• The upgrade to XenForo 2.3.7 has now been completed. Please report any issues to our administrators.

Bought/Thought: The 4/20 Edition!

I don't mind him being dragged into it, but for all that Bendy likes to hear himself talk, you think they would have talked about it a little. That's Bendis' problem in a nutshell. He has his characters talk and talk and talk about completely irrevelent nonsense. But then when an opportunity for some actual conversation comes along that might actually mean something, noooooo.

I'm willing to give Bendis credit when credit's due. I did enjoy SIEGE which was more action driven than anything else. Avengers Prime featuring the long awaited Steve/Thor/Tony reunion was done well for the most part.
 
I still can't forgive moraldeficiency for making me realize how terrible Siege's ending was. I thought it was good until I really started thinking about it. :csad:
 
I still can't forgive moraldeficiency for making me realize how terrible Siege's ending was. I thought it was good until I really started thinking about it. :csad:

Which part? The Avengers/Asgardian love orgy on top of Avengers tower?
 
No, the fact that the Sentry beat himself. Siege's whole point was ostensibly that the heroes got their act together and pulled themselves and the world out of the long misery that Civil War had plunged them into, but that message loses a lot of its impact when you realize that the heroes didn't actually do anything to the Void. Bob Reynolds killed the Void. And both will probably come back.
 
It's the Indiana Jones effect. Take him out of Raiders and everything still happens the same way. The nazis still get the Ark, open it up, and melt their faces off. Indy basically just jumps around a lot.
 
I read that in a book about fiction years ago and it blew my mind. How can a bunch of nothing be so entertaining?
 
I didn't like Avengers Prime either. Steve cheating on Sharon. More of the same old Bendis dialogue. Then there was the classless and juvenile disrespect shown towards Hellcat. Who i don't really care about but it just shows how classless, juvenile and mean Bendis can be.

He's a troll who just so happens to be a professional comic book writer.
 
It's the Indiana Jones effect. Take him out of Raiders and everything still happens the same way. The nazis still get the Ark, open it up, and melt their faces off. Indy basically just jumps around a lot.

Love this!:applaud

:indy:
 
Debates about the notable flaws in Bendis' technique are why I never regret dumping his comics nor avoiding trying many of his new ones. I don't need that noise.

As always, full spoilers ahoy.

DREAD'S BOUGHT/THOUGHT FOR 4/20/11:

INVINCIBLE #79: This is another "dust settling" issue after eight issues of the titular character in space, in which the status quo of normal life is established for our main characters. It also is an issue where the lateness of GUARDING THE GLOBE becomes an eyesore, as this issue is likely set after it concludes. Robert Kirkman is launching a new Image/Skybound title this week (see below), but this doesn't mean he is out of gas on his long running superhero title. Ryan Ottley and Cliff Rathburn continue on art and inks, with fill in colorist Nikos Koutsis (SAVAGE DRAGON) taking over for FCO Plascencia for a spell. Invincible tweaks his costume yet again to make it look more like his original suit, stomps some bad guys and tries to get used to life on earth after ten months in space (during which time he turned 20). He and Eve (who has gained weight as well as some emotional problems since Mark left) spend most of the issue visiting the Immortal and Dupli-Kate, who are happily retired from super-heroics and raising twins in a mansion. This issue establishes once and for all that the Immortal was Abe Lincoln in this universe, and the terrible secret that Eve has kept from Mark, and the readers, for two issues has come to the fore. Meanwhile, Nolan tries to find a way to live on earth now that he has reformed, especially since when he last left he went on a very public rampage that killed thousands (and spawned the creation of at least one villain, PowerPlex). This was a quiet issue, but the sort of quiet issues that INVINCIBLE has always done well and continues to do so. The change in colorist is detectable, but Koutsis does a solid job.

SUPER DINOSAUR #1: "This is where it begins", as the cover boldly says. Robert Kirkman reunites with ASTOUNDING WOLF-MAN artist Jason Howard to launch what he sees as a more "family friendly" comic book title, after claiming there are too few of them on the racks (while writing titles like INVINCIBLE, WALKING DEAD and DESTROYER that have loads of swears and gore). This is, in fact, the title that Kirkman and Howard were so eager to launch that they chose to walk away from WOLF-MAN after 25 issues to do so promptly. This is a true "extra sized" debut issue - 28 pages of story with zero ads and no extra price hike for the luxury. If Image can afford to do this without going bankrupt, and they remain roughly 3-4% of the industry on a good month, why can't Marvel, who represent at least 35% of the industry on an average month? There is an "origin special" issue being offered for FREE COMIC BOOK DAY on May 7th, which leaves this issue to cover a lot of said origin for paying customers with a lot of narration boxes - it borders onto "info-dump" exposition territory. On the other hand, this is a debut issue that literally leaps right into some action; no waiting six issues for the title character to appear here!

The premise is that Derek Dynamo is the son of aging scientist Dr. Dexter Dynamo, who discovered that the earth is supposedly hollow at the center and that at said center are dinosaurs as well as a valuable new mineral, Dynore. Dr. Dynamo's partner, Dr. Max Maximus, "turned out to be totally evil" and has been creating genetically modified dinosaur warriors to steal Dynore and get revenge on Doc Dynamo. Derek, alongside his custom made robot Wheels and Maximus' prototype dino-warrior, Super Dinosaur, stop said evil plans on a regular basis. There also is another of Maximus' creations who has rebelled and has her own path. Super Dinosaur (SD) is a typical 9 foot tall T-Rex, only he talks and makes up for such tiny arms by wearing armor that has larger ones; he is Derek's best friend and a video game fanatic. The oddity is that while SD is the titular character, he is practically Derek's larger sidekick. The fact that Derek is more of a genius than his aging father comes into play when a family of technicians moves into their lab to help out with SD's armor in a way that brings things down to earth a bit. This reads, to be honest, like a pitch for an above average CARTOON NETWORK or NICKTOONS show, which may be it's inevitable fate. The first half of the issue, with so much exposition being thrown at the reader that ones used to decompression may get whip-lash, is the most tedious; the second half of the issue improves greatly once things are established. To a degree, Kirkman almost seems to be pandering to younger readers, with a lot of alliteration inspired names to remember and focus on dinosaurs, which supposedly every child loves (much like gorillas and ninjas). On the other hand, Kirkman is effective at capturing the voice of a genius ten year old and simply because the premise involved dinosaurs doesn't prevent it from being accessible to adults, too. Kirkman comics typically become vastly different by issue six or twelve than in the first.

While this issue may not make some fans get over missing WOLF-MAN, it is a solid launch for those who like talking T-Rexs and a lot of boundless energy in their comics. Despite the last name, this comic also has nothing to do with Jay Faerber's DYNAMO 5 series (even though they have appeared in INVINCIBLE, and vice versa). It would, however, fit in perfectly with the world of another Kirkman creation seemingly destined for a cable network cartoon series, SCIENCE DOG. This isn't Robert Kirkman's best debut issue, but it still is fairly good for those who like some original energy to their comics, and given Kirkman's current popularity, might sell well. It will be curious to chart this book's sales alongside HAUNT.

AVENGERS ACADEMY #12: Let us take a moment to appreciate the fact that this title has survived cancelation at Marvel Comics for a full year and actually has every intention of being published until issue 20 (since a FEAR ITSELF crossover tie in begins in issue #15, and it would be embarrassing for Marvel to cut it short prematurely). That is a mark that even relaunches of characters such as Moon Knight and Namor The Sub-Mariner have failed to meet lately; even a secondary Iron Man title hasn't lasted this long recently. While sales for this series on a monthly basis have fallen below 24k, they have become more stable in recent months, and there is a chance it may hang in there with the sort of small but devoted audience that NOVA, RUNAWAYS, and GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY had for years. The fact that it has accomplished this with a cast of new characters as well as B and C-List Avengers who have rarely sold before (as well as some spare New Warriors for good measure) is quite an accomplishment for writer Christos Gage. With AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE, he had the benefit of a title launched by the more well known Dan Slott in the midst of a successful crossover period and co-writing alongside him for other a year; this launch was all on his own (albeit as part of the HEROIC AGE launch). Of the art team, only colorist Jeromy Cox has remained from the launch team; Tom Raney is the new regular penciler with Scott Hanna on inks, but Sean Chen is in rotation for the occasional fill in issue. This issue sees the Academy class take on one of the most powerful villains in Avengers history, right after he has laid out two teams of Avengers with no sign of slowing down. Such an intense trial by fire is an ideal way to cap off an initial year on a title such as this.

Picking up from the previous issue, after Korvac has laid out the cast from both AVENGERS and NEW AVENGERS, his estranged wife Carina has given the cadets their best shot at taking the villain down. She has allowed them access to their "future" bodies, so that they can employ their powers at their peak against the demigod. The point of view via narration panels is still on Veil, whose gaseous powers are slowly causing her to break apart until she may one day fade away. However, all of the characters manage to get notable development in this issue, especially Hazmat, Reptil, and Mettle. Having the teenage cast of a superhero comic gain knowledge, or even use, of their theoretical "adult selves", or at least revealing such data to the audience, is nothing new - both TEEN TITANS and recently YOUNG AVENGERS have done so before. However, Gage has utilized this trope to explore his characters further, and it leads to quite a few lasting ramifications for his cast after the threat has been dealt with. While long time Avengers fans will likely be impressed with the kids' performance against Korvac, as he is not terribly well known, casual readers may not care. The subplot with Pym wishing to revive the Wasp is even capped off, and in many ways this feels like the proper ending to the first year of this title (as well as its second trade collection).

For the most part, Raney's artwork is very good, and alongside Hanna's inks and Cox's colors it pops and has both flow and a sense of action. Where Raney struggles is where he is asked to draw the teenage cast as being in bodies that are ten years younger, and then to return most of them to normal teenage form. It is difficult to sometimes draw the difference between older teenagers and young adults, and this line can blue for many artists. Raney succeeds with Striker but fails for most of the female characters (although with Finesse, longer hair is a close substitute). Fortunately, Mettle's skull head remains, so that is not an issue. He does handle the final two pages of the issue brilliantly, which is a powerful scene.

Plus, Reptil is able to turn into a talking T-Rex. Everyone likes those, right? It does look like my theory about Veil being "the one to go bad" is also proving accurate. She has a scene where the power of Korvac clearly went to her head, and like the best villains, her road is paved with good intentions. Dr. Doom just wants to save his mom and bring order to the world; Magneto just wants what's best for mutants; Norman Osborn just wants to ensure his own success and family's prosperity, and so on.

This was another great issue of the best Avengers book Marvel publishes, and a great way to cap off a year of its existence with more to come. Marvel is finally investing more into this title, with an appearance in AMAZING SPIDER-MAN (written by Gage) coming up soon as well as a GIANT SIZE one shot and a reprint of the debut issue being featured in UNCANNY X-MEN. Hopefully, more fans choose to do the same, or at least the ones that remain continue to do so.

THUNDERBOLTS #156: As the cover indicates, Marvel’s version of the Mod Squad (or the Dirty Dozen) are recruiting additional members, and one of the villains on the cover is actually considered. Jeff Parker continues on a great run for this franchise, flanked by regular artist Kev Walker, and at least two people on inks and colors. Given upcoming announcements and solicitations from Marvel concerning material attached to their latest crossover, FEAR ITSELF, it is easy to feel sorry for Parker here. At least two of his regular cast members, Juggernaut and Man-Thing, will essentially be yanked from this title to serve in other mini series. That is at least 20% of his regular cast. Thus, Parker has to find ways to replace them, which this issue is going through the motions of doing. Fortunately, Parker has managed to tell such a story in a manner that it does not seem like a functional exercise, but an organic part of his overall arc.

The recent Thunderbolts program, which has been altered since it served as Norman Osborn’s hit squad, has performed better than expected. Luke Cage has managed to keep his rag tag team of cons on the straight and narrow, for the most part, as well as alive. However, there are some reservations about the program Raft’s warden, John Walker, who has decided to establish a “beta” team in case Cage’s “alpha” team goes rogue or dies in a mission. Cage has recently recruited Satana the She-Witch to provide a magical member besides Man-Thing (especially since Man-Thing may soon go on a break from the team). So, while the long term Thunderbolts take on a magical castle in Germany to stamp out some demonic Nazi’s, Walker and the rest of the staff cull the cream from the crop for the next team in waiting.

One thing continues to plague Parker, and that is the lack of an overall antagonist. This eventually became a concern with AGENTS OF ATLAS and continues to be a concern here. His routine is that he has a cast of characters fight random oddness. While Parker makes it work with his imagination for odd threats as well as his solid dialogue among characters, after a while it would be nice to have some sort of arch nemesis or so on for his characters to battle more than once. It is ironic that the SECRET AVENGERS, a team who should be fighting world class threats, instead are fighting yet another secret villain society nobody has ever heard of, while the THUNDERBOLTS, who could use a vague, reoccurring threat like the Shadow Council, instead fight monsters of the week.

The part of the issue that will likely get the most attention are the new Thunderbolts recruits. One is Gunna the Troll-Girl (or "Troll" as she calls herself), an Asgardian refugee who was created for this series. Two of them are villains best known for fighting Spider-Man (even if one began his career fighting the Hulk, Iron Fist and the Defenders), and one of them was mysteriously resurrected without explanation way back in NEW AVENGERS #2, the issue in 2005 that infamously got character’s powers wrong and had no end of errors, which its writer (Brian Bendis) either crassly denied or blamed on artist David Finch. What a hero. At any rate, the selections are sound choices and should provide some interesting dynamics when Parker has to relinquish a chunk of his cast to “more important” writers. Yet rather than whine about it on Twitter as some might, he is instead clugging forward and managing to make the book all the more interesting for it.

The choices I mean are Shocker, Boomerang, Centurius, and Mr. Hyde. Yes, believe it or not, Boomerang did start out fighting Hulk, Iron Fist and the Defenders before ever running into the web-slinger. The Shocker has mostly fought Spider-Man (and come very close to beating him a few times), but has also gotten his ass kicked by Gravity and the Young Avengers, and was briefly a member of the Masters of Evil. Centurius is the version who was an African American and mostly battled SHIELD and the Hulk before being incinerated to death and then being revived by Bendis in act in which, a theory insists, Bendis picked some names out of the MARVEL HANDBOOK MASTER EDITION and told Finch to insert them, regardless if they were alive or dead, like Cutthroat. Mr. Hyde seems to be a choice that seems destined to backfire, like Crossbones, but it seems that an easy out is that nanobot controllers were mixed into his serum, and he seems to be set up to replace Juggernaut as the "muscle". Out of the lot of them, I am most interested in the Shocker's portrayal here. He's often been considered a "professional" sort of villain - more after cash than murder or revenge, who has had moments of modest success. Given that he was able to invent his first "vibro-shock units" from prison scraps, he is someone who is perhaps a lesser version of Techno/Fixer, as a "MacGuyver" type guy who can make gadgets out of common items. Given that Parker seems to literally be selecting characters to fill in for ones being yanked from him, I am curious to the future.
 
Last, and sadly, least:

SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN #1000: This is essentially a random Spider-Man one shot, that isn't connected to current continuity nor is written by anyone marginally connected to current Spider-Man comics. However, in the mighty Marvel fashion, they cannot simply sell it as a one-shot, because they know it will sell at the bottom of the Top 90 at best. Thus, they have tacked on the title of one of Spidey's former ongoings and tacked on a ridiculous four digit number. The first volume of SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN ended in 1998 after a run of 263 issues during the end of the Howard Mackie era (the "Final Chapter/Gathering of 5" stuff). It also had 14 annuals (15 if you count one thrown into the "Planet of the Symbiotes" story). The second volume ended after 27 issues in 2007, during the Paul Jenkins era. There also were two SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN magazines that were sold in 1968. My point is that even if Marvel added all those up, they are far shy of 400 issues, much less 1000. But simple math has never stopped them; they have gotten titles to triple digits even if it meant counting issues before the character appeared in them, or by fudging 1-3 copies. If Marvel wanted to release a Razorback one shot, they could not simply call it THE SAVAGE TRUCK OF RAZORBACK. They would instead call it RAZORBACK #1,000,000.1A. Now, Marvel was willing to make fun of their own absurd renumbering tactics by launching DEADPOOL TEAM-UP at issue #900 and counting backwards, as well as with a Deadpool one shot which was listed at #1000. But then Marvel decided to move beyond parody and sell a WOLVERINE #900, then a WOLVERINE #1000. In fairness, doing so has caused those one shots to perhaps do slightly better than simply giving it an obvious one shot title (such as WOLVERINE: NEVER ENOUGH).

At any rate, this is priced at $4.99, and for that you get a 32 page main story and a color reprint of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #129, which was the first appearance of the Punisher. Now, a 32 page main story is a perfect reason to justify selling a one shot at $3.99, but is that reprint really worth the extra buck? Marvel was literally willing to reprint that story and offer it at movie theaters FOR FREE to anyone who bought tickets for one of the Lion's Gate Punisher films - either "THE PUNISHER" or "PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL", I forget which. Now, while movie tickets are hardly cheap in NY (ranging from $10-$14 full price depending on the year), any cash Marvel saw from Punisher films was minimal because it was a licensed property. My question is, if Marvel are willing to print out THOUSANDS of reprinted copies of ASM #129 and give them away FOR NOTHING to casual movie audiences, why do they demand their smaller, regular customers pay a dollar for it in the middle of a recession? Greed, or plain stupidity?

At any rate, I bought this because of the creative team. John Ostrander, the man who once wrote HEROES FOR HIRE, pens this story, with artwork by Todd Nauck and Michael Ryan (the latter of whom draws only 4 pages). While the cover implies a Spider-Man/Punisher team up, and while such a thing does happen, it is mostly a story obligation as the narrative is really about the trials and tribulations of Craig Williams, football player for Midtown High. The story is dated during the JMS era of ASM, back when Peter Parker taught there, and Flash Thompson was involved in the athletic department too. Williams is a football meat-head, the type who gets benched for rough hits and snapping at his coach. His father is both verbally and, later, physically abusive, and Williams vents said frustrations by being a bully and, on the side, a drug dealer. He gets involved with some local Russian mobsters, and winds up caught in the middle of a raid by Spidey and Punisher. While Punisher, of course, breaks his promise to Spidey to only use "rubber" bullets (seriously, what'd Spidey expect), Williams idolizes the web-slinger after he prevents the Punisher from shooting him. Unfortunately, he has a falling out with his dad after the kid he bullied draws a gun on him, and Peter has to save his life. As time passes he becomes more of a thug for the Russian mob, and the next time he runs into the web-slinger, he doesn't get a second pass.

The art is good, although a bit where Craig fights his dad that is super-imposed on metaphorical images of Spidey & Punisher is awkward at best. To a degree the entire story is awkward, at beat. The POV of a random teenager whose life goes down a spiral is interesting in theory, but a lot of bits are plodding and obvious. The abusive father angle is supposed to elicit some sympathy, but in the end I saw Craig as a "thug" like Spidey did and thus couldn't feel especially sorry for him. Above all, I didn't see the point of this story besides to suck an extra $4.99 from hardcore Spider-Man, Punisher, or Ostrander fans - and if so, I guess mission accomplished because it got me. Maybe if Craig Williams pops up somewhere down the line in BIG TIME it could be interesting, but I don't really see that happening.

While this is technically a fine comic - the art is fine, the story isn't too bad and it has a clear beginning, middle, and end - it really only serves as the sort of comic that Marvel should really not publish if they want to lower costs and thus prices. John Ostrander needed eye surgery so if the paycheck from this script helped in that, that's cool I guess (there was a donation collection going around the Internet a year or two ago about that). Marvel have started to publish a few "from the vaults" releases of scripts and/or whole comics that they paid for but never published, so to a degree I wonder if this is one, too. At any rate, I can't recommend this to anyone but the most hardcore fan.
 
Debates about the notable flaws in Bendis' technique are why I never regret dumping his comics nor avoiding trying many of his new ones. I don't need that noise.

I will say, in fairness, I buy all of Bendis' stuff and have for a while. I may poke fun at his (glaring) weaknesses as a storyteller, but I can't deny that he entertains me. Sometimes unsatisfying, a lot of the times wishing that he'd tone down his Bendisisms, but the bottom line is entertainment. And that he does.
 
I will say, in fairness, I buy all of Bendis' stuff and have for a while. I may poke fun at his (glaring) weaknesses as a storyteller, but I can't deny that he entertains me. Sometimes unsatisfying, a lot of the times wishing that he'd tone down his Bendisisms, but the bottom line is entertainment. And that he does.

Here's the thing. Bendis' "glaring weaknesses" have been glaring weaknesses for at least 5-7 years, which at this stage is half his career at Marvel. If I was the #1 writer at Marvel and every single person on the Internet was saying, "Hey man, it would be nice if your dialogue could be relevant, if you didn't just copy and paste the last two words of what the previous speaker said like a computer program, if you figured out how to create suspense in USM without the star hero being unmasked or fighting someone who unmasked him, and oh, it would be nice if you at least scimmed Wikipedia so you could avoid glaring mistakes when you write big characters in Avengers", I would at least take some of their suggestions to heart and, I know this is a baffling concept, but improve upon my flaws. Instead Bendis gets snappy, snippy, and just repeats his flaws over and over until the next check clears. The problems I had with USM are the same problems I had from issue 30 well past issue 100. He has not improved one iota on his Avengers work and he's been coddled by editors into quality irrelevance. His bosses tell him how awesome his work is before he even writes it; why would he improve? Much as some people need "a good friend" to tell them when they're full of it, Bendis has needed "a good editor" to honestly tell him when his script had a character error, or a narrative error, or was just a festering pile of goat feces cynically submitted for a paycheck and to string along trade waiters, since at least 2006. His comics sell because they're important, not because anyone enjoys them. Marvel has sold them as important so long they are grandfathered in. And even despite all that, they've lost sales drastically over the past year.
 
I've had way too much wine to respond, so I'll just say that you're mostly right.
 
As someone whos been a fan of BEndis' work i gotta say even i'm starting to wear of the guy. But every now and then he writes something i really enjoy. I LOVED Siege. I thought it was by FAR marvel's best event. Hell, it was the only event that FELT like an event. Civil War was anticlimactic, Secret Invasion was...something, World War Hulk was disappointing etc. Siege was big and epic and had a satisfying ending. Bendis won back alot of points with me on that.

But...his Avengers books are dull as hell, nothing ever happens in them. I was actually HOPING that Thanos was the real deal in the latest issue because, well, how awesome would it be to actually have an epic villain like Thanos take on the Avengers in an Avengers book? But of course, Bendis disappointed again then. Although in fairness Bendis probably thought he was being clever but it would have been much better to just have Thanos there and battle the avengers.
 
Now between Deadpool MAX, Avengers Academy and Uncanny X-Force I'm having some trouble deciding which was the best book of this week. They're all great candidates but I'm gonna go with:

Deadpool MAX #7 - This book is so brilliant on so many levels. Lapham does such a great job with Deadpool as a character. He nails home the point that while DP is crazy, he's not stupid. This issue reveals what most suspected, that Domino MAX is Crazy Inez from issue 2. She's quite a memorable character and her basis is a slight rip-off of Typhoid Mary I suppose but it doesn't change the fact she's a fun character.

The scenes are real wacky and out there thanks to Kyle Baker's art. Deadpool daydreams of raising the perfect son in his own special way (hijacking tanks, defusing bombs, assassinations, ect.), and then believes the toy baby Inez was carrying around is real. At least it seems that way, it seems it might have been all a ploy by Deadpool to actually cure Inez which he succeeds doing to an extent.

Who the hell knows what actually went down, that's the best part of this book. Lapham sucks you right into the twisted mind of Deadpool and tosses in a single page of Deadpool vs. Yakuza carnage at the end, to remind us that even though major screws are loose, Wade is a extremely dangerous person. I think this book is due to end with #12 but I highly recommend all to pick up the trade when it comes out later this year. It's been absolutely brilliant.

Avengers Academy #12 - The best Avengers title hands down. Gage deserves a shot at writing the main title down the road. This book has some great character development and there's some major moves in this issue in that regard. And it's not just with the kids either, Gage has done some great stuff with Pym, Tigra and Speedball as well. The ending with Mettle and Hazmat was real touching. It's a going trend with this title looking back, the actual endings can be pretty powerful.

Uncanny X-Force #8 - This is some great filler material. It bridges the gap between The World arc and the upcoming Dark Angel Saga nicely. It seems Deathlok is the newest member of UXF, so it's interesting how this will alter the team dynamic. The Shadow King is someone who I never found as a great threat. Yeah, he crushed Xavier's legs back in the day but he's a psychic villain for the X-Men and they usually have the top 3-4 telepaths at their disposal. This time around he doesn't promptly get his ass kicked. Instead he is able to get the ball rolling with Archangel arc as a measure of revenge against Psylocke who's become his nemesis over the past 10 years. The ending was really well done as Archangel kills a soldier after the latter asks "who are you?" "It's a good question." replies Warren after he mows down the soldier. Great one-liner. Logan goes on to support Warren's decision not realizing what Betsy already knows, the Warren they know is lost. This continues to be the best X-title on the market with Uncanny X-Men storming right behind after 2 Fraction-less issues. I'm looking forward to Gillen and Remender restoring some glory to the franchise.

Wolverine #8 - The Wolvie goes to Hell arc wraps up, while it was decent, the problem was it that it was too long. This seems to be the 1st leg of the story as now Logan is going to go after the person who set him up. There's still questions to be answered from the first arc and it shouldn't take 8 issues to answer them. Aaron's stretching this out way too much. He should try and stick to his Punisher MAX pace, it's works out better in the end.

I also skipped the Fear Itself Sin book. It seemed like a waste of money, at least for me. It was a short prologue/epilogue sandwiched with a classic Cap story from 89, where Sersi (in a story that led to her becoming an Avenger a couple of months later) turns Cap into a teenager to help out track down Bernie Rosenthal's runaway sister. It led him to a "hate camp" led by Mother Night and Sin. It was an ok story from what I remember, it was mainly a "breather" arc for the upcoming "Bloodstone Hunt". I didn't see the need to get something I already own again. I guess I can recommend it to any newer reader interested in an older Cap tale.
 
As someone whos been a fan of BEndis' work i gotta say even i'm starting to wear of the guy. But every now and then he writes something i really enjoy. I LOVED Siege. I thought it was by FAR marvel's best event. Hell, it was the only event that FELT like an event. Civil War was anticlimactic, Secret Invasion was...something, World War Hulk was disappointing etc. Siege was big and epic and had a satisfying ending. Bendis won back alot of points with me on that.

But...his Avengers books are dull as hell, nothing ever happens in them. I was actually HOPING that Thanos was the real deal in the latest issue because, well, how awesome would it be to actually have an epic villain like Thanos take on the Avengers in an Avengers book? But of course, Bendis disappointed again then. Although in fairness Bendis probably thought he was being clever but it would have been much better to just have Thanos there and battle the avengers.

I find that the phrases "in all fairness" and "probably thought he was being clever" come up all to often in critiques of Bendy's work.
 
I skipped FEAR ITSELF: SIN'S PAST too, upon hearing it was just a series of reprints.

AVENGERS ACADEMY #12 was quite good, I agree. Gage did help with Slott's MIGHTY AVENGERS run, by writing one issue and co-writing a few more. He will write 1-2 ASM issues that will feature the cadets. But I do agree that he's quite good at what he does. He has a knowledge of history while still full of innovative new ideas. The fact that a series like this, in which the most "popular" character is probably Hank Pym and stars a lot of new characters, has lasted past a year in today's market is an accomplishment. I liked how this issue could still seemingly center on Veil yet still give notable moments to not just Mettle & Hazmat, but Striker, Reptil, and Pym. Finesse got the least of them, which is fine since she was the focal point of issue nine.

I am glad to see this much chatter about Academy. I am stunned I seem to the only one reading Thunderbolts now.

As someone whos been a fan of BEndis' work i gotta say even i'm starting to wear of the guy. But every now and then he writes something i really enjoy. I LOVED Siege. I thought it was by FAR marvel's best event. Hell, it was the only event that FELT like an event. Civil War was anticlimactic, Secret Invasion was...something, World War Hulk was disappointing etc. Siege was big and epic and had a satisfying ending. Bendis won back alot of points with me on that.

But...his Avengers books are dull as hell, nothing ever happens in them. I was actually HOPING that Thanos was the real deal in the latest issue because, well, how awesome would it be to actually have an epic villain like Thanos take on the Avengers in an Avengers book? But of course, Bendis disappointed again then. Although in fairness Bendis probably thought he was being clever but it would have been much better to just have Thanos there and battle the avengers.

In the era of $2.99 - $3.99 comics, eventually I realized that a ratio of one good to great issue against 3-10 mediocre, frustrating or outright bad issues is not a winning ratio to invest in. That is what finally got me to drop his Avengers books after over 3 years and what got me to leave USM, and so on. It is why I dropped Fraction's INVINCIBLE IRON MAN and why I didn't even give his THOR six full issues. Paying $3 for a book you either don't enjoy or have low odds of enjoying by that "good to suck" ratio is insane enough; paying $4 for such is borderline masochism. And I say that as someone who has been there.

To give credit, at least Bendis didn't throw a monkey-wrench into Abnett & Lanning's story by actually reviving Thanos. He very well could have, but didn't. That's at least some restraint.
 
Its really sad that whenever good writers start to gain a little fame, their quality dips substantially. Like they dont even try anymore. Its happening with Bendis, Millar, Fraction, JMS, Loeb (dont EVEN get me started bout this guy), even Brubaker is starting to become monotonous by treading the same old territory again and again and again (WHAAA? THERES A SECRET FROM CAP'S PAST COME BACK TO HAUNT HIM??). It's like they're just phoning it in at this point because, hell, they've already made it to the big time.And let's not even go into guys like Claremont and Miller.
 
Its really sad that whenever good writers start to gain a little fame, their quality dips substantially. Like they dont even try anymore. Its happening with Bendis, Millar, Fraction, JMS, Loeb (dont EVEN get me started bout this guy), even Brubaker is starting to become monotonous by treading the same old territory again and again and again (WHAAA? THERES A SECRET FROM CAP'S PAST COME BACK TO HAUNT HIM??). It's like they're just phoning it in at this point because, hell, they've already made it to the big time.And let's not even go into guys like Claremont and Miller.

I got into this with Tron Bonne a while back and my theory is that "something" happens in editorial when a writer reaches that "level". I could be wrong, but I would imagine writers lower on the totem pole have more editorial involvement and have more restrictions on what an editor might allow than the ones higher up on the pole. That isn't to say that every editor is a slave driver, but that it makes more sense that someone who sells in the Top 10 be given more free reign than someone who sells below the Top 80. As she mentioned, there also could be an element of working on a franchise so long that it becomes hot and now is "the big money work" and no longer the work you are as jazzed for. It's possible for some (which could be why Bendis is now going into his own stuff like BRILLIANT or TAKIO), but I don't think that's the answer for it all.

It was once joked that during the height of Claremont's time on the X-Men in the 80's, all an editor had to do was make sure he'd had lunch that day. They were selling like hotcakes and whatnot, so why mess with the golden goose?

I also believe, and this is just me being a crackpot, that the memory of Jim Shooter's iron fist style is sort a sore memory for a lot of long time Marvel people that many editors sort of want to be the opposite. Sort of like adults whose own parents were harsh and strict, who then have their own kids and go, "I won't treat them like my own parents treated me," and more often than not, end up making their kids into spoiled brats because there's little discipline. Joe Q brought the company out of bankruptcy into being worth over $4 billion to Disney during a recession, so it also could be seen as "don't mess with the style that saved us".

Now, that isn't to say that EVERY writer whose editor has a "hands off" approach for most of their scripts will automatically devolve in quality. But without that extra pressure, without that criticism, I think it is easy for many writers to fall into ruts, to not challenge themselves, and to get too into their own heads. There are writers who love the universes they write about so much that even when the training wheels are off, they're in no rush to mow it down. And there are others who feel they've gotten to this point because they're awesome, so to **** with what someone did in the 80's or last year, let's do it ______'s way. And variants in between, of course.

I just know as a human being, if I had a boss who didn't criticize my work, complimented me before I even did anything, and barely got involved in what I produced beyond helping with staples and maybe the odd typo, it would be very tempting to just slack, to not second guess myself as much, and so on. And I think this happens to a lot of human writers and this is why their output can seem to slack the higher up the chain they go. Especially when they reach that odd place where they're not an editor, but you can easily see Marvel firing the editor and not the writer if things go sour. At least with DC, Geoff Johns was officially promoted so his connection to DC brass is obvious. Bendis isn't an editor only because he doesn't want the position, because he dislikes the work schedule (which has been stated and joked about so many times whenever someone asks, I am fairly certain it is true). Which now places Bendis in this awkward position where he isn't an editor but is more important to Marvel than five editors. He's not the first writer to hit that position; Claremont and John Bryne had their day too, and Jim Shooter rose up the ranks too.

Anyway, that's just my theory on that. Either that, or there's a secret bathroom in the upper offices that releases Goblin Gas that makes A-List writers go mad. :word:
 
Last edited:
It's the Indiana Jones effect. Take him out of Raiders and everything still happens the same way. The nazis still get the Ark, open it up, and melt their faces off. Indy basically just jumps around a lot.

Haha awesome, I've never thought of it that way
 
I am glad to see this much chatter about Academy. I am stunned I seem to the only one reading Thunderbolts now.

I still read it and enjoy it. I just haven't yet. It just easily got lost in the mix of Pool MAX, AA and UXF this week. I was way too tired to read that and Hellblazer. They're gonna have to wait this weekend sometime between the Knicks playoffs and Easter.
 
I'm glad i'm not the only one who enjoys Deadpool MAX. Such a shame it got relegated to maxi series.

It really shows that Deadpool might be crazy, but isn't stupid. And the way he views things and does things is... unorthadox, to say the least.

Honestly for a while there I actually thought Deadpool thought the baby was real! But then as the story goes on, the pieces all come into place and it genuinely made me go "Ahh i see what you did there!"

Awesome book. Truly deserves more recognition. And i believe it would get it, if Marvel didn't spam the hell out of the character in the last couple years.
 
f you figured out how to create suspense in USM without the star hero being unmasked or fighting someone who unmasked him

Hasn't been like this for years, tho that might change now to this suspsense of him being unmask as Peter Parker changes his identity with presumingly Green Goblin telling the world who Parker is, so Bendis can set up the "Spider-Man: Brave and Bold" status quo where Parker is being trained by Nick Fury and teams up with other heroes, sounds familiar? Yeah it's the pitch Bendis has for the ULTIMATE Spider-Man cartoon. :)
His comics sell because they're important, not because anyone enjoys them. Marvel has sold them as important so long they are grandfathered in. And even despite all that, they've lost sales drastically over the past year.

How is Avengers then outselling Thor and Captain America? These characters are highly important with Fear Itself, Avengers will have tie-ins witrh Fear itself but Bendis top selling titles we never used to build up for this year's big event so why are they selling? Dark Avengers was a very liked comic and from what i gathered it might have been the highlight of Bendis' Avengers career. Also what about his creator owned title Scarlet which is top selling Icon book? Are you telling me that Icon is so important that people just buy all the creator owned material people put out?

You also keep telling that Ultimate Marvel is irrelevant thesedays, yet why is Spider-Man selling well and even getting higher on sales chart with the event going on? Are you perhaps going to tell me Ultimate Marvel is now important again? :p What about Bendis' upcoming Brilliant?

PS. Anyhow i really agreed on the "no arch villain" thing on Thunderbolts, perhaps they should get a chance to fight bigger named villains or having a AIM/Hydra as a big arc villain or so. I really hope Parker won't perma lose Man-Thing and Juggernaut, but B team looks intriquing. I think Mr. Hyde will be in more control of himself because the upcoming Fear Itself tie-in preview art showed Mr. Hyde all fancy-dressing cane guy, so perhaps the serum had nanonites to his brain to calm him down.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"