Which Volume is Better? Villians Or Fugitives?

[SuperJediHero]

Just so far on Fugitivies, I know it has 2 more eps left...

 

[SuperT]

This all still depends on how Vol. 4 ends but:

Vol. 1 >>> Vol. 2 >>>>>> Vol. 4 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Vol. 3

 

[Deaths Head II]

Fugitives has been my favorite volume since the first, so I'll go with that by far.

 

[YoungE808]

Knox breaking that guy from 4400's neck was a good highlight for me in Volume 3

 

[Sawyer]

Out of Villains and Fugitives? Fugitives, by far. Villains was quite possibly the most tragically dissapointing arc of episodes ever. I was really pumped for it and... nothing.

But out of the four...

1. Genesis
2. Fugitives
3. Generations
4. Villains

 

[shoelessthunder]

Yeah, I'm with Loud Silent Man and Deaths Head on this.
Fugitives by far...in fact it's kinda funny to me that 1 person picked Villains by far. I hope that was a joke, but to each his own.
Anyway, yeah
Genesis > Fugitives > Generations > Villains.

 

[MaxG]

Fugitives.

 

[Dark Sentinel]

love Fugitives..Danko is easily the best villain since Sylar in Genesis and to see them join forces is insane

 

[Primal Slayer]

Fugitives. Villans started out about villans but ended up about Sylar.

 

[RonStoppablefan]

Fugitives>>>>>Villains yes.
I am loving the way they've been doing Peters character, all they need to do is twink his ability a bit like say let him use two powers like flight and maybe Matt's power or Mohinders and things would be fine.
But as far as other Volumes are concerned

Volume 1>Volume 4>Volume 2>Volume 3.

But I did love the episode I Am Death in Volume 3 and some other episodes but yah it wasn't a good Volume.

 

[November Rain]

i'd say villains is probably had the better potential but the worst execution of the two

i had really high hopes for arthur

 

[Sawyer]

Not to mention that all the villains were insanely over-hyped. Before the season started, all the producers were like "these Level 5 guys are just as, if not more, dangerous than Sylar." And i was like "omfg, yes!!!" I was so pumped. And then the season started.

Jesse and Knox were just a couple of two bit hoods, with not too exciting or dangerous powers.
The German got his ass killed within the first twenty minutes of his second episode.
Flint was a brain-dead moron.
Black hole guy had a somewhat dangerous power, but he wasnt a bad guy.
The puppetmaster was probably the most dangerous, because he was actually somewhat messed up in the head.

It was just lame.

 

[Deaths Head II]

They probably meant "more dangerous then Sylar is now". Because they made him into a good guy in Volume 3.

 

[shoelessthunder]

I think it would be pretty messed up if they meant it like that, cause in that quote, Kring is clearly trying to make the villains sound really badass.
And that would be a weak technicality...

 

[O'Haire]

Villains started out fine. But then turned into yet another save the world story.

And they killed Adam Monroe. That was a bunch of crap.

 

[YoungE808]

Yeah, I'm with Loud Silent Man and Deaths Head on this.
Fugitives by far...in fact it's kinda funny to me that 1 person picked Villains by far. I hope that was a joke, but to each his own.
Anyway, yeah
Genesis > Fugitives > Generations > Villains.

I was just saying what I thought was a cool moment to me since 4400 was imo....really bad towards the "end". Villains wasn't that good. Fugitives is probably the best, maybe Genesis but I'm sure that's all everyone else will say.

Company Man was the best ep from Volume 1 (imo). Not sure about the best from Fugitives

 

[Ryudoz]

Villains had a nice premise. A mass collection of Villains to combat the Heroes. The first episode was okay, but after that I think I said "WTF" about a billion different times. The Volume finale was ludicrous.

 

[nausicaa]

They probably meant "more dangerous then Sylar is now". Because they made him into a good guy in Volume 3.

Nah, they actually had Noah say how dangerous they were, like 10 Sylar's running around or something.
Villains was terrible, it amazes me that professional writers, people who are paid to write stories, could produce such utter garbage. So so bad. There didn't seem to be a plot at all most of the time, characters constantly flip flopping with no motivation, things set up and then never happening. I was really excited by the trailer as well, it could have been epic.

 

[sherlocke]

I'm losing faith in the series in general. Villians was too hokey with surprise twists every 5 minutes, while Fugitives is plodding and boring.

 

[Sawyer]

I'm losing faith in the series in general. Villians was too hokey with surprise twists every 5 minutes, while Fugitives is plodding and boring.

How is it boring? Character development? Does that bore you?

 

[Deaths Head II]

I hear that complaint a lot from the people who dislike this season. If character-focused stories are boring then I like boring shows.

 

[Matt]

How about we close this and re-open it when Fugitives ends so people can make fully informed votes.