I would really like to do this. In terms of participation, we are kind of right on the point between enough interest and not quite there.
Never the less, I think I might give it a go. This weekend, I am going to put together an outline for the game and start recruiting players to fill holes.
One idea I had to fill holes is to kind of adapt two of the TV show's better seasons and do a Fans vs Favorites type. I think that would be a good way to restore the game and bridge the gap between classic Hype Survivor and a new generation. After all, you put a bunch of newbies who weren't even on the Hype when Survivor was played on a tribe with vets and the Newbies will get picked apart. In fact, I really believe that this is what caused the game to go stagnant. The same 5 or 6 people dominated every game. I think Fans vs Favorites format gives newbies a chance to find their footing in their own tribe and let's veterans compete with each other at a high level, right off the bat.
But for that to work, I would need a tribe of all newbies (which would run the risk of the players losing interest, quitting, etc) and a tribe of all veterans. But I'd want it to be quality vets. I would love to see some combination of Erzengel, JewHob, Spider-Fan, Hunter Rider, and CC on that tribe. If I could get commitments from a few of them, I think my interest and motivation in crafting the game would increase exponentially. Hell, just talking about it in that format gets me excited. So let me have the weekend to start reaching out to those who expressed interest and recruiting others and we'll see what happens!