Batman Elimination Game - Round 13: Batman Artists

[Fledermaus]

Neal Adams 71 (-)
Jim Lee 56
Mike Mignola 15 (+)
Tim Sale 56

The only reason I'm voting against Adam's and not Lee is the fact that I hate the yellow oval. hate it hate it hate it. Immature? maybe. If it comes down to Lee and Sale, my votes are going to Sale.

 

[The BatDude]

Neal Adams 70 (-)
Jim Lee 56
Mike Mignola 15 (+)
Tim Sale 56

 

[trustyside-kick]

Pretty much everyone would rank Adams or Sale above Lee. I didn't gang up on you, I just said Lee is not the greatest. He has no absolutely no style, his art is so plain and ordinary.

That is not true. It was after he became well known that some artists drew more like him. You don't have to have a major in art or attend an art school or private institute to have a 'good/great' opinion on art; even though I know people who do and they like Lee a lot like me too (with Sale and Adams following after).

Not like I hate Adams, I said in the suggestion box thread how it was going to be hard for me to decide out of the 3 artists.

I remember there being a poll about the best artist, it was pretty close between Adams and Lee I think, don't remember who won.

Wish I saw that thread/poll.

 

[trustyside-kick]

The only reason I'm voting against Adam's and not Lee is the fact that I hate the yellow oval. hate it hate it hate it. Immature? maybe. If it comes down to Lee and Sale, my votes are going to Sale.

I was watching Volume 2 of BTAS this morning and watched the episode Robin's Reckoning and there was some flashback where Bats was in a different suit then his usual in BTAS. It didn't have the oval and was a darker blue and I was like "wow, without the oval he really does look better".

Aside from that, sorry for the double post. I clicked the quote button and planned on cutting and pasting (to put on my previous post) when I was done but accidently posted.

 

[Mee]

Wish I saw that thread/poll.

It was a while ago. Before your time I think.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 70 (-)
Jim Lee 56
Mike Mignola 15 (+)
Tim Sale 56

That should make Mignola at 16 not 15. So the next voter knows here is the current score:

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 56
Mike Mignola 16
Tim Sale 56

Lol, I feel like the police of this thread. Normally Mister J would be right beside me helping me out.

 

[The BatDude]

That should make Mignola at 16 not 15. So the next voter knows here is the current score:

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 56
Mike Mignola 16
Tim Sale 56

Lol, I feel like the police of this thread. Normally Mister J would be right beside me helping me out.

Sorry I didn't see Fledermaus's post

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 55 (-)
Mike Mignola 17 (+)
Tim Sale 56

... poor Aparo

 

[trustyside-kick]

... poor Aparo

I like Aparo too but someone mentioned and I believe they were right how he was basically a rip-off of Adams.

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 71 (+)
Jim Lee 54 (-)
Mike Mignola 17
Tim Sale 56

 

[Mee]

Neal Adams 71
Jim Lee 55 (+)
Mike Mignola 16 (-)
Tim Sale 56

 

[Flexo]

Neal Adams 71
Jim Lee 54 (-)
Mike Mignola 17 (+)
Tim Sale 56

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 71
Jim Lee 53 (-)
Mike Mignola 18 (+)
Tim Sale 56

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 70 (-)
Jim Lee 54 (+)
Mike Mignola 18
Tim Sale 56

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 54
Mike Mignola 17 (-)
Tim Sale 57 (+)

 

[Hellstormer]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 53 (-)
Mike Mignola 18 (+)
Tim Sale 57

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 52 (-)
Mike Mignola 18
Tim Sale 58 (+)

 

[The Watchman]

Neal Adams 71 (+)
Jim Lee 51 (-)
Mike Mignola 18
Tim Sale 58

 

[batmaluco]

edit
nevermind

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 70 (-)
Jim Lee 52 (+)
Mike Mignola 18
Tim Sale 58

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 51 (-)
Mike Mignola 19 (+)
Tim Sale 58

 

[batmaluco]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 50 (-)
Mike Mignola 20 (+)
Tim Sale 58

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 51 (+)
Mike Mignola 19 (-)
Tim Sale 58

 

[JTStarkiller]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 52 (+)
Mike Mignola 18 (-)
Tim Sale 58

 

[Hellstormer]

Neal Adams 70
Jim Lee 51 (-)
Mike Mignola 19 (+)
Tim Sale 58