Batman Elimination Game - Round 13: Batman Artists

[CConn]

Neal Adams 58 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 7 (-)
Jim Lee 35
Frank Miller 9
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 59 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 7
Jim Lee 34 (-)
Frank Miller 9
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Kraven]

Neal Adams 60 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 6 (-)
Jim Lee 34
Frank Miller 9
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 60
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 6
Jim Lee 35 (+)
Frank Miller 8 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[WolfCypher]

Neal Adams 60 Jim Aparo 11Norm Breyfogle 11Rick Burchett 5 (-) Jim Lee 36 (+)Frank Miller 8Mike Mignola 19Doug Moench 10George Pérez 10Tim Sale 29

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Neal Adams 61 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 5
Jim Lee 35 (-)
Frank Miller 8
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 61
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 5
Jim Lee 36 (+)
Frank Miller 7 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

Why the hate on Jim Spidey-Bat?

 

[Spidey-Bat]

Jim's artwork is the equivelant of diarrhea

 

[Kraven]

Neal Adams 62 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 5
Jim Lee 36
Frank Miller 6 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[trustyside-kick]

Jim's artwork is the equivelant of diarrhea

????????????????????????????????????????

 

[Spidey-Bat]

????????????????????????????????????????

it's crap

 

[trustyside-kick]

it's crap

I really cannot see how you can say that about Jim. Some people have complained how in Hush for example Bruce, Harvey, and Tommy had same face basically but diff hair but still...crap?

What don't you like about his art in Batman?

 

[Spidey-Bat]

I really cannot see how you can say that about Jim. Some people have complained how in Hush for example Bruce, Harvey, and Tommy had same face basically but diff hair but still...crap?

What don't you like about his art in Batman?

I find it to be ugly. Everyone looks the same, Batman's ears are too short and his real ears stick out. His Batman doesn't look like Batman, it just looks like a soldier with a cape and cowl.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 5
Jim Lee 37 (+)
Frank Miller 5 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 4 (-)
Jim Lee 38 (+)
Frank Miller 5
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Mee]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 3 (-)
Jim Lee 39 (+)
Frank Miller 5
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 3
Jim Lee 40 (+)
Frank Miller 4 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[trustyside-kick]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 3
Jim Lee 41 (+)
Frank Miller 3 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Nightwing92]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 3
Jim Lee 42 (+)
Frank Miller 2 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 3
Jim Lee 43 (+)
Frank Miller 1 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 29

 

[Fledermaus]

Neal Adams 62
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 2 (-)
Jim Lee 43
Frank Miller 1
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 30 (+)

As bad a writer and artist he is now, DKR was so awesome, I just can't vote against Frank Miller.

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 63 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 1 (-)
Jim Lee 43
Frank Miller 1
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 30

 

[Mister J]

Neal Adams 64 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Rick Burchett 0 (-)
Jim Lee 43
Frank Miller 1
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 30

 

[Fledermaus]

Neal Adams 64
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Jim Lee 43
Frank Miller 0 (-)
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 10
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 31 (+)

Sorry, but as Frank would write, your eliminated. I eliminated you. You have been eliminated.

 

[Iceman]

Neal Adams 65 (+)
Jim Aparo 11
Norm Breyfogle 11
Jim Lee 43
Mike Mignola 19
Doug Moench 9 (-)
George Pérez 10
Tim Sale 31