JLA vs. The X-men

[Hole Shot]

What makes you think that Batman could beat Wolverine? Please give me an explanation becuase I'm not buying the prep time thing. Wolverine would cut Batman to bits and pieces. He is stronger faster and more of a hunter. I don't want to hear about prep time cuase it doesn't always work. The only reason he beat Superman is becuase of kryptonite.

Bat-Wolverine Repellent. DuH!

 

[MagicPrime]

Beat is different than Kill.

The punisher beat wolverine by shooting him in the crotch with a shotgun and parking a steamroller ontop of him.

So Batman could just fight and dodge wolverine, place a beacon on him, and have the Batwing crash right into him. Kill him? no - knock him out for a while enough for batman to be considered the victor? I think so.

 

[Damiean Dark]

I actually think Wolvie would win his over a century of experiance would be too much for bats he wins on every front: agility, strentgh, stamina, has a animal sense of hearing and smell, perfect for hunting and tracking. in a straight battle wolvie wins.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

He also fights like a barroom brawler nine times out of ten. I know he's supposed to have lots of training, but he rarely ever is portrayed using any of it.

 

[CaptainClown]

I think Bats best bet of survival for a fight with wolverine would be swinging around wolverine until someone else declaws kitty.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Or he could just hit him with a bunch of exploding batarangs, leaving Wolverine to heal off on the sidelines for a few minutes.

 

[CaptainClown]

oh ya that, there are quite a few ways Batman could beat Wolverine is the overall point though.

 

[KAD]

He also fights like a barroom brawler nine times out of ten. I know he's supposed to have lots of training, but he rarely ever is portrayed using any of it.

Except when fighting another accomplished fighter

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Like the Punisher? Or Sabretooth, who soundly kicked his ass numerous times? I'm not saying he's never portrayed as a good fighter, but the instances he's not seem to outweigh the times he is to me. I haven't read Wolverine comics in years, though, so he may be fighting like a world-class martial artist all the time now.

 

[Anubis]

Nope, still a boozed up slasher.

 

[trustyside-kick]

I hate when that happens. So and so is supposed to be such a skilled fighter, and then of course he never shows it. I guess it would require the artists for such characters to have to be familiar with certain martial arts to fix this, huh? That would certainly up the criteria the next time an artist wants to tackle one of the proclaimed awesome fighters.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Well, no, it would require the writers and artists to at least devise a scene where Wolverine doesn't run in front of someone much stronger and more powerful than he is and try to slash them with reckless abandon, only to get tossed away like nothing for his troubles. I don't need to see authentic martial arts moves to consider someone a good fighter. I need to see them not get knocked around with ease by everyone they fight.

 

[Infinity9999x]

Like the Punisher? Or Sabretooth, who soundly kicked his ass numerous times? I'm not saying he's never portrayed as a good fighter, but the instances he's not seem to outweigh the times he is to me. I haven't read Wolverine comics in years, though, so he may be fighting like a world-class martial artist all the time now.

Nope, they still write him like he has no training. In fact, they write him like a glorified punisher now. He doesn't even try to restrain his berserker rages anymore, and they barley talk about his honor and all that. Add that onto the fact that now he can apparently heal back from just a skeleton...yeah they've pretty much F*ed up his character.

Now, if it's today's Wolverine fighting Batman, then Batman is in trouble because Wolverine basically can't be killed because his healing ability is at ridiculous levels now a days.

If Wolverine is written the way he used to be, then he would definitely not have as much of an edge in regards to the whole healing factor, but he would also fight with much more skill.

Either way in a confrontation where they just meet up and start fighting, then I'd say Wolverine would win because Bats isn't going to be chucking bat-grenades at him because he doesn't know that Wolverine will live. If Batman has his all powerful prep time, then it would be a different story.

 

[Damiean Dark]

Whats that graphic novel when Wolvie fights spiderman? the one when he is protecting some girl from assasins i remember reading it yonks ago wolvie held his own against someone way out of his leage in terms of speed, strentgh, stamina ect its the way people write that perticular character at a particuler time.

 

[sandwraith]

Maybe we should try two different teams of JLA and X-Men considering the number of inactive members both groups have.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Well, if you're gonna include inactive members, the JLA expands to include virtually the entire DC superhero community, while the X-Men expands to include lots of mutants but not much else.

 

[moraldeficiency]

Whats that graphic novel when Wolvie fights spiderman? the one when he is protecting some girl from assasins i remember reading it yonks ago wolvie held his own against someone way out of his leage in terms of speed, strentgh, stamina ect its the way people write that perticular character at a particuler time.

It was Spider-Man vs. Wolverine. The end fight was pretty good. Pete held back but then was forced to go all out. He had a shot to kill the furball but he couldn't do it, then wolvie had him but let him go. It ended with pete actually killing the girl by mistake. Pretty good read.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

I've never liked fights like that. The idea of someone like Wolverine even being able to keep up with someone like Spider-Man, let alone give him a good fight, makes no sense to me.

 

[Silicon Surfer]

Wolverine didn't give Spidey a good fight in that story. All he did was endure the beating Spidey gave him. Spidey beat on him at will and Wolvie couldn't lay a claw on him.

 

[nimrod]

I've never liked fights like that. The idea of someone like Wolverine even being able to keep up with someone like Spider-Man, let alone give him a good fight, makes no sense to me.

Well said.

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

I've never liked fights like that. The idea of someone like Wolverine even being able to keep up with someone like Spider-Man, let alone give him a good fight, makes no sense to me.

Yet.... he was made to fight the Hulk. How ironic.

 

[Flash Facts]

Yea, I hate it when popularity overrides all logic and the character's actual powers. I remember reading some magazine in which fans voted who would win in a fight between various superhero and thinking wtf! Most of the outcomes made no sense, people with no powers beating metahumans ect. As a matter of fact I think Wolverine beat The Flash in it.

 

[TheCorpulent1]

Yet.... he was made to fight the Hulk. How ironic.

Yeah, he was a terribly conceived character on that basis.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Just like Wolvie beating Lobo...

 

[moraldeficiency]

Wolverine didn't give Spidey a good fight in that story. All he did was endure the beating Spidey gave him. Spidey beat on him at will and Wolvie couldn't lay a claw on him.

That's about right.