Cheese cake... Pie or Cake?

Johnny Drama

Sex Panther
Joined
Oct 14, 2005
Messages
12,278
Reaction score
0
Points
56
The debate that wages on between my friend and I has everything to do with Cheese Cake and whether or not this desert is a pie or a cake. I say pie, considering it is a custard like filling over a crust. Your thoughts?
 
I need some time to think about this. excuse me.

*leaves thread*
 
Cheesecake is my favorite food group :up:
 
Gerard Way said:
The debate that wages on between my friend and I has everything to do with Cheese Cake and whether or not this desert is a pie or a cake. I say pie, considering it is a custard like filling over a crust. Your thoughts?
hmmm. I agree.
 
Well, I just added a poll so feel free to chime in.
 
Its cake, why do they call it a cup cake if it isnt in a cup?
 
Gerard Way said:
Which is?
Superhero Hype! Forum Rule 41-A
"All discussion threads pertaining to food and/or beverage, are under the rule of Musclesforsupes. Anyone creating threads of said nature must be deemed by Musclesoforsupes a violation of his personal taste, and dealt with in a true Randor fashion."
 
Because it's baked and made with flour, both of which are absent from the Cheese Cake.
 
Gerard Way said:
The debate that wages on between my friend and I has everything to do with Cheese Cake and whether or not this desert is a pie or a cake. I say pie, considering it is a custard like filling over a crust. Your thoughts?
Well cake begins as a batter. You could also call it a batter ...
Sorry, just tryin to keep the party goin :D :up:
 
Another reason why it must be a cake...is because I wouldn't eat something called cheese pie or cheese custard. Eh.. :o :o
 
Gerard Way said:
Because it's baked and made with flour, both of which are absent from the Cheese Cake.
So are sheperd's pies really "meatcakes"? :confused:
 
Why does it matter? If its called Cheese pie, would it make it more delicious?
 
depends..what kind of pie and what kind of cheesecake
 
Gerard Way said:
The debate that wages on between my friend and I has everything to do with Cheese Cake and whether or not this desert is a pie or a cake. I say pie, considering it is a custard like filling over a crust. Your thoughts?


I agree, but Cheese pie sounds gross, so they use the name cake instead.
 
I'm a man that loves his cheesecake and every cheesecake I ever ate was made in a pie pan, so I guess that makes it pie.
 
didn't this thread already happen?

anyway, neither. the myth one.

but it tastes way better than sasquatch meat.
 
Gerard Way said:
Because it's baked and made with flour, both of which are absent from the Cheese Cake.


WRONG......A TRADITIONAL CHEESECAKE IS BAKED. AND WHERE THE HELL DID YOU GET THAT "CUSTARD" NONSENSE? :confused:
 
raybia said:
I agree, but Cheese pie sounds gross, so they use the name cake instead.


YEAH, CHEESE PIE IS TOO CLOSE TO "C**T CHEESE". :down:(
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
200,328
Messages
21,662,210
Members
45,469
Latest member
Arnold Rimmer
Back
Top