LarryLegend
Superhero
- Joined
- May 30, 2002
- Messages
- 8,990
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
Stillanred, nice take on MJ. Very true, she can be well written but like Spider-Man overall often hasn't been recently.
LarryLegend said:Stillanred, nice take on MJ. Very true, she can be well written but like Spider-Man overall often hasn't been recently.
I agree with LarryLegend: Nice post. I didn't care too much for Party MJ, but something truer to that would be ever so much better than the stereotype we sometimes get.stillanerd said:I think part of your frustration comes from the fact that after she was married, the writers wrote MJ out of character to be either "Mrs. Spider-Man" or a nagging housewife (sort of like what happened in the case of Superman's marriage to Lois Lane). Even worse was when they made her a successful supermodel/soap actress, and thus removing the idea that Peter was supposed to be a character who had to make ends meet and never seemed to get rich.
Peter and MJ relationship works if they have opposite personalities; he always feels he has to do something, while she just wants to relax and have some fun. That's one of the problems I had with the "Brainy Janey" version of MJ over in Ultimate--it made her and Peter too much alike, so it's no wonder why some fans of that comic like his relationship with Kitty Pryde over her (the only time Bendis seemed to get MJ right was Ultimate Spider-Man #13). Movie MJ, while definately "Gwenish," still has a bit of that happy-go-lucky aspect to her, and I think Sean McKeever's MJ (although saccrine as that comic is) seems to be how Ultimate MJ should've been written.
JMS, to his credit, actually writes a very decent Peter/MJ relationship. However, if other writers need an example a more recent example of how to write a proper MJ, they have to look no further than Spider-Man:Blue...or they can always read some back issues.![]()
stillanerd said:What I like to call Crazy Spider-Man/Civil War theory Version 4.0.
stillanerd said:Ridiculous? Yeah, maybe. Then again, whoever thought we see Spidey having stingers that pop out a la Wolverine, or a red and gold costume, or teamed up with the Avengers? Stranger things have happened. So, what do you think could happen if Spideys revealed his identity, and what could happen to him after Civil War is over?
AgentEnforcer said:I like the idea of the Civil War cultivating with a final battle between Spider-Man and Iron man, with an Injured Cap watching from the sidelines. I do think some of the people on here should be contracted to write for Marvel... or at least have the writers use our general plot outlines and base scripts from them... how woul dwe be dissappointed by storylines we've all created/gave input on?
TheWhiteSpider said:Really interesting ideas, Still. I wouldn't want to see all of them happen, but still interesting.
* Aunt May Opposes Peter Revealing Himself to the Masses.
* Mary Jane supports Peter.
*Spidey Gets Caught in The Middle
*Peter's World Begins to Crumble
*Spider-Man vs. Iron Man
*Not a fight they can win.
*Tony Conceals Peter's Identity
stillanerd said:Marvel, if you read these boards and use our ideas, we'd at least like 10%![]()
stillanerd said:Also, it would be quite amusing to see her go back and reorganize the “Grey Panthers” as you suggested.
stillanerd said:Register or become an outlaw--they’re screwed either way. And I don’t think she’s trusts Tony like her husband does. Chalk it up her woman’s intuition.
stillanerd said:I agree. Other things that would really question Peter as to whether he’s on the right side is if some of his rogues gallery end up registering and thus become official law enforcement agents in order to escape prision time. I can just picture Peter’s reaction seeing guys like Doctor Octopus joining up with the registered side, or even worse the Green Goblin.
stillanerd said:Couple of things. As I speculated, I think the Green Goblin would attack Aunt May (and injure some protesters in the crossfire) to get back at Peter for revealing he’s Spider-Man, thus ruining his one hold he had on Peter. “You think you can best me, Parker?” he’d say. “Well think again!”
stillanerd said:Also, I do agree that Iron Man is going to torture one of the captured anti-registration heroes, and it certainly would be a shock if he was applying “direct pressure” to Cap (although I think Namor might be a person he interogates using “water deprivation” if you will) it does underscore the idea that Spidey would think Iron Man has gone over the line.
stillanerd said:I definately see something like this [(Spidey vs. Iron Man)]* going down. This could even be the moment where Spidey, to show which side he has chosen, makes the nanocites in his costume change from Iron Spidey to his classic red and blues.
stillanerd said:Also, during the fight, Tony may realize that combined with Spidey’s already foremidable powers, he made the suit too well because Spidey is managing to hold his own. Plus, Tony is holding back, not wanting to hurt someone he’s come to see as a “kid brother.” He’d probably warn Peter to stand down and give up, which of course he won’t. That’s when Tony tells him “I’m sorry I have to do this, Peter” and, in an act of ultimate cheapness, Tony presses a button on his armor and Spidey’s suit begins to immobilize him using electro-static pulses, freezing up his muscles, and the more Spidey struggles, the worse the pain is. Tony keeps telling Spidey “Please, Peter. Give up. Don’t force me to kill you.” But Peter, remembering Uncle Ben, Captain Stacy, Gwen, all the people he’s let down, through sheer strength of will, resists and manages to tear out the device giving him the convulsions.
stillanerd said:But he is so weakned by his efforts that he’s now at Iron Man’s mercy. That’s when MJ, who arrives just to see this, steps in and stands in front of Peter. This is followed by the weakened Cap, then other heroes one by one. Tony then turns his back, giving all of them a chance to escape as the rest of S.H.E.I.L.D. arrives.
stillanerd said:Afterwards, Peter recovers and then, after saying good-bye to MJ and saying it’s too dangerous to be with him, goes on his “fugitive” status (which of course gives JMS the opportunity for Peter to discover “the truth” behind the spider totems and how it’s all an elaborate sham).
stillanerd said:He might replace Peter with an Iron Spidey and alter his file, but there’s the matter of convincing the public. What’s more, S.H.E.I.L.D. and the feds would still want to go after Spider-Man regardless.
TheWhiteSpider said:You're right about that. It's a no win situation. I also can see MJ being against it, but I thought it would be more interesting if Peter were being pulled in both directions even inside his own home. [He's usually at his best, storywise, when he's facing problems from every direction].
Well, we can expect some super villains to join up with the registration side, I imagine. And just the idea of one of Spidey's rogues just rubbing salt in the wound over Spidey not being able to do anything about it would be too good to pass up.Great idea. I'd love to see the "WTH" look Peter would have on his face when he saw Tony issuing directives to Ock, or another of his R.G.
There are only two reasons I didn't want to see this happen. 1) Because it's always Norman. Honestly, I think he paid Flash Thompson to bully Peter during high school. Far fetched..? Why do you think he really hired and took to Flash so quickly after his return? [Don't worry, I requested that SHH ban all Marvel Exec. IP addresses before submitting this post. Somewhere an E-I-C sighs, dejected].
Secondly, because if the injury was caused by an enemy who didn't know Peter's I.D. before, it'd be another reason for Stark to feel like dirt and assist Pete with the I.D. cover up later.
I assume that the person being tortured would have a high rank amongst the anti-reg group, and I saw Cap's defiance under torture/escape from SHIELD as a method that'll enable Millar to make 616 Cap appear a "bada$#." Also, Spidey's outrage would be even more intense if it were Cap being tortured.
That would be another beautiful, true-to-Spidey moment. However, I don't have much confidence in their depiction of Spidey's battle prowess. When was the last time Peter was shown to be able to lay down law on a bad guy in a group setting? IMO Peter could go the distance with Tony and surprise the heck out of many, from the embedded reporters to segments of the reading audience.
Ahh.. this is the only part of your scenario I don't want to see. I don't want to see "David Banner" Spidey, going under an assumed name. Especially not from the current writing staff.. It would be an interesting 6 month arc under someone like Dematteis, but.. I wouldn't want it to go there until there's a staff rotation at Marvel.
stillanerd said:Well, the problem with Peter unmasking himself before the entire world is, while it would be great to see all the reactions from the other characters, the problem would be how to fix it. After all, Spider-Man HAS TO HAVE a secret identity in order for the character to work. That's why the few times he HAS BEEN UNMASKED it always lasted for a short time and he ended up maintaining his secret identity in the end. I would not rather see it happen, but if it does, then hopefully somebody at Marvel has a plan...maybe.
As for MJ, I know you hate the marriage but killing her off (which was done before) would be a mistake. Then again, I probably can't convince you of that anyways.![]()