Bought/Thought for September 28, 2011 - SPOILERS

Part 2: Spider-Islanders & The Rest!

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #670: This is now the midway point of the SPIDER-ISLAND event within AMAZING SPIDER-MAN (not including crossover tie-in's in HERC or VENOM); the story itself is supposedly six chapters, with a prelude and an epilogue. As such, Dan Slott's script is very busy and has a lot of things to do, in regards to the general thrust of the story itself as well as setting up scenes to be played out in detail in the tie-in material. Spider-Man himself is barely in half of the 23 pages within this issue (and that's including a flashback). As the cover indicates, most of the plot of this issue embellishes on the fact that mayor J. Jonah Jameson is now one of the countless New Yorkers who has gained Spider-Man-like powers. Thus, he gets to have a team-up with the web-slinger which is as amusing as it sounds. However, the situation by the Jackal and the Queen has reached a critical juncture; those who have been altered by their plot are no longer simply budding spider-powers, but are becoming giant spiders that are now under the Queen's control. The Queen herself lays out a couple pages of exposition which recap her origin from 2004 as well as confirming where her minion Spider-King came from. The series also continues along with Mr. Fantastic and the Horizon Lab staff's attempt to come up with a cure for the "infestation", while Anti-Venom finds himself finally being embraced as a hero by the populace - and taken seriously by other heroes - because he can cure those infected with his own powers. The ending of the issue brings back elements revolving around the SPIDER-SLAYER arc that was Dan Slott's second as he went on his "BIG TIME" push on ASM. Thus, long term readers are rewarded with a "mini event" which also settles long term subplots from last year. Humberto Ramos continues on regular art chores, and between Anti-Venom, regular Venom (who guest stars here), and various Spider-Monsters, he gets oodles to play with. Ramos has always been better with characters who are less human looking, and thus monstrous types allow him to go wild. Highlights include Slott using clever use of continuity with Alicia Masters, as well as the subplot with MJ reaching an inevitable conclusion. This isn't the best issue of the arc, but it still a riveting and suspenseful segment of one of the biggest Spider-Man stories in years. While the climax is telegraphed a little bit here, subsequent issues should provide far more bang.

ANNIHILATORS: EARTHFALL: The previous ANNIHILATORS mini series by Dan Abnett, Andy Lanning, and Tan Eng Huat was fine, but was a dip in quality from THANOS IMPERATIVE as well as NOVA and GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY. Why? Perhaps much like with WAR OF KINGS or ANNIHILATION CONQUEST, they struggle with certain lead characters over others, who feel more natural to them. However, this issue seemed to flow a bit better. I am not usually a fan of Huat's artwork, but it was quite good here. And the fact that Silver Surfer is gone from the roster of Annihilators meant a cast with one less member who speaks in stiff dialogue, and I think that helped with the banter - especially since Gladiator's hardly a snarker, either. The Annihilators are taking on the Universal Church for Truth again, who haven't closed up shop despite their god Magus supposedly being dead - which in itself is a clue. Everything is going routinely until Cosmo detects an apparently doomsday fall-back plan that has been set up via a branch of the church on Earth (Colorado to be specific). They beam in and start punching out alien impostors, but are then suckered by them into what looks to be a generic "misunderstanding battle" with the Avengers which should fill most of the next issue.

The interesting point comes up when Ikon mentions that Quasar is more concerned about collateral damage on worlds that aren't his own. Quasar doesn't hesitate in the battle, but it is nice to notice how it's difficult to be hypocritical in regards to one's own planet. The negative point comes from neither Quasar or Beta Ray Bill seeming aware of the possibility of being suckered into being confused for invaders. I do wonder what excuse will be taken for why Cosmo can't simply psychically beam the data the Annihilators know into the Avengers' heads in five seconds.

There is a 5 page Rocket & Groot back up strip by the same writers and Timothy Green II, in which they get into a bar fight with the Badoon that turns out to be a plot by Mojo for ratings. As usual, the tone is fun and the idea of Mojo as a villain for them is cool. For the record, with this back-up, the reader gets 25 story pages for $3.99. I had hoped that whenever Nova comes back to life, it would be DnA that do it, but POINT ONE #1 shows that such a thing may be handled by others. It will be good, however, if the POINT ONE story merely is used to promote the next DnA space comic, so it'll maybe sell some more copies. As for the ANNIHILATORS, it's a solid idea, but most of the cast usually are difficult to portray as characters like GOTG were, at least for DnA.

AVENGERS ACADEMY #19: Two weeks late, but better than never, this issue concludes the five issue crossover tie in with FEAR ITSELF. As the lowest selling of the four Avengers titles, AVENGERS ACADEMY needed the potential sales boost from this crossover the most. It did see a modest one, but perhaps not to what editorial wanted. The bigger story is that crossover tie-in's have ceased to boost sales for most Marvel titles for the past two years - mostly because retailers and readers have caught on that little of consequence to the event itself happens in said tie-in's. And in terms of FEAR ITSELF, nothing in these five issues has vastly mattered to the plot. However, writer Christos Gage is too wise to make such issues feel meaningless. A pro with handling crossover tie-in's from his years writing and co-writing AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE, Gage knows to continue to focus the story on advancing characters and long term subplots. That is exactly what happens here. The cadets face their darkest hour, they are forced to come up with the better of several terrible solutions to their problem, and at the end, one of them can no longer handle the strain.

Tom Raney returns on art, and is up to his usual high form alongside Scott Hanna on inks and Jeromy Cox on colors. He gets a lot of action as well as emotional beats to play with, as well as far-out locations from the Infinite Mansion to the Microverse to an aircraft carrier. This is also the first issue in a while in which the entire team - aside for Jocasta and Speedball, who are busy in FEAR ITSELF: THE HOME FRONT - assemble. Virtually every character gets a moment to shine, or at least a couple of good lines. Finesse continues on her path to seeming like more than a standard "emotionless" character, which is good; the issue also focuses on it's two couples heavily. The adult Avengers save the day to a degree, but by this point the reader is not disappointed, because they don't want anyone to die. If there is one major downer to the plot, it is that neither of the two "Worthy" villains here - Absorbing Man and Titania - can be defeated because they are required by contractual obligation to appear in FEAR ITSELF #7; they all bit literally say that in dialogue. Thus, one can see why the tie-in's didn't attract much fire; Marvel made a beat deal about "The Worthy" fighting other heroes in other books, but a battle in which a conclusion cannot be reached is aimless - just look at America's wars in the Middle East. Still, Gage has used this arc to put his young heroes through the worst situation they'd ever been in - which itself was a challenge - and see who rose to the challenge and who crumbled.

It is difficult to review this comic without giving away a spoiler, but here goes. One of the cadets leaves the team; not to death, but due to no longer believing in the cause. Without giving much away, it is one of the female members and it isn't Finesse. It is a character that has been predicted as leaving several times in this column in reaction to news stories (such as two weeks ago:http://www.examiner.com/comic-books...1-cable-returns-again-x-23-joins-academy-more). According to solicitations, X-23 will replace this cadet, and according to the letter column, some of the teachers may also leave. The book will see a change of scenery, and thus this arc was hardly a waste of time. In fairness, at least one of the cadets had to wash out and possibly meet a dark path; if not, the Avengers' premise of wishing to prevent these kids from becoming menaces would have seemed paranoid. It will be interesting to see if the corporate antagonists Jeremy Briggs from the 14.1 issue will become involved in this subplot.

As always, AVENGERS ACADEMY is the top of the heap due to several things that are usually always consistent in every issue. There is great art, a lot of action, good dialogue and solid characterization with both old and new characters. It's the most underappreciated Avengers title and it's a pleasure to read every month.

HERC #8: A dead book walking, this issue completes the two-part crossover with SPIDER-ISLAND, which was on the heels of a very loose 3-4 part crossover with FEAR ITSELF. The book will end with issue ten. Even including the .1 issue, that will have meant that roughly half this series needed some crossover series banner on the cover, or at least Marvel thought it did. There is no telling if HERC would have lasted longer without it; Marvel have seen plenty of past ongoing series be canceled before issue ten…or even issue seven. It is still unknown if HERC #10 will be the end of Greg Pak and Fred Van Lente’s critically acclaimed run on the Hercules franchise; one that began by taking over INCREDIBLE HULK and then carried on with several mini-series before HERC began. Marvel have been as persistent about this run as they have about keeping Black Panther and Moon Knight in print lately, but on the other hand, editorial patience with Jeff Parker’s AGENTS OF ATLAS eventually wore thin. At any rate, the final issues before a cancellation can often be vibrant deck clearing exercises where anything can happen.

These two issues have featured guest artwork by June Brigman, of POWER PACK and BRENDA STAR fame, and it has been more enjoyable to read than Neil Edward’s style has been. The arc has focused on Herc being bitten by one of the genetic super-spiders created by the Jackal and becoming a pawn of the Queen who seeks to control all of Manhattan. To that end he is fighting the X-Men as they attempt to help Horizon Labs to set up some machines to prevent infected Manhattanites. At the same time, what is apparently the African spider-god Anansi (or his agent) has manipulated Herc while the Greek spider-goddess, Arachne, comes into the fore for the first time in years. Half the issue is Spider-Herc vs. the X-Men and the other half has him mutate into a tarantula-man, and such a thing actually not being treated with angst. This issue has a lot of action and amusing one-liners, which was what INCREDIBLE HERCULES did so well. While I have liked HERC overall, I do admit the return to that style is naturally welcome to more straight-forward angst. The finale introduces Elektra as a guest character for the final two-part story of the series, which does make sense. She hails from Greece, so it would make perfect sense that the Greek gods via their “Olympus Group” company would hire her out for mercenary work. At the very least, a thorax doesn’t get in the way of Herc’s mojo with the ladies.

Crossover tie-in arcs can often be a mixed bag between obligation and boredom, but HERC managed to actually make an amusing romp out of it. Hopefully the series’ final two issues will prove to have been as entertaining as these SPIDER-HERC issues have been. Khoi Pham, who drew the opening arc of INCREDIBLE HERCULES as well as CHAOS WAR, will return to the series for issue nine, which should be a solid reunion of talent.

SPIDER-ISLAND: CLOAK & DAGGER #2: This came out last week, but there was a hiccup in shipping it to my LCS, so I got it this week. Despite the title, this is really a general CLOAK & DAGGER mini series with Spider-Island existing in the background just to provide most of the generic action sequences. Dagger's roommate transforming into a spider-monster as she types a term paper is hilarious, but Nick Spencer could have replaced that with, say, the chap turning into a werewolf or a gamma-monster and the scene wouldn't have been much different. And that's fine; he and artist Emma Rios have their own story to tell, and waste no bones getting there.

The sequence of this story is altered between past and present, likely to try to make the story seem longer than it is. Last issue, Mr. Negative learned from a seemingly infallible seer that Dagger is supposed to kill him. To this end, he sets about to capture her and Cloak. The oddity is rather than simply kill them - which he could easily - he seems to either want to see if Dagger is "honorable" enough to be the one to slay him, or if he can basically replace Cloak in her life as her "dark powered boyfriend". While Spencer has a terrific flare for dialogue here, Rios' artwork (along with Javier Rodiguez's colors) really steal the show here. Combined, of course, this is a total package. The fascination Mr. Negative has with Dagger is a bit strange, but villains have been going to absurd lengths to avoid killing the hero in Act 2 since fiction started. To be fair, now that Mr. Negative has to be a mobster full time since his political alter ego has become useless weight, having someone like Dagger at his side besides his nameless henchmen would be a tactical boon. He also has likely been psychologically messed up from being exposed and suicidal thoughts are there.

Frankly, I'd have been happier to see THIS creative run retroactively made an ongoing than ALPHA FLIGHT to a degree, if only because I want to see more than three issues by this team. I'm looking forward to the conclusion, and am glad I bought this on a whim.

SPIDER-ISLAND: DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG-FU #2: This, on the other hand, I'm not really thrilled with, but because it's only three issues, I'll see it through. Perhaps the lesson is to avoid buying a book for the supporting cast rather than the star. That isn't to say that Antony Johnston has written a poor script, or that the art by Sebastian Fiumara and Leandro Ferandez (with inks by John Lucas and colors by Dan Brown) isn't good. In fact, I like that Johnston has remembered things like Shang Chi's cat and record collection or had Silver Sable get a cameo. I suppose my dilemma here is that this comic is "alright" in an era where every comic dollar seems to be scrutinized. Thankfully, the standard cover price and the short arc length will keep me aboard.

Sable saved Chi from the end of the last issue, and he sets out to use his new spider-powered kung-fu to rescue Iron Fist and the other Immortal Weapons from Bride Of Nine Spiders, who has betrayed, attacked, and captured them. Yet she herself does not enjoy these feats, and her angst hits Chi in dreams. One could argue strange dreams being used to move the plot is also as old as time. We learn that the Bride is being controlled by the Queen as well as Ai Apaec, a man-spider villain from the recent OSBORN series this year. It seems SPIDER-ISLAND has been an excuse to do a lot of stories around other spider or bug themed characters. Given that new villains usually fade into obscurity, it isn't a bad idea to reuse him here. The final page does look cool, even if readers of ASM may know it won't end well.

This is more of an IMMORTAL WEAPONS saga than it is a Shang Chi story, which makes it odd that he's the star. Iron Fist, after all, did have an ongoing series that ran 27 issues fairly recently. You could combine a few of Marvel's canceled series and STILL not get 27 issues (and an annual or so). Chi isn't a bad character, but I often find him boring, and his POV really seems to exist because somebody has to be the lead character and go through certain motions. Still, I can imagine this series being more amusing as an POWER MAN & IRON FIST thing than with Shang Chi. Overall, this has been a fine romp, but less enjoyable than some other spare SPIDER-ISLAND material out there.

VENOM #7: As the first successful spin off of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN in years, it makes sense that VENOM would be included as part of the SPIDER-ISLAND crossover. Unlike the crossover tie-in's from FEAR ITSELF, where things that happen in the tie-in's don't matter to the bigger "event", VENOM has proven to be rather key to SPIDER-ISLAND. Specifically, the identity of the Spider-King minion was revealed last month in VENOM #6, while those who skipped that had to wait until ASM #670. Much like Christos Gage, writer Rick Remender manages to keep his story about his main characters and general subplot so that it feels like an organic chunk of story overall. Artist Tom Fowler is in the rotation this round (he and Tony Moore are rotating artists), with John Rauch on colors. Despite the fact that there's this entire plot about Spider-Monsters plaguing Manhattan, the issue focuses on Flash Thompson and his struggle as the military's latest Venom. Infiltrating the enemy via the alien symbiote's camouflage powers, Venom has learned that Eddie Brock - the former host of the symbiote now called Anti-Venom - has the cure to the infestation. He is tasked with bringing Brock in alive, but Flash's alien once again reacts in ways that Flash cannot predict. Meanwhile, Flash's abusive, alcoholic father is dying in the background from liver cancer and he has to decide whether to weep or cheer. The Venom vs. Anti-Venom fight was something that was inevitable and is thrilling to see as drawn by Fowler, but as always, Thompson remains the centerpiece of this series. Remender's success with this series is in establishing Thompson as a viable and interesting lead hero after decades of being a supporting character to another hero. Future issues, according to solicitations, promise more involvement by Brock, and this issue sets that dynamic up brilliantly. This is a book with a bright future ahead of it with a lot of potential, and it's fitting that this incarnation of Venom has been the most popular (in terms of sales) since the 90's. It happens to be the best written incarnation of the franchise in years, with a brilliant premise and a deeply interesting main character. If VENOM manages to become a clever legacy hero series like IRON FIST, CAPTAIN AMERICA, and GHOST RIDER have become, then so be it. Whether due to a crossover or through positive word of mouth, this is one bit of VENOM that shouldn't be skipped.
 
Last edited:
Part 3 of 3: Hickman

FF #9: Such an inconsistent book, this. There are things I always like about another Jonathon Hickman FF issue and things I don't. The boon is the return of Steve Epting to the pencils, at least until FANTASTIC FOUR #600 branches off. This issue also has more action and wraps up at least one chapter in what seems to be a long term engagement with the "Council Of Evil Reeds". Which don't include other evil versions of Reed like the Brute or the Dark Raider. A damn lot of alternate versions of Reed go bad or mad. This issue has a lot of action and some good lines. The Inhumans show up and clean house, mostly because unlike the FF, they don't care a lick about collateral damage or killing Evolved Moloids by the dozen. Unfortunately, the Mad Thinker has been rewritten to simply be mad (or suffering from Asbergers) and is more a boob than an evil genius. The last remaining "Evil Reed" - the one who carried an Infinity Gauntlet - manages to gain control of Dr. Doom because the lug took a swing at him rather than do something more calculated. I liked the art and the action, but I'm not thrilled that this arc will apparently never end and that certain "genius" characters seem to act real dumb to further the plot at times (such as uniting past villains for any purpose). This is still a book on an issue-by-issue basis for me, but I liked this issue more than the last two, so call it a good month and move on.
 
They've promoted a few new students for the academy. X-23 and Julie Power come to mind... and others that I don't remember. They've also hinted at a Runaway though I don't think that's been confirmed. I like X-23 but not enough to pick up Academy for her. I'll see who else is added to the book in addition to her to decide if I want to jump back on board at that time... but I doubt I will.
 
It's all right. Too committed to your terrible, terrible parts of the Avengers line, JewHobs. We understand. :oldrazz:

In other news, I've read all of the current Venom series and I've found it to be most agreeable. It shall be added to my pull list forthwith. It's not caving and buying Spider-Man comics after "One More Day," you see, because whenever Peter leaves from his cameos in this series, he's still going home to snuggle with Mary Jane. This is a true fact and none of you can convince me otherwise. :)
 
It's all right. Too committed to your superior, spectacular parts of the Avengers line, JewHobs. We understand. :oldrazz:

Fixed :up:

In other news, I've read all of the current Venom series and I've found it to be most agreeable. It shall be added to my pull list forthwith. It's not caving and buying Spider-Man comics after "One More Day," you see, because whenever Peter leaves from his cameos in this series, he's still going home to snuggle with Mary Jane. This is a true fact and none of you can convince me otherwise. :)

Good man :up:

I liked Venom too but I was just buying too many comics and had to drop stuff.

Honestly, I'm just finding comics, or at least Marvel comics, annoy me more than entertain me these days. The only non-X-Men books from Marvel that I buy are Avengers, New Avengers, and Daredevil. DD I go back and forth on and even the main Avengers book I'm iffy on (not Bendis's best title). I'm honestly just looking for books to drop just to drop them these days. I'm tired of buying them... despite my love of the characters.

I'm actually to the point where I'm really debating on dropping a bunch of X-Men stuff too. I've not been happy with them since some of Morrison's run (anything having to do with Emma, Jean, and Scott basically) and it went COMPLETELY downhill once M-Day hit. Eight years is a long time to stick with an entire group of books that I'm not that happy with. My fault is that I grew up with these characters and love them despite the crappy status quos.

I'm debating on cutting my X-Men buying in half:

Keep
Uncanny X-Men
Wolverine & the X-Men
X-Men: Legacy (provided the line up stays unique and doesn't become copy of Uncanny or Wolverine)
X-Men (same as Legacy)
Uncanny X-Force

Drop
Daken: Dark Wolverine
X-23
New Mutants (after the arc with Blink)
Generation Hope
X-Factor (I was going to keep with it to see how it is with Havoc and Polaris but eh)
Astonishing X-Men (I was only getting it hit or miss anyway)

I just started debating this yesterday. I'd be down to just 8 Marvel titles a month plus whatever DC books I stick with and one issue in and I'm already debating on what DC's I want to get rid of. It'd be my lowest in maybe 10 years. I don't know if I'm just going through a spell of frustration on Marvel's company or if I'm starting to finally lose interest in the medium. It's been a long time coming but slowly building so I don't know. I've been going on this frustration dropping for a good 2 years now (as you all know) and I think it's just going to keep going until I'm done with comics entirely.

Marvel (the company) has ruined my love of their comics, despite my love of their characters. It seems like every announcement, direction, pricing scheme or promotion just annoys me and I'm tired of paying them to annoy me.
 
Last edited:
It's all right. Too committed to your terrible, terrible parts of the Avengers line, JewHobs. We understand. :oldrazz:

In other news, I've read all of the current Venom series and I've found it to be most agreeable. It shall be added to my pull list forthwith. It's not caving and buying Spider-Man comics after "One More Day," you see, because whenever Peter leaves from his cameos in this series, he's still going home to snuggle with Mary Jane. This is a true fact and none of you can convince me otherwise. :)

And after snuggling with Mary Jane, he goes off to have sex with a cardboard cutout, I mean Carlie Cooper.
 
And after snuggling with Mary Jane, he goes off to have sex with a cardboard cutout, I mean Carlie Cooper.


Just Carlie? He's the hipster swingster now. He can bang all the chicks and it's cool! He can take Black Cat, that old roommate chick, and maybe throw ol' Betty Brant and Gwen's Sins Past daughter in there too.
 
You shut your filthy mouths! Spider-Man is a loyal and faithful married man. How could his best buddy Flash respect him otherwise? :argh:

Anyway, I've gone through contractions in my buying too, JewHobs. I suspect most longtime readers have. Comics move in cycles because, frankly, the fact that they're designed to go on forever kind of necessitates it. So sometimes you get bored of the same-old, same-old or sometimes you're just not into whatever cycle they're on at the moment or whatever. It happens. Someday you'll start hearing about something that sounds enticing in one or more of those comics you dropped and you'll try it out and find that it's good again. Until then, enjoy the extra cash each month. :)
 
I've just become so disenchanted with comics that I honestly WANT to stop buying them altogether, but it's hard stopping a 20 year-long hobby like that. I think I'm subconsciously weeding them out until they're gone. I can't imagine not buying them though... it's like breathing.
 
That's how they get ya. We're worse than crack addicts, us comic fans. :csad:
 
In other news, I've read all of the current Venom series and I've found it to be most agreeable. It shall be added to my pull list forthwith. It's not caving and buying Spider-Man comics after "One More Day," you see, because whenever Peter leaves from his cameos in this series, he's still going home to snuggle with Mary Jane. This is a true fact and none of you can convince me otherwise. :)

Now you need to cave and get Uncanny X-Force.
 
It's actually one of the few books that writes Wolverine right. He kills now, yes, but only when it absolutely HAS to be done and there's definately remorse for it (for all of them when it happens). And there really hasn't been much death in the book to be honest. I can only think of a few people they've killed in the series.
 
You're not alone. My collection spans four decades and I can honestly tell you, including the lackluster 90s, that this recent batch of books has me the least interested in reading I've ever been. It's been very hard for me to find books to get excited about and recommend. There is a handful that I DO dig, make no mistake. But, it's not as wide or diverse as it SHOULD and HAS been.
 
Yeah, most of the really great comics from Marvel have been canceled and some of the previously great ones are in a slump right now. Daredevil is the only Marvel comic right now that feels genuinely fresh and exciting each month to me.
 
I'm a bit different. During the early to mid 90's, I didn't actually have to buy too many comics I liked because my mother had a subscription to several from Marvel; AMAZING SPIDER-MAN, WEB OF SPIDER-MAN (until it ended), INCREDIBLE HULK, THOR, FANTASTIC FOUR and ultimately DAREDEVIL. Of those I usually read Spidey, DD, and FF the most, Hulk sometimes, and never Thor because I didn't care for him. We ended the Spidey subs during the Clone Saga and she finally dumped the rest in the early 2000's. Sadly, it was during the height of the Waid run on FF and the Bendis run on DD. I have to admit, I read a damn LOT of comics via scimming at the shops. Bigger Manhattan ones were easier since the floors were bigger, so by the time someone groused about reading a trade reprint, I was usually done. That's pretty much how I read a lot of X-Men material back then, when the 90's cartoon got me interested. I read/bought a few BATMAN comics sometimes, but not often.

During high school in the late 90's I was getting into anime and didn't spend much on comics at the time, beyond an occasional #1 issue or VENOM mini series, or WOLVERINE one shot, or the Ostrander/Ferry HEROES FOR HIRE.

Once I started college in 2000 I started getting into comics again as a weekly habit little by little. Ironically, the Ultimate books were an easy jumping on point; ULTIMATE X-MEN did it for me. I caved on USM a few years later and read it via trade up until about issue 80-something I think, when I caught up. By then I started to delve back into mainstream Marvel books again too. Once I started working more I bought more comics. In a way I probably buy more now than I've ever been before, aside for the heights of CIVIL WAR maybe. Ironically, a lot of what I buy are mini series; I thought about it and I maybe buy about 11-15 ongoing series, and those include IDW's TMNT, a couple of Kirkman Image books, and whatever the spare DC ongoing I'm getting is. Marvel publishes a damn lot of mini's. Usually, whatever series I drop I immediately replace. The last series I dropped was SECRET AVENGERS (ironically, people say the Ellis issues have been better, but, eff it) and the ones close to the cusp are FF and (some months) THUNDERBOLTS. I'll likely stick on ACTION COMICS and I'm very partisan on staying on BLUE BEETLE. I dropped THOR and INVINCIBLE IRON MAN ages ago, but replaced them with, I'll say, DAREDEVIL and VENOM. Plus, a few series I get end up getting canned, like YOUNG ALLIES or HERC or SPIDER-GIRL or HEROES FOR HIRE. So it all cycles.

I still like the Marvel Universe, although I don't like the upheavals that mess up what a creative team I like is trying to do. I'd like more books to be allowed to sink or swim on their own, but sadly, sales don't usually go for that. However, FEAR ITSELF hasn't even been the "hit" that SIEGE was, so Marvel may have to have a serious re-think as to their annual event syndrome, as it has run its course from overuse. Ironically, comics still seem to rely heavily on men aged 13-40, yet that's the group of Americans who have been hit the hardest during this Great Recession. Lord knows I've been.
 
Last edited:
I started in the early 90's with Amazing Spider-Man, Web of Spider-Man, Spectacular Spider-Man, and Marvel Tales. In about a year I started getting adjectiveless Spider-Man to complete them and that was all I bothered with for the first few years. I had a couple of neighbors would sometimes buy Ghost Rider and Fantastic Four so I got a little of those but not much.

Then I really got into the X-Men cartoon in its first season and decided to give them a shot. So I talked my grandmother into taking me to a comicshop and then into buying me stuff. I bought Uncanny X-Men 300 and 301 and X-Men 23. I was sold on that and my spiratic allowance buying (which wasn't much) was split between some Spidey titles and some X-Men titles. I eventually got my first job and started on the 2099 line but it quickly dropped to just X-Men 2099.

Well, I honestly didn't have much money to blow so I had to choose between X-Men stuff and Spider-Man stuff (since they interconnected during the Clone Saga and the Onslaught era). I chose to stick with X-Men (and X-Men 2099).

That's all I collected for years until I was working a steady job, married, etc. My shop (at the time) was pushing how great this new Avengers writer named Bendis was going to be so I caved and bought the first issue since he was such a good guy. So then I was buying every X-title and Avengers. Well, Avengers blew up to a genre which got me back into Spider-Man. I started buying Pulse. I'd buy random things with Captain America in it. It got me to try other things like Daredevil and Fantastic Four.

I refused to buy DC (as I was a Marvel fan and loyal dagnabbit) but I was just so interested in this independant book called Sojourn from Crossgen that I caved and LOVED it. So now I'd stepped into Indy a little. Then DC came out with Identity Crisis and my brother-in-law made me read it. Well, I needed to do some research for the DTL on here anyhow so I gave it a read (he owned it fortunately). Well, I loved it and it led to me reading Green Lantern: Rebirth which led me to read Countdown to Infinite Crisis which led me to read all the Infinite Crisis tie-ins and then the event itself.

From there I've been pretty steadily buying way over my budget. Over the past few years I've been knocking down some here and there but, like Dread, for ever Wolverine that I drop I replace it with a Project Superpower, Echo, or Immortal Iron Fist. I've finally got it down to just over $100 a month again, which is my goal, but I find I'm not even happy with that anymore. Gripe!
 
Captain America, Iron Man, Thor and Avengers are slumping pretty bad right now. Avengers hasn't been the same book I grew up with since Bendis took the reigns in 04. Fraction's style and attitude towards the fans has driven me away from his books and Brubaker's best days appear to be behind him on Cap.
 
To go against the trend, I'm probably more into buying and reading comics now than I've ever been. Yes, I hardly buy any Marvel these days, but with the relaunch I now have 20 DC titles I'm coming back for with issue #2, and I also read quite a bit of Vertigo and indy stuff.
 
ALL STAR WESTERN #1

Over the past three weeks, amongst making my planned DC New 52 pickups, I’ve also, on a whim, grabbed another last-minute addition that I’d had no intention of buying up until the 11th hour. These were, respectively, Detective Comics, Red Lanterns and Nightwing. In each case, I didn’t really feel vindicated for my spontaneity, as in each case my wild card selection was the weakest offering of the week, with me unlikely to come back for issue #2 of any of them. So, when I was in the store this week, and – with no prior planning – grabbed All Star Western #1 off the shelf and added it to my buy pile, in the back of my mind I had a worry that I would be going 0 for 4 on such decisions. Thankly, in the case of All Star Western #1, this concern was unfounded.

For a long time, I bought DC’s Jonah Hex series – also by co-writers Justin Gray and Jimmy Palmiotti – faithfully each month. Shoved in a box somewhere, I have the first 50-odd issues of that series in my overgrown and wild comic collection. But when I was trying to curtail my buying habits and thin down my list of monthly purchases, arguably the biggest strength of Jonah Hex - the largely one-and-done structure of standalone tales each month – became one of the things that made it an easy choice to cut. And though I came back for the final two issues of that series, that to me felt like my goodbye to the character. I had no inclination to return to that world with All Star Western in the relaunch.

But reading All Star Western #1, it’s clear that with a new title comes a different approach to storytelling. The simple, standalone tales have given way to what seems to be a dense, intricate murder mystery, the first chapter in a multi-part saga that very quickly drew me in. While I still think that Hex is a character best suited to those one-and-done fables, I can’t deny that Gray and Palmiotti make a skillful transition to a longer-form narrative for the scarred bounty hunter. Aiding in that transition is the shift in locales from the wilderness of the Old West to the burgeoning city of Gotham, where Jonah Hex partners with Amadeus Arkham to discover who has been killing and mutilating prostitutes in a case that bears parallels to Jack the Ripper. This change of scenery has a twofold effect. First, it alters the dynamics of the story, so in spite of the title this feels less like a classic Western than it does like a Victorian murder mystery. Second, it gives us a Jonah Hex story that feels more connected to the current DCU rather than existing in its own distinct historical corner: we even get some references to the ideas and even the characters Scott Snyder has been playing with in his Gotham-based writing.

In terms of characterisation, by this stage Gray and Palmiotti could write a compelling Jonah Hex in their sleep. But, in introducing Hex to a potential new wave of readers here, they take an interesting angle of presenting him from the clinical perspective of an outside observer: in this case, Dr. Arkham. His evolving insights into Hex’s personality and motivations help to show new readers that there is more to this apparently amoral bounty hunter than meets the eye, while those more familiar with the character will get a kick of seeing how certain comments by Arkham accurately (or inaccurately) allude to Hex’s storied history.

Over the course of their Jonah Hex run, Gray and Palmiotti were fortunate enough to work with a wide range of talented artistic collaborators, and Moritat carries on that fine tradition. Aided by the muted color palette of Gabriel Bautista, Moritat evocativelly brings 19th Century Gotham to life, right from a breathtaking opening splash page of Gotham train station and the emerging city behind it. He also provides us with a fine rendition of Jonah Hex, capturing the fine balance between ugly and heroic. If I had any small complaint to make about Moritat’s work, it would perhaps be that his ink lines are a bit too thick and heavy at points, to the point where it can get distracting.

Another thing worth mentioning is the length of this comic. This has a bumped-up price tag compared to other DC comics, and my understanding was that this would allow a regular-length main feature, plus a shorter backup. There is no backup feature here, just the main Jonah Hex/Amadeus Arkham story. This means we get a whole 28 pages devoted to this opening chapter, letting the creative team go more in-depth with establishing this world and its characters than a lot of comics got the chance to do in their debuts. You really feel like you’ve got your money’s worth after reading All Star Western #1, a full, dense chapter of storytelling.

So, when it comes to my wild-card selections from DC’s relaunch lineup this month, it seems I’m now 1-3. I don’t yet know if I’m ready to make another long-term commitment to DC’s weird western world, but for the duration of this storyline at least, All Star Western has grabbed my interest, and reminded me why I had such fondness for Jonah Hex in the first place.
 
Captain America, Iron Man, Thor and Avengers are slumping pretty bad right now. Avengers hasn't been the same book I grew up with since Bendis took the reigns in 04. Fraction's style and attitude towards the fans has driven me away from his books and Brubaker's best days appear to be behind him on Cap.

I kinda agree on Brubaker's Cap, but I still enjoy it every month and/or overall to see it though. His run was the first I bothered with Cap on, and I doubt anyone else could get me to stay once he calls it a run.

Hickman's FF, on the other hand, wares on me sometimes. I'll likely drop that before CA at this rate.
 
Captain America, Spider-Man and Uncanny X-Men are books I'll never abandon, I'll always weather any storm with those 3. I did briefly drop ASM after Ben Reilly officially took over in the Clone Saga (at the end of the arc The Greatest Responsibility) but I had a change of heart a few months later after catching wind of Jurgens relaunch. Everything else I'm not loyal to.
 
I'm pretty much the same as JH. I started collecting in '91 when I was given a stack of comics for Xmas, then sporadically after that until around '96 when I began buying all of Marvel's books (back when there was only like 30 a month). It wasn't until '06 I started branching out into DC and Indies, even though I did have the odd book here and there I ended up with. Now I'm getting my Marvel books for free, freeing me up to get as much as I did before with DCs and whatever Indies I can find.
 
Free comics... that's a good price. I, on the other hand, get yelled at by Dan Slott when I get free comics :)

I've since stopped doing that, but I still laugh about it from back when I did.

So how do you get yours for free? Is it due to the whole working for them thing?
 
Just finished reading all of my DC comics; and, while I don't have enough time to review them, I thought All-Star Western was HANDS DOWN the best of the bunch. I didn't even have to think about it. If you loved Batman: Gates Of Gotham, this book has the same feel, as it tells of when Jonah Hex came to Gotham in 1880. At first I rolled my eyes; but, the storytelling was fantastic. I almost though Snyder had wrote this book! Fantastic!!!

My worst isn't as easy. Quite a few of the titles that came out I didn't really enjoy. I hated how Flash and Firestorm has started over, and especially thought Manapul should stick to drawing. For that matter, Green Lantern: New Guardians didn't do much for me. Again, we get a Green Lantern title that focuses on an Earthling more than any other. (That's what makes Red Lanterns such a nice change of pace, and my favorite of the four Lantern titles.) Are they starting Kyle over, while the rest of the Green Lantern universe is still the same?? (This DC universe makes zero sense.) Teen Titans almost did the same thing. Everything in Batman's universe is almost the same, but I guess not Red Robin. As usual, this Teen Titans has no connection between the members.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"