, whose name I forget. I passed the book to him, shook both their hands and left.
After that I went to Ape Entertainment, and since I couldn't find pictures of the three co-founders of the company I asked one of the people working on the booth if any of them were around. They said no, but to come back tomorrow and they might be there.
I then went to IDW and spoke to Chris Ryall. I offered him a copy of
The Standard, but he said he probably wouldn't get to read it and it might be left behind, so I'd be better talking to one of the other editors tomorrow. So I shook his hand and just made my way onto the convention floor to do some shopping, done with my Standard pimping for the day.
THURSDAY
I went back to the Ape booth and, rather than listing off the names of these three editors, I asked someone to tell me who deals with submissions. They pointed me in the direction of a David Hutcheson. So I went over, introduced myself and gave my little spiel on the comic again. He said he'd take a look and get back to me, so I shook his hand and moved on.
Then it was back to IDW. I asked one of the people at the booth who to talk to about submissions, and she went off and talked to someone. The guy never talked to me in person, but passed on the message to the girl that they weren't accepting any submissions at this time. So I just said thanks anyway and left. IDW was the only really negative experience I had with any of the publishers, but I didn't really let it get me down.
I went to the "Breaking into Comics the Marvel Way" panel, and I noticed Matt Fraction out front beforehand talking to the moderator. I went over to him, said hello and shook his hand, and told him I loved his work on Iron Man and Casanova. I asked him if I could give him a copy of my comic and get his feedback on it, he said sure. So I gave him
The Standard. He asked if I had contact info on there for him to be able to get in touch with me, so I showed him the back cover. I thanked him and shook his hand again, and as I walked back to my seat I saw him putting the comic in his backpack.
Later that day was the Geoff Johns Spotlight panel. After it was done, Geoff Johns - as he did last year - made sure to sign something for everyone who came up to him afterwards. Guy's a class act. Anyway, I got him to sign a book, and also gave him a copy of
The Standard and asked him if he could give me feedback on it when he has a chance. He said sure and I walked off, thinking he'd be too overwhelmed with the crowds to spend any further time with me. But then he called me back, and I went over. He asked if I was John, I said yes. He extended his hand to me rather than vice versa, so I shook his hand, and as I did he said, "Thanks for giving me this, I WILL read this and get back to you." So I made sure to thank him again. Afterwards, when I was meeting up with my friends outside the panel, I spotted Johns out in the hallway, still signing for fans, and noticed he had my comic tucked under his arm. So at least he didn't just throw it away once I was gone.
FRIDAY
Friday was a bit quieter on the Standard front. The only person I gave the comic to was Grant Morrison. After the Batman panel I passed it to him and asked if he could take a look at it and give me some feedback. He skimmed through it while I was standing there, and said, "Well the art's great anyway." He then said the book was interesting, so he'd take a look at it later. I said thank you before heading off.
SATURDAY
No comics given out on this day, I'm afraid. I spent the whole day camped out in Hall H, and seeing that I was dressed as Green Lantern, it might not have been a good idea to introduce myself to comic creators on that day anyway.
SUNDAY
I thought it was going to be a quiet day, but a few late additions made it a success. While my friend was off buying some comics from the Archaia booth, I wondered over to the Image booth, my attention grabbed my two volumes of
Phonogram on the table. I had heard of this book, as it's by Kieron Gillen - whose work on Thor I've really enjoyed. Anyway, I'm looking at the book, and I hear an English accent saying, "Are you familiar with the work?" I look up, and it's Gillen behind the booth. I end up talking with him for a few minutes about his work on Thor, about following J. Michael Straczynski and how that, as much as I like Fraction, I found myself wanting Gillen's run to last longer as I've really been enjoying it. I bought both volumes of
Phonogram, then gave him a copy of my book, asking if he'd read it when he got the chance and give me feedback. He said "Certainly", and I shook his hand and said it was nice to meet him.
Finally, it was 5pm and they announced the hall was closing. I walked over to the Image booth - they were just about to close up. I bought a few volumes of Invincible, seeing they were doing a "Buy 2 Get 1 Free" offer on the books. While I'm paying, I hear a voice behind me saying, "Are we just closing up, yeah?" The guy at the booth said he was just serving me then they were done. I turn around, and it's Robert Kirkman. So I shake his hand, give him the book, and ask if he could give me some feedback if he has time. He asked if I had contact info, and I showed him the back cover. He popped the comic in his "I HEART ZOMBIES" tote bag, and I shook his hand again and left Comic Con.
Thus far, only Jim Valentino has got back to me about the book. But I don't hold it against any of the others for not replying - they're all insanely busy. I just hope that it's that they never got round to reading the book, rather than they read the book and it was so awful they couldn't say anything nice about it!