I hope this is in the movie

[eledoremassis02]

This is probably one of my favorite flash backs from X2

 

[TNC9852002]

Yeah, I was mentioning that a few days ago..

-TNC

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Well, i'd say it's gonna be. Hard to do a wolverine origin movie without it, y'know?

 

[eledoremassis02]

well it's hard to say, since in X2 striker says "I even gave you claws" and well in the trailer,

So I thought this scene was because he's a horrified because what he had done, not to mention the pain he's in because he used his claws for the first time, and is in horror that there even there.

 

[Wesley Dodds]

Yeah, Logans claws are bone... This makes sense. What Styker is saying is "I gave you adamantium claws"...

 

[Spider-Vader]

"I even gave you cool claws"

 

[TNC9852002]

Well, let's assume that continuity here is addressed.

One theory:
Wolverine can't technically REGROW limbs and bones, so, my guess is that in some point, Wolverine breaks and loses his bone claws. By the time he's.."recruited" by Stryker, he gives him the kind of claws that can never be broken. I guess this would be a benefit to Logan since his original claws were very special to him.

-TNC

 

[protocida]

In the Benniof's script, Sabertooth breaks Wolverine's bone claws. He signs up for the Weapon X project to get indestructible claws.

 

[Peter McCabe]

In the Benniof's script, Sabertooth breaks Wolverine's bone claws. He signs up for the Weapon X project to get indestructible claws.

That was definitely changed because Logan still has the bone claws when he signs up for Weapon X during vietnam.

*The whole "I gave you claws" Stryker X2 thing could just be misinterpreted.

He wouldnt wanna tell Logan anything crucial at that point, since he was trying to seduce Logan once more into joining him.

 

[sniktsnakt]

Well, let's assume that continuity here is addressed.

One theory:
Wolverine can't technically REGROW limbs and bones, so, my guess is that in some point, Wolverine breaks and loses his bone claws. By the time he's.."recruited" by Stryker, he gives him the kind of claws that can never be broken. I guess this would be a benefit to Logan since his original claws were very special to him.

-TNC

??? He regrows his claws all the time in the comics after Magneto pulls out his adamantium . . . .

 

[Peter McCabe]

??? He regrows his claws all the time in the comics after Magneto pulls out his adamantium . . . .

Yeah, technically he's indestructible in the marvel universe.

I think the only reason Sabertooth died after getting his head chopped is because the brain could no longer instruct the body to regenerate being unattached to it.

I wouldn't be surprised if he can regrow limbs and bones.

 

[sniktsnakt]

Yeah, technically he's indestructible in the marvel universe.

I think the only reason Sabertooth died after getting his head chopped is because the brain could no longer instruct the body to regenerate being unattached to it.

I wouldn't be surprised if he can regrow limbs and bones.

Well, since Deadpool has a healing factor given to him by Weapon X and can regrow his head so long as it's reattached or whatnot, I figure both Sabes and Wolvie should be able to as well.

The whole "magic sword made out of a part of Wolverine's soul" did the trick.

Edit: Took the words right out of my mouth, Congo Jack.

 

[Congo Jack]

I think the only reason Sabertooth died after getting his head chopped is because the brain could no longer instruct the body to regenerate being unattached to it.

It was actually because of the Muramasa blade which inhibits both Wolverine and Sabretooth's healing factor. Yes, they powered up Wolverine so much they hd to give him his own version of Kryptonite.

 

[Peter McCabe]

It was actually because of the Muramasa blade which inhibits both Wolverine and Sabretooth's healing factor. Yes, they powered up Wolverine so much they hd to give him his own version of Kryptonite.

The man is hard to kill.

 

[BMM]

Well, since Deadpool has a healing factor given to him by Weapon X and can regrow his head so long as it's reattached or whatnot, I figure both Sabes and Wolvie should be able to as well.

The whole "magic sword made out of a part of Wolverine's soul" did the trick.

Edit: Took the words right out of my mouth, Congo Jack.

 

[TheZink]

I haven't kept up on ALL of the recent comics but I had always wondered did Logan perhaps actually forget he had the claws?

I mean with the way his memory seems either a) be wiped or b) just black out as a result of his healing factor pushing out psychological trauma it would seem entirely possible he could have woken up and forgotten about the claws.

Then the whole weapon X thing happens and as a reaction to the adamantium they pop out and Logan pretty goes "wtf did you do to me?!"

 

[sniktsnakt]

Exactly.

 

[Peter McCabe]

Exactly.

At the least the covers for Wolverine 55 were great.

I would have preferred a fight to the death, no magical crap, no mentally challenged Sabretooth, no pity/guilt trip on Wolverine's part.

 

[Congo Jack]

I haven't kept up on ALL of the recent comics but I had always wondered did Logan perhaps actually forget he had the claws?

Yes.

 

[TNC9852002]

Excuse, but did someone say that there's a mutant that can REGROW HIS OWN HEAD?

WTF?

-TNC

 

[Congo Jack]

Excuse, but did someone say that there's a mutant that can REGROW HIS OWN HEAD?

WTF?

It's not that he can regrow it but once it is placed on the body it can reattach itself and start binding together again.

 

[Peter McCabe]

Excuse, but did someone say that there's a mutant that can REGROW HIS OWN HEAD?

WTF?

-TNC

Ever seen Species II?

That was an alien though.

 

[sniktsnakt]

Excuse, but did someone say that there's a mutant that can REGROW HIS OWN HEAD?

WTF?

-TNC

Well, Deadpool can reattach his, and Wolverine once supposedly regrew out of a single living cell when the world got blown up. . . . which I'm not sure how that works, since then there should be a whole lot of little WV clones running around.

I'll get a pic of Deadpool, if you like. Give me a few minutes.

 

[Legion]

Well, let's assume that continuity here is addressed.

One theory:
Wolverine can't technically REGROW limbs and bones, so, my guess is that in some point, Wolverine breaks and loses his bone claws. By the time he's.."recruited" by Stryker, he gives him the kind of claws that can never be broken. I guess this would be a benefit to Logan since his original claws were very special to him.

-TNC

I've said several time before that I hate bone claws and I'll tell you how I feel about this theory. My biggest problem with bone claws in this film has to do with Sabretooth and Wolverine's fight immediately after Silver Fox's death.

In the comics when this story was first told Wolverine didn't have any claws and he got the beating of his life. After Stryker said in X2 that Wolverine volunteered for the experiment we could assume that in the origin movie, an event like that would be Wolverine's motivation for going through the procedure.

The thing is though, when Wolverine found out he had bone claws, he was still able to defeat all of his enemies and his healing powers and senses were stronger than ever. So it's hard for me to imagine Wolverine losing to Sabretooth so incredibly bad with the bone claws that he would choose to get an adamantium skeleton. Sure breaking bones still hurts alot even when you can heal, but when your bone claws can already cut through metal and you can regrow bone, limbs, etc...it makes the adamantium seem not as important.

If Wolverine can't grow bone back, his claws and other bones break, he chooses to go through the procedure, then that might make alitte more sense. So I like this idea better, it sounds like an idea Claremont had for the character that Wolverine had broken all the bones in his body and he couldn't heal bone so had them replaced with adamantium. It also sounds a bit like Archangel's origin too.

So I kind of like that idea but at the same time I feel if they introduced the bone claws and made him lose them for good, why put them in at all?

 

[Congo Jack]

Well, Deadpool can reattach his, and Wolverine once supposedly regrew out of a single living cell when the world got blown up. . . . which I'm not sure how that works, since then there should be a whole lot of little WV clones running around.

He didn't...well, he did, but with the help of a big magic freakin' crystal. This misconception comes from people either not having read the original comic, or not understanding it.