Batman Elimination Game - Round 13: Batman Artists

[The BatDude]

Neal Adams 61 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 111 (+)

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 64 (+)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 108 (-)

 

[Flexo]

Neal Adams 63 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 109 (+)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Error, post #902. Here is the current score (my vote and the two previous to mine):

Neal Adams 60
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 112

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 59 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 113 (+)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 58 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 114 (+)

 

[Flexo]

Neal Adams 57 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 115 (+)

 

[LEX]

Neal Adams 56 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 116 (+)

 

[Obsequens]

Neal Adams 55 (-)
Mike Mignola 30
Tim Sale 117 (+)

 

[Batman]

Neal Adams 56 (+)
Mike Mignola 29 (-)
Tim Sale 117

 

[Prognosticator]

Neal Adams 56
Mike Mignola 28 (-)
Tim Sale 118 (+)

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 55 (-)
Mike Mignola 28
Tim Sale 119 (+)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 54 (-)
Mike Mignola 28
Tim Sale 120 (+)

 

[CConn]

Neal Adams 55 (+)
Mike Mignola 28
Tim Sale 119 (-)

 

[Ebil Gig]

Neal Adams 54 (-)
Mike Mignola 28
Tim Sale 120 (+)

 

[The BatDude]

Neal Adams 54
Mike Mignola 27 (-)
Tim Sale 121 (+)

 

[Flexo]

Neal Adams 53 (-)
Mike Mignola 27
Tim Sale 122 (+)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 52 (-)
Mike Mignola 27
Tim Sale 123 (+)

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 52
Mike Mignola 26 (-)
Tim Sale 124 (+)

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 53 (+)
Mike Mignola 26
Tim Sale 123 (-)

First you say Jim Lee is crap and that Adams, Sale, and Mignola are better cause of the styles and crap.

Now you say we have no taste or respect?

Sale's style is more unique than Adams. While I do respect Adams and his drawings look great, he gets too much credit just because he drew in the time where Batman was less campy.

Besides, if this was mainly about the person with most respect wins the game then why bother playing a round of the artists? It would be an automatic win then.

Lee sucks b/c he has no style. Sale is good, but is art is abstract. Adams is the definitive Batman style. If Adams gets too much credit for drawing during a less campy era, the same should hold for Sale and Lee.

 

[The BatDude]

Neal Adams 52 (-)
Mike Mignola 26
Tim Sale 124 (+)

 

[BatScot]

Neal Adams 50 (-)
Mike Mignola 26
Tim Sale 126 (+)

 

[late_night]

Neal Adams 52 (+)
Mike Mignola 26
Tim Sale 124 (-)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Lee sucks b/c he has no style. Sale is good, but is art is abstract. Adams is the definitive Batman style. If Adams gets too much credit for drawing during a less campy era, the same should hold for Sale and Lee.

You think Lee has no style because you see so much art similar to his when that did not happen til after he became big.

Does not matter if Sale's Batman is more abstract. You said we have no style or respect so I was stating that we were voting for someone who had style and respect.

When I mentioned Adams getting too much credit I meant that was when Batman finally got out of his campyness...so no the same could not be said for any artist after him; also just the fact that him and O'Neil were a great team (he gets too much credit for that as well).

Besides, style or not...respect or not...this is about what artist we like; their art just looking good is a factor as well.

 

[Prognosticator]

Neal Adams 52
Mike Mignola 25 (-)
Tim Sale 125 (+)