• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Just the facts, ma'am: Bought/Thought for June 15, 2011. Spoilers may be involved.

TheCorpulent1

SHAZAM!
Joined
Jun 20, 2001
Messages
154,474
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Avengers Academy had perhaps its best issue this week. The conflict in Pym and Tigra over protecting the kids and protecting civilians by sending the kids out to war was handled really well, with both Steve Rogers and and Maria Hill (two military-minded soldiers) noting that young kids have been sent to die in every war in the history of the world. It's a hard fact that takes some measure of callousness to cite, but it's true. I think the best trait of this issue is that it's done a better job than anything else related to Fear Itself--including the main mini-series itself--of showing that Sin and the Serpent have unleashed a full-scale world war. This isn't just your usual superhero/supervillain dust-up. Yes, the fact that there are magic hammers amping various characters up to Thor's level all over the world implies that, but it only does so on an intellectual level. This issue of AA tackles it on the level that counts in narrative fiction: the emotional level. You can feel the conflict in Pym and Tigra's handling of the students, you can feel the fear in the students themselves, you can feel the desperation across the superhero forces. Gage and Raney have done an excellent job of drawing me in and making me feel like I'm right there in the hopeless situation that FI only implies. It's issues like this that really make me come down on the side of character-driven storytelling over its spectacle-driven counterpart. You can have stuff blow up every five seconds, but it's only when you devote the time to getting into the characters' heads and seeing their reactions to all of that that it actually becomes compelling. To me, anyway; others' mileage may vary.
 
My eyes almost fell out of my head when Fear Itself: Youth in Revolt started with a recap of Tarene's origin. I never see s*** from Dan Jurgens' Thor run referenced. So that was a nice start. The rest of the issue is pretty good. Tarene is (kind of) willingly placed under arrest for her role in the accidental death of a cop in the first issue and, of course, the fact that she too wields a hammer. Ultra Girl is reassigned to help Gravity and Firestar take down Crossbones, one of the many escapees from the Raft. His appearance was a nice little treat, although the heroes make pretty short work of him. Hardball and Kimodo basically just hang out in Vegas for a while. Apparently Hardball decided to wall himself up on the strip, make that secure, and relax--until Prodigy calls, warning him that he needs to step up and stop the Juggernaut, who's on his way there as they speak. That should be fun to see next issue. Meanwhile, Tarene, who was supposed to be released as soon as Prodigy believed the public was satisfied, ends up at the mercy of some shady government-types who believe her relationship to Asgard means she must have information concerning the Worthy. Cloud 9 busts in and saves her, though, and she looks quite stylish in her new Amelia Earhardt-esque costume. Cue next issue.
 
Fear Itself: Youth In Revolt #2

This is the only Fear Itself tie-in I've read so far; as, I must admit I actually gravitated to the Flashpoint tie-ins first this week. I did go for this first, because it's one of the books that I enjoyed. I've always been a huge Thor Girl fan, and I'm glad she's getting some star treatment with this book. Great to see some of my other favorite characters appearing, too...like Cloud 9.

Pretty good issue. McKeever is so lucky to have such a large playground of young characters to play around with; and, I can't wait for the next issue. I'm also happy to see this is a six-issue mini, and I wouldn't mind seeing it expand after Fear Itself is over. :yay:


Flashpoint Titles!!!

Legion Of Doom #1

Get the bad over first...because, the other three books blew me away! This one is garbage. First, it makes NO SENSE that the current Firestorm (with Ronnie and Jason) would still be around in this version. If something in the timestream was messed with, how do they still get together?? Nope, this is one of those issues that just isn't that well thought out. For this Legion Of Doom, that old hooky structure still exists; but, it houses all the villians within its prison walls. The villians aren't interesting...and, since I read this Flashpoint issue last, it paled HUGELY in comparison to the others. :dry:

Grood Of War One-Shot

My favorite of this batch...and, I'm SOOOO peeved that it's only a one-shot! Sean Ryan did a great job of letting readers know how Grood fits into this world; and, the art is fantastic...and, bloody! Pick it up, because it's the first Flashpoint title that's getting my top rating. :woot:

BTW, with those getting your buttons. I got a Emerald Warrior Button for this book, and not the insignia on the cover. Did you guys get the same?

Wonder Woman and the Furies #1

Looking at this issue, I was not aware that Abnett and Lanning were writing it. OH BOY! Another great Flashpoint title, and everything you need to know about how Wonder Woman and Aquaman met...and, what leads up to their battle that destroy's Europe.

How did DC get Abnett and Lanning?? How in the holy heck do they even have time for ANOTHER TITLE??!?? Another fantastic issue. I have to give this another :woot:!

Deadman and the Flying Graysons #1

Not as fantastic as the two previous titles, but still pretty darn good. Can't wait to see what happens next issue, as the Amazons are after Dr. Fate's helmet. (He's part of the traveling circus...and, that fits perfectly in this story. Much better thought out book than Legion Of Doom, that's for sure.) Things don't look too good for Robin. Can't wait for the next issue.

Not my top rating, but still worthy of two :yay::yay:.

Kirby Genesis #1

Good first issue...although, the book suffers slightly from giving the reader too much. (That was one problem I had with Project Superpowers.) So many new characters, but at least we have two earthlings that the story is centered around. I'm excited for the next issue...and, the art looks fantastic. :yay:

Captain America Corps #1

Fun first issue. The concept sure doesn't feel like anything new. Elder of the Universe tries to warn Uatu of how different realities are having Captain America disappear from them; thus, changing all history. Uatu doesn't think it's that important...before he completely disappears; so, the Elder goes through realities and time to get 5 different versions: U.S. Agent, American Dream, Commander A of the Future United Americans, Steve Rogers (during early WWII), and Bucky-Cap (bet the writer wasn't expecting him to be killed off before his mini started).

Roger Stern does a good job, and the price is right. Just don't expect a lot of originality. :yay:
 
Avengers # 14: Actually surprised the hell out of me. Bendis managed to Balance the talking head crap with great action. Even JRjr's art was bearable. The actual story was essentially a reversal of World War Hulk, only having a Hulk defend New York instead of destroying it; with Red taking on the worthy controlled Ben Grimm. Despite never doing any work with Hulk characters before, Bendis managed to write a really cool Red Hulk and inject some energy into the book. I may just stick with series post-fear itself.
icon14.gif


Batman # 711: The Two-face story continues this month, with Harvey surving his encounter with Gilda and gaining help from an unlikely source, while Grayson plays catch up. Not quite as good as the last issue, but still pretty interesting. Daniel does a great job capturing Harvey's instability and desperation after losing his coin, though I'm not really liking Cat-girl and the multiple sidekicks that Daniel keeps creating. a Good comic but not a great comic.

Hulk # 35: Loved it. Jeff Parker is really proving himself to be one of the best writers going around. This is the second part of the 2 part "Planet Red Hulk" story arc, which features Red Hulk arriving on some strange alien world which is going to war with a neighbouring planet. At first one could dismiss this story as just a cheap rip off of Planet Hulk, but Parker manages to create an entirely new beast that can both work as its own thing or as a great companion peice to Greg Pak's original masterpiece. What truely makes this better is Carlo Pagulayan's great world building work, he manages to draw gigantic Hulking brutes and large scale alien battles almost without effort. truely the best series Marvel is putting out today.
 
Small week, but a solid week. Spoilers abound.

DREAD'S BOUGHT/THOUGHT FOR 6/15/11!

INVINCIBLE #80: Having skipped May, Robert Kirkman's long running creator owned superhero series reaches another high round number. While the schedule for the supplemental mini series GUARDING THE GLOBE has gone off the rails, this title continues to be on it's usual pace of shipping 8-10 issues a year (aside for 2009, where it actually shipped monthly). With the Viltrimute War behind us and the title hero, these past few issues have been seeking to play catch-up with the lives of the supporting cast back on earth. This is actually a good and perhaps overdue thing. Mark Grayson's friend William, for instance, has had more panel time for these past two issues than he's gotten in almost two years. Ryan Ottley's pencils continue on their usual pace of excellence, and while Nikos Koutsis' colors are fine, it takes some getting used to. As the cover suggests, one of Invincible's newer enemies - Dinosaurus - marks a return here. Much as Kirkman is using this time to dust off Mark's earth-based cast, he also is addressing the problem of there being few enemies who seem able to challenge Mark anymore unless they are of his alien Viltrimute heritage - or are the dimension hopping Angstrom Levy, who appears infrequently. Between Dinosaurus and SUPER-DINOSAUR, Kirkman is coming close to waring out his welcome with the prehistoric reptiles in a similar manner that some writers over-use the appeal of gorillas, cyborgs, zombies, or ninja. Quite a lot is packed into these 22 pages, due to many of them having as many as 12 panels apiece. Thus, in 22 pages Kirkman is able to pack in quite a few conversations between characters as well as get in a major fight sequence without things feeling rushed. Suffice it to say Dinosaurus proves to be a worthy threat to Invincible and the world, and in a manner that is unexpected - his mind (or at least cunning). The TECH-JACKET back-up strip by Kirkman, Aubrey Sitterson, and artist E.J. Su also wraps up, after having two issues off. The cliffhanger revelation of the previous issue does come up, but it is a very delicate subject which is naturally something to deal with apart from super-action. Plus, Invincible actually TALKS a super-criminal out of a heist!

The only negative is a half page sequence where Kirkman has his comic-loving hero talk to a comic shop clerk, which ends with a bit which seems very much like Kirkman once again shaking his finger at the "big two" for recent editorial stunts. While it is probably deserved, and Kirkman does poke some fun at himself, it can come off as hypocritical coming from a writer who cashed paychecks from Marvel for a large chunk of his career and currently earns heftier pay with an AMC TV show. While some readers have felt this title is in a rut, I believe this title is a perfect marriage of the enjoyable tropes of superhero comics with the leeway of a creator owned comic, in which anything can truly happen. While some issues and stretches are better or worse than others, this remains a solid investment for any reader who even remotely enjoys superheroes who doesn't enjoy having to buy seven titles to enjoy a franchise.

AVENGERS ACADEMY #15: This is the second issue to ship this month, after the .1 issue at the top of June, and the first in a lengthy stretch that ties into Marvel's latest event, FEAR ITSELF. It will be a five issue crossover, one of the longest durations for many Marvel ongoing titles. While sales have been steady for this title for the past 3-4 months at over 23,500 copies, Marvel likely does hope for a boost for some of these issues. This may be possible, but such a sales boost will likely be modest - the days when a crossover could boost an ongoing title by notable means for more than a single month likely ended with SECRET INVASION in 2008. Which actually is a shame in this case, because AVENGERS ACADEMY remains the best Avengers title Marvel publishes. Christos Gage has hit a stride with this title that has proven superior to even his best work on AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE - which was exceptional in itself by the end. In that title, Gage had to ride with the waves of one crossover tie-in after the next, whether with co-writer Dan Slott or alone. Every time, he managed to wrangle a good if not great story out of it, and this issue is no exception. He uses the event as a backdrop to continue telling stories with his characters, and develop long-term themes and subplots. Thus, the reader who may only be reading this does not feel lost, or cheated. After several issues of Sean Chen's artwork, Tom Raney returns for this issue and likely the next few, alongside Jeromy Cox on colors and two inkers.

The key information is that the Raft, a prison full of super-villains, has been smashed open at the same time as attacks by superhumans across the globe are sowing fear and chaos. They are all slaves of "evil Norse hammers" that have been sent by "The Serpent", who grows stronger with the chaos. One of them, Sin, the daughter of Red Skull, has attacked Washington, D.C. with an army of Neo-Nazi in giant mechanical exoskeletons. Overwhelmed by the siege, Steve Rogers asks Giant-Man if he and his cadets are ready for a war zone. Begrudgingly, he says yes. While prior encounters with the demigod Korvac or the Sinister Six have tested the skills and integrity of the young cadets, this proves to be unlike anything they have trained for. Their instructors, particularly Pym and Tigra, hate to have to be the ones who lead them into battle, and perhaps their deaths, but have no choice but to do so. The events naturally cause the characters to relive some of their most painful moments, from Tigra losing her husband to Striker's fear of death, and Mettle's fear of causing death. Pym is eager to quickly defeat Absorbing Man, who has also been empowered by a hammer, but his rush to do so (to save his cadets) may spell his own doom.

The problem with FEAR ITSELF as a story is that it has very little of one - it merely offers a lot of combat and explosions with very little actual meat to encourage people to care. This is a problem that this tie-in deftly avoids. Gage tells the reader all they need to know about the event for context and scene building, but makes it about his characters. He does an equally terrific job of selling the danger of the event, and the threat they are facing. The cadets, in Washington D.C. are being thrown into something akin to 9/11, while the sheer power of "The Worthy" is stressed heavily. It is a struggle that not only won't be easy to survive, much less win, but clearly will be one with casualties. The point that people as young as the cadets have been sent to wars both currently and throughout history is also stressed as an unpleasant reality. While Pym and Tigra clearly get the lion's share of focus out of the adult mentors in most issues, Gage is able to utilize them in ways many writers haven't in years, or ever. He also is not afraid to break his own original cadet characters down and show us what they are made of, or not made of. While Tom Raney is not a "house hold name" artist like some are - even Sean Chen was best known on IRON MAN in the 90's - he handles the combat scenes and facial expressions very well. It has to be a challenge drawing a character with a skull for a head having an emotional reaction to something, but Raney pulls it off.

While this entire series has had subplots, this five issue stretch will actually be one of the longest arcs the series has yet had. This issue provides an exceptional story to kick off that stretch. Gage is a writer who can turn virtually any editorial backdrop into at least a readable story, if not a great one. AVENGERS ACADEMY #15 accomplishes the latter and looks to continue being a "must read" book for Marvel fans of good taste despite tying into the Crossover Du Jour. If Marvel were serious about newer, younger readers, they'd make sure back issues of this series were at their digital shop, pronto. With as intense an issue as this, it is difficult to imagine where the next will lead - as it should be.

ALPHA FLIGHT #1: Believe it or not, this is technically the second issue of this latest attempt to relaunch Marvel's Canadian super-team; ALPHA FLIGHT #0.1 went on sale on May 18th. Not only has "The .1 Initiative" been used to try to drum up interest in long running ongoing series by producing an extra issue of it, it is being used to promote new mini or ongoing series (like GHOST RIDER) before they have official debuted. Thus, it was a "zero" issue, only trendier - everything has a dot in it these days. At any rate, with writers Greg Pak and Fred Van Lente aboard - the masterminds behind the classic INCREDIBLE HERCULES/FALL OF AN EVENGER/PRINCE OF POWER/CHAOS WAR/HERC run - this is a must buy for anyone curious about reading more great Marvel comics. Along for the ride on this eight issue series is artist Dale Eaglesham, fresh off great runs on FANTASTIC FOUR and STEVE ROGERS: SUPER SOLDIER. He is ably joined by inker Andrew Hennessy and colorist Sonia Oback. A spin off from UNCANNY X-MEN launched in 1983, the first volume lasted 11 years and 130 issues; thus, it seems in Marvel's vested interest to keep trying to revive it. This will be the third go at it - the fourth if you count the 2005 mini series OMEGA FLIGHT, which was a spiritual successor. For this attempt, however, Pak and Van Lente settled on something which has become extraordinary and rare with a relaunch of a B or C list franchise that once was a mainstay - they have re-assembled the founding characters best known by the franchise's fans as well as their key interrelationships. If one is thinking, "it would be madness to revive a franchise without such elements", then one hasn't paid attention to prior ALPHA FLIGHT relaunches - or, for that matter, the last few NEW WARRIORS or NAMOR relaunches. This proves to be a winning formula as Guardian, Vindicator, Shaman, Sasquatch, Snowbird, Marrina, Northstar and Aurora unite to protect Canada from one of "The Worthy" from FEAR ITSELF. This is a contrasting comic to AVENGERS ACADEMY #15, as the tone of the fight sequence is fairly light hearted despite the incredible danger. Unlike many American heroes, Alpha Flight are generally loved and respected by their country, and get on with what they do best. Unfortunately for them, Northstar seems to only want to be a part-time member, and a shift in their country's political system may soon make them outlaws of the government. An interesting bit is that the married couple Guardian and Vindicator (Mac and Heather Hudson) are operating together for the first time in a dog's age; often one or both of them are dead at any given time. The one glaring missing member is Puck, which is an absence alluded to and may have to be addressed once the character escapes Hell in WOLVERINE. The founders all act as one would expect, except for Marrina. She has been redesigned and become a bit of a "punker", embracing her alien heritage and dressing in a more distinct sea attire. To a degree it is similar to Warren Ellis' approach to Machine Man in NEXTWAVE, although not taken to such an extreme. It is a bit awkward to see, but given how Marrina has often spent her days as Namor's bride, dead, or a monster, she probably is entitles a personality shift. At the very least, she always had a nasty temper.

While promoting this as a FEAR ITSELF tie in is more pragmatic than spectacular, Pak and Van Lente manage to do a great job with some neglected and dismissed characters. While Christos Gage can wring an impactful story out of FEAR ITSELF, Pak and Van Lente succeed in the opposite - providing a fun, wise-crack laden story with it; at least until the end. The pair can shift tone in their work from slapstick to serious on a dime and make it look easy; such a talent will serve them well here. If one has been burnt out on teams like X-Men or Avengers, this option north of the border is more than worthy. The only drag is the $3.99 cover price. If Marvel wasn't willing to charge that much for POWER MAN & IRON FIST, why do so for this?

FEAR ITSELF: YOUTH IN REVOLT #2: Former GRAVITY, TEEN TITANS, and YOUNG ALLIES writer Sean McKeever and artist Mike Norton (along with Lauren Gandini’s colors) continue on their FEAR ITSELF spin-off title that covers all of the young heroes from the Initiative. So much so, in fact, that it remains bizarre why Marvel didn’t simply call it FEAR ITSELF: AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE to sell an extra few thousand copies. Marvel isn’t afraid to have extra long titles that tenuously stretch a franchise’s name to sell a book, such as AVENGERS: THE CHILDREN’S CRUSADE: YOUNG AVENGERS #1 or about half of all X-MEN spin-off’s. Sadly, Marvel is a company that needed four months to figure out calling something AVENGERS ACADEMY GIANT SIZE was more “sellable” than ARCADE: DEATH GAME. While Christos Gage has created the spiritual sequel to AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE in AVENGERS ACADEMY, the characters from the Initiative have mostly fallen into McKeever’s hands.

As the Thor-powered minions of “The Serpent” rampage across the world, including a devastating attack by Sin on Washington D.C. and Juggernaut’s rampage across America, massive unrest is rampaging out of control. Former SLINGER Prodigy has been put in charge of a new, volunteer Initiative that comprises of most of the last iteration’s graduates (as well as any spare young hero standing around). While the intentions are good, as always with the Initiative, things seem to go wrong. The alien Tarene, who usually goes by Thor-Girl, is unfortunately stuck as being the scape-goat to the chaos around her when a riot goes wrong and a cop is killed. She is manipulated into surrendering to custody over it, and finds out that while Prodigy may have genuine intentions, government agents merely see her as a suspect. This brings us into one quibble that I had with this issue; it is the recap page that states that the police officer who was injured in issue #1 was killed – the artwork in the prior issue in no way made that obvious; he was shot in the shoulder area with his ricochet.

Meanwhile, the distraught Gravity and the experienced Firestar continue to lead a squad of heroes in New Jersey, and they run into one of the escaped super-villains from the Raft – one of Captain America’s worst enemies. When things go horribly wrong, Gravity makes quite a decision. Meanwhile, Hardball and Komodo take stern control of Las Vegas, and Hardball’s general quest to be an a-hole is interrupted by the task of trying to stop the Juggernaut. Cloud 9, who has sought to remain retired from “costumed” life due to a healthy distaste of the Initiative, slaps together a new costume to save her friend.

Thor-Girl is a character that one would have expected to have seen more of, but has been scarcely seen for a few years, and has never gotten this much focus in an even longer period of time. The one handicap is the fact that the “Thor-Girl” who was in half of AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE was revealed as a Skrull in SECRET INVASION, yet quite a few of the characters, like Ultra-Girl and Cloud 9, act like they’ve all been pals forever. At any rate, the fact that Dan Jurgens’ origin for Tarene from his oft forgotten run on THOR was referenced was a wonder in itself. Another drawback is that while the series has central characters, they are often fighting for panel time with an onslaught of cameo characters like Geiger and Frog-Man, and that can irritate some readers. I, on the other hand, love those sorts of cameos so it remains a treat for me. Heck, even the new clone Scarlet Spider (not the infamous one) gets some panels here!

On the downside, any fight with one of “the Worthy” minions of “The Serpent” seem obligatory, especially since they probably cannot lose unless it is in the “core” mini series or a more “important” spin-off series, which this likely isn’t. There also is a modest underlying message of “civilians and government officials are not worth saving” that sometimes seems to come to mind unintentionally, but this is less so than in some of the Speedball strips in FEAR ITSELF: THE HOME FRONT.

Overall, this is a great series for people who like newer, younger characters as well as seeing more obscure characters get panel time, and get GOOD panel time. While McKeever and Norton will likely continue to develop their character Gravity more, others will naturally will get some needed focus too. While most of the spare FEAR ITSELF mini’s, like FEARSOME FOUR, are not worth the cash, this one definitely is.
 
Only One More:

FEAR ITSELF: THE HOME FRONT #3: Another installment of this 32 page anthology mini series focused on the fringes of FEAR ITSELF. It merges stuff like FRONTLINE with anthologies like I AM AN AVENGER or AGE OF HEROES - more the former since it has a few serial strips.

The lead 14 page strip continues to be the Speedball story by Christos Gage and Mike Mayhew, with Rain Beredo. This is a satisfying chapter, if only because the BLEAKNESS button is turned off. The only quibble is that it happens too quickly. For a recap, Speedball has been exposed in Stamford, Connecticut, which is an area where he is loathed for the "incident" that cost 600 lives (most of them kids). Despite only seeking to volunteer at the charity run by "face of the opposition" Miriam Sharpe, the masses of Stamford have sought to pummel, beat, and lynch Speedball at every turn. Whether he is just standing there or defending them from criminals, all they seek is his death. Yet all Miriam has to do is offer a speech, albeit while holding a shotgun, and all of a sudden everyone's a friend again. Oh, no hard feelings, Speedball, let's help you up. While I understand the point of this strip is to have Speedball and Sharpe come to an understanding - which happens here - the transition is awkward even for Gage. Sharpe, however, coerces Speedball to use the Infinite Mansion's doorways to defend towns across America where there is no police, military or superhero presence - despite his eagerness to help his Academy cadets. While the intention is decent, it does make Sharpe come off a bit like a hard-ass. Speedball deflects the Juggernaut and goes after Attuma, but it seems none of "The Worthy" can lose in any book that isn't FEAR ITSELF or INVINCIBLE IRON MAN (or maybe Bendis books).

The Peter Milligan/Elia Bonetti/John Rauch Jimmy Woo story continues, and I can't stand it. While I imagine Jeff Parker isn't the only writer who can write Woo and his AGENTS OF ATLAS in an enjoyable manner - Paul Tobin managed it in some back-up strips in HERCULES: FALL OF AN AVENGER - but Milligan isn't it. The story is awkward and the way the characters are chatting feel even more so. I'll be glad when this is over.

Howard Chaykin continues on his "pointless one page story" run, and this time focuses on an unlucky tourist caught in France when Gray Gargoyle turned them all to stone. Ho-Hum. His strips have consisted of such "shockers" as J.J. blaming stuff on superheroes and Purple Man escaping the Raft. While the latter will likely come up in HEROES FOR HIRE, this is very close to welfare - paying Chaykin for stories that really serve no other purpose.

Which leaves Ben McCool and Mike Del Mundo's Cardiac story. He's a character who hasn't shown up in ages - I think his last appearance was in Kirkman's MARVEL TEAM UP, circa 2005. The story is simple; Cardiac is trying to sow some chaos in the streets, when he comes across an injured father and child in a car. The father, however, is the sort of corrupt executive whose actions in business have led to deaths which have gone avenged. A part of him doesn't want to save his son, who he sees as guilty by association. Cardiac eventually reconsiders, but that hesitation proves to be critical. It's not a bad story, but a bit predictable. When McCool talked about this story online, I came close to guessing how it would go, and I wasn't wrong. Still, it's better than the Milligan and Chaykin strips. Cardiac is a vigilante who targets white collar criminals more so than street level ones, which makes him an interesting vigilante who appears far too infrequently. A future issue will have Fred Van Lente create a teen team of the new Power Man and Thunderstrike alongside Spider-Girl, Amadeus Cho and X-23, which sounds incredibly awesome. Sadly, we still have another month of the Milligan strip. Still, this month sees 2 hits to 2 misses, so that's about even.
 
Actually, dread, you forgot (which isn't a bad thing) to count the 2003 attempt at Alpha Flight, so this is the fourth, technically fifth, attempt.
 
Actually, dread, you forgot (which isn't a bad thing) to count the 2003 attempt at Alpha Flight, so this is the fourth, technically fifth, attempt.

Right.

And to think, it took this many to get it right.

Seriously, how hard is it to relaunch a franchise with all the elements/characters it did best and that they're best known for? Yet with Alpha Flight that's been rare, and with New Warriors, it's been rarer.
 
Wonder Woman and the Furies #1

Looking at this issue, I was not aware that Abnett and Lanning were writing it. OH BOY! Another great Flashpoint title, and everything you need to know about how Wonder Woman and Aquaman met...and, what leads up to their battle that destroy's Europe.

How did DC get Abnett and Lanning?? How in the holy heck do they even have time for ANOTHER TITLE??!?? Another fantastic issue. I have to give this another :woot:!

They're doing another Flashpoint book, Lois Lane and the Resistance. They're also doing a revival of one of their older heroes with the 52 relaunch in September, Resurrection Man.
 
Deadpool MAX 9.

Another great issue. Such a shame that this series tanked and got turned into a maxi series. It deserves to be an ongoing, more so than Daniel Way's garbage.
 
They're doing another Flashpoint book, Lois Lane and the Resistance. They're also doing a revival of one of their older heroes with the 52 relaunch in September, Resurrection Man.
Looking forward to Resurrection Man. I first learned about him in the One Million stuff and always thought that was a cool concept for a character.

I mean, it's obviously gonna sell like s*** and be canceled inside of a year, but I'm still looking forward to it.
 
Uncanny X-Men #538: Let's start with this summation: based on his first example, Kieron Gillen writes a damn ****ty X-Men comic. It's not Milligan-bad, but it's not even close to the caliber of writing the titles have had across the board for the past couple years, at least.

This issue ends his first arc, and it's good that it's over. Hopefully his continued work will get better, but with everything moving toward Schism, there's a good chance his next arc before the event will also be "high-stakes." And that doesn't bode well.

The entire arc was built on a ridiculous presence, continuing with more and more silliness as it goes by. We have all the staples of stupid storywriting, too: heroes who have no clue, a villain who is totally mwa-ha-ha wicked except he doesn't actually want to do anything really threatening. Throw in some light Slasher flick tropes. What a delicious combination! At least Gillen carried through and the ending is as ridiculous as the rest of the arc, and as meaningless.

The only thing to come out of this arc is Kitty getting to be a real girl again. Yep. Three or four issues (whichever it was) to get one character out of a ****ing spacesuit.
 
I seem to be realizing that certain writers seem to get assignments in Marvel that revolve around doing the "dirty work" of either resolving subplots and/or doing a sloppy cross over tie in that some of the more "hot shot" writers don't want to do.

For example, Nick Spencer doing the 3, and ONLY 3, issues of SECRET AVENGERS that are FEAR ITSELF related? Why? Because neither Brubaker or Ellis were interested. And while Spencer is making a name for his creator owned MORNING GLORIES, at Marvel his rank is little above a writer who does MARVEL ADVENTURES stuff nobody reads or appreciates. Even if, ironically, most of the writers who toiled for years on MA stuff before getting more "mainstream" assignments have turned out to be really good and efficient writers. The MA are like a minor league farm system, and maybe they create better writers than some fancy pants duded recruited from another team's star roster.

Gillen seems to find himself in a similar role. His run on THOR was basically to fill time between JMS and Fraction, more "important" writers. He got more time than expected and got to invest in some of his own subplots. Of course, he also had the task of wrapping up that whole Clor/Ragnarok clone cyborg thing because nobody else wanted to. He also had to write the obligatory SIEGE crossover that made JMS flee, and Fraction wasn't going to come in time to do. So, now that I see that he's done similar things on UXM, such as resolve subplots like Breakworld (left over from Whedon's AXM run) or ghost-Kitty that Fraction or no one else wanted to get to, it makes me wonder if certain writers exist to be hench-men who do the dirty business the more "fancy pants bigger names" don't want to derail their epic Eisner masterpiece of generic storytelling to do. Or if certain writers just rely on that stuff for narrative ore, and some don't. It just seems certain writers, like Gillen, seem to write these sorts of things more often than others.

Abnett & Lanning, who are good but lower level than Fraction or Bendis, seem to be taking a similar route with their NEW MUTANTS run. Of course, it could also be the X-Men franchise is a minefield of unresolved plots to slog through for brainstorm sessions.
 
There was no need to touch anything Breakworld at all. Better yet, if he'd wanted to, he could have done that when he was writing SWORD. He didn't have to "deal with" spacesuit-Kitty anymore than any writer had to - to which I'll add that Gage has used her in his Astonishing story, still in spacesuit, with ill effect.

Even then, really shouldn't take that much to figure out a way to "solve" her problem, and it certainly shoudn't take 3-4 issues of suck.

Rather, there are two points to form in reply:
Gillen wrote a bad-bad X-Men story.
Abnett and Lanning wrote a very good first issue and in it made a conscious decision regarding team focus for that title.
 
Actually, as a fan of Gage, I found his first issue of AXM to be a pretty mundane affair. It wasn't bad but it wasn't great, and when his second issue debuts there is a part of me that will have to consider whether $4 for "meh", even for a writer I like elsewhere, is worth it.

Gage perhaps struggles with the X-Men; he wrote WORLD WAR HULK: X-MEN in which he was tasked with writing 3 issues of the Hulk fighting all of the X-Men in which neither side could be effected or impacted in any way. It was sort of a page filler, but readable. It had Andrea DiVito on art, who's far stronger than whoever is on Gage's AXM issues.

The elephant in the room is a disproportionate amount of normally talented writers on other franchises have struggled to imitate that success on the X-Men post M-Day in 2005. The tragedy is so long as Joe Q has some pull and Marvel Editorial remains a group of friendly yes-men who can't find fault with each other, none of them will see that maneuver for what it is, nor see it's effects soberly. It is a status quo that robs the X-Men of their central metaphor and leads to no story but reversing it to some degree - which Marvel eventually conceded with Hope and her GENERATION.
 
I loved Gage's first issue of AXM. It felt like a continuation of SWORD, which is probably why you didn't like it, Dread. As I recall, you didn't have the good taste to adore SWORD like the cool kids. :oldrazz:
 
I loved Gage's first issue of AXM. It felt like a continuation of SWORD, which is probably why you didn't like it, Dread. As I recall, you didn't have the good taste to adore SWORD like the cool kids. :oldrazz:

Three things eliminated any desire to read SWORD:

- Agent Brand is a lifeless character I can't stand; she's Maria Hill only with a more memorable design.
- The artist made Beast look like some sort of aardvark sheep thing, which is bad since he was a starring character
- At the time, I didn't know Gillen very well. By the time his THOR run was in a stride, SWORD was canned.

Gage's AXM issue just felt like another Brood story to me - which in itself is limited because all the Brood can do is mindlessly imitate ALIEN, which inspired their creation (ALIEN debuted in 1979; the Brood in 1982). It follows a trope - go in, kill some Brood, find some survivors, WHOOPS, they're all infected, either cure or kill them. There are some variations, and it was intense the first few times, but like with anything, over-use kills it. This is the second Brood story in AXM within the past year, I believe.

His first issue had it's moments, but for $4 my expectations are much higher. Heck, even some of the central logic of the story was off. Beast assembles a team of X-Men to handle the Brood crisis at SWORD because he feels it is too sensitive a mission or whatnot for his Secret Avengers allies. Are you kidding me, Henry? Your SA allies literally went to Mars to investigate Roxxon having a weird statue. They'd be unwilling to help you liberate a righteous intergalactic organization from fanged monsters? For a "secret team", Steve Rogers has no qualms jumping into Roxxon offices without a mask or gloves, nor did they shy away from landing in China in broad daylight to stop a terrorist attack. He'd have been better off claiming that the X-Men have more experience fighting the Brood than any Avenger, but Gage didn't.
 
Last edited:
I never read SWORD, but Gage's AXM was a good issue. Bubillo was on art, I believe, and while his art has some muddy qualities, as I wrote in the B/T thread the week the issue came out, his art isn't as bad as some people in the thread were claiming it was. All the guy really fails at is clean art for a few characters, but panel-work and page-energy exist in high amounts. Regardless of art, however, I was talking only of the writing portion - you know, Gage's portion of the comic. It's not the greatest thing since sliced bread, but it doesn't fail at any point. It picks up some pieces from other writers, it doesn't step on toes, and it never becomes a point where it exists on the premise that the heroes are stupid.

What all happened with House of M has nothing to do with today's X-franchise, outside of "it happened and we did some stuff with it and here's what comes after." This idea that House of M somehow destroyed the X-franchise is silly, though it does make a wonderful talking point for nay-sayers, so I understand that. No offense, Dread. I respect you, and I usually make a point of reading all your reviews, but you're worse than a conspiracy theoriest going on about Elvis and aliens and JFK with some of these talking points. :) If anything, House of M eventually paved the way for some strong stories at the hands of capable writers. Yes, if they'd continued down the path of Morrisonian-X that would most likely also be true, but that's a giant what-if and not worthy of consideration.

It's not "Oh the sky is falling and the franchise is floundering because the previous CEO was a big ****bag." Is it so hard to consider that some writers have flaws, whether because they try too hard, want to do something so big it doesn't work out well, or just do not work well with some characters or tropes? Not all writers are professional - some want to work with their favorite characters, and that can come out great or poor. Some writers are strictly professional without caring who they're writing. And some writers - most, probably - are a mix in between.

No writer is getting shafted. Certainly Gillen is not getting shafted by being put on the "biggest" of the X-books. But Remender is writing a better comic over in Uncanny X-Force, and what's this? He's "cleaning up" some of the Archangel stuff from Yost&Kyle's X-Force, not to mention using Morrison's Fantomex (better than Jason Aaron did, might I add), re-introducing Dark Beast, and using the Age of Apocalypse. Abnett and Lanning wrote a better comic in their debut of New X-Men than Gillen did in his. Mike Carey's X-Men: Legacy is month-in and month-out one of the better X-titles. And even though people loved griping about him, Fraction's Uncanny was just fine on a writing level.

And then we have Gillen, who brings up Breakworld at a point that is now so long after - how many years has it been since Whedon's Astonishing wrapped up? - that there is no need or excuse for it. That can be solved by producing a capable and serviceable story, which he did not do. He did exactly what the other X-writers have done - bring something in of his own accord, to do with as he would - but executed it in a very poor manner.
 
Gage's AXM issue just felt like another Brood story to me - which in itself is limited because all the Brood can do is mindlessly imitate ALIEN, which inspired their creation (ALIEN debuted in 1979; the Brood in 1982). It follows a trope - go in, kill some Brood, find some survivors, WHOOPS, they're all infected, either cure or kill them. There are some variations, and it was intense the first few times, but like with anything, over-use kills it. This is the second Brood story in AXM within the past year, I believe.

His first issue had it's moments, but for $4 my expectations are much higher. Heck, even some of the central logic of the story was off. Beast assembles a team of X-Men to handle the Brood crisis at SWORD because he feels it is too sensitive a mission or whatnot for his Secret Avengers allies. Are you kidding me, Henry? Your SA allies literally went to Mars to investigate Roxxon having a weird statue. They'd be unwilling to help you liberate a righteous intergalactic organization from fanged monsters? For a "secret team", Steve Rogers has no qualms jumping into Roxxon offices without a mask or gloves, nor did they shy away from landing in China in broad daylight to stop a terrorist attack. He'd have been better off claiming that the X-Men have more experience fighting the Brood than any Avenger, but Gage didn't.
That line you're referencing by Beast, once again, seemed very much tongue-in-cheek in the way it was written.

And no, there has been no other Astonishing Brood story. There were some Brood present in the very-delayed last arc by Warren Ellis, in the way they were present for an issue in an attempt to trap/kill the team, I believe, but it wasn't a Brood story per se.
 
Didn't Beast basically say that the X-Men are his family while the Secret Avengers are just teammates? That's why I figured he went to them. If the guy's primary concern is rescuing his girlfriend, he'd want family at his back rather than just any old team.
 
I never read SWORD, but Gage's AXM was a good issue. Bubillo was on art, I believe, and while his art has some muddy qualities, as I wrote in the B/T thread the week the issue came out, his art isn't as bad as some people in the thread were claiming it was. All the guy really fails at is clean art for a few characters, but panel-work and page-energy exist in high amounts. Regardless of art, however, I was talking only of the writing portion - you know, Gage's portion of the comic. It's not the greatest thing since sliced bread, but it doesn't fail at any point. It picks up some pieces from other writers, it doesn't step on toes, and it never becomes a point where it exists on the premise that the heroes are stupid.

What all happened with House of M has nothing to do with today's X-franchise, outside of "it happened and we did some stuff with it and here's what comes after." This idea that House of M somehow destroyed the X-franchise is silly, though it does make a wonderful talking point for nay-sayers, so I understand that. No offense, Dread. I respect you, and I usually make a point of reading all your reviews, but you're worse than a conspiracy theoriest going on about Elvis and aliens and JFK with some of these talking points. :) If anything, House of M eventually paved the way for some strong stories at the hands of capable writers. Yes, if they'd continued down the path of Morrisonian-X that would most likely also be true, but that's a giant what-if and not worthy of consideration.

It's not "Oh the sky is falling and the franchise is floundering because the previous CEO was a big ****bag." Is it so hard to consider that some writers have flaws, whether because they try too hard, want to do something so big it doesn't work out well, or just do not work well with some characters or tropes? Not all writers are professional - some want to work with their favorite characters, and that can come out great or poor. Some writers are strictly professional without caring who they're writing. And some writers - most, probably - are a mix in between.

No writer is getting shafted. Certainly Gillen is not getting shafted by being put on the "biggest" of the X-books. But Remender is writing a better comic over in Uncanny X-Force, and what's this? He's "cleaning up" some of the Archangel stuff from Yost&Kyle's X-Force, not to mention using Morrison's Fantomex (better than Jason Aaron did, might I add), re-introducing Dark Beast, and using the Age of Apocalypse. Abnett and Lanning wrote a better comic in their debut of New X-Men than Gillen did in his. Mike Carey's X-Men: Legacy is month-in and month-out one of the better X-titles. And even though people loved griping about him, Fraction's Uncanny was just fine on a writing level.

And then we have Gillen, who brings up Breakworld at a point that is now so long after - how many years has it been since Whedon's Astonishing wrapped up? - that there is no need or excuse for it. That can be solved by producing a capable and serviceable story, which he did not do. He did exactly what the other X-writers have done - bring something in of his own accord, to do with as he would - but executed it in a very poor manner.

The X-Men seem to certainly have a lot of loose ends that need tying up, is all. There was some potential with the Breakworld, at least if someone had written them beyond being knock-off Z'Nox like Whedon did. They're like Colossus' Morlocks, only aliens.

Gillen taking over UXM is his biggest assignment, next to his THOR run.

I thought M-Day was a bad idea when it was started, and I don't think it made writing the X-Men any easier. Immediately afterward, Brubaker and Milligan spent their X-runs avoiding it for a year. Peter David on X-FACTOR was the only writer who tried to dive into it head on at the onset. Ever since, it seems the X-Books have bounced from one status quo to the next every year. I see that as a lack of editorial direction. Marvel thinks it keeps things "fresh", but it also keeps things from being allowed to breath. Who cares about the next X-shake up when they're shook up every year? But, to each their own.

That line you're referencing by Beast, once again, seemed very much tongue-in-cheek in the way it was written.

And no, there has been no other Astonishing Brood story. There were some Brood present in the very-delayed last arc by Warren Ellis, in the way they were present for an issue in an attempt to trap/kill the team, I believe, but it wasn't a Brood story per se.

Right.

I didn't read the line as tongue-in-cheek.

Didn't Beast basically say that the X-Men are his family while the Secret Avengers are just teammates? That's why I figured he went to them. If the guy's primary concern is rescuing his girlfriend, he'd want family at his back rather than just any old team.

Beyond the fact that, by obligation, it HAD to involve an X-Team, that barely holds water. Beast has known Valkyrie and Steve Rogers for years; hell, he was an Avenger throughout the 70's and involved with them and the Defenders for a chunk of the 80's. You could argue they're about as much family as Lockheed and Kitty are, since he hung around them more often while Kitty was fresh. Beast didn't return to X-stuff full time after the end of the initial "volume" of UXM in 1970 until X-FACTOR #1 in fact, which was 1986. He was really a part-time X-Man from the 1970's until then. Yes, Beast was the Wolverine of the late Silver Age - the member who popped up all over.

You could argue that if Beast's girlfriend is really in danger, he'd want professionals, not close "family" members who are easily traumatized. Storm freaks out in closed spaces and Colossus once went berserk with memories of his brother the first time he went into space. Kitty is also caught in her ghost-form, at least as of that story.

I mean I get it - it couldn't be an ASTONISHING X-MEN story if Beast just asked his SECRET AVENGERS buddies to help him - but it felt like a wonky way to justify a story expectation. A simple, "my Avengers buddies were busy in _______" would have sufficed.

I'm a big Gage fan. I only got that AXM issue because of him and I don't like disliking his work, as wonky as that sounds. But I won't lie and say I thought the issue was more than it was. No, it wasn't bad, but for $4 and an X-Men story I was underwhelmed. Instead I got a very generic Brood set up story with a few notable story beats, the Kitty/Lockheed reunion in particular. Storm and Colossus just seem there to fill the numbers, Piotr especially. Which for $2.99 would be okay, but for $3.99 on a title I haven't bought in years, it has to knock my socks off.

Anyway, must've been a slow week if the most heated topic of discussion becomes a comic from a few weeks ago. ;)
 
Last edited:
I've not had the chance to do my reviews this week due to work and all that, but I will say this... I thought Uncanny X-Men was the BEST of the week.

Generation Hope was also surprisingly good :up:

I picked up Kirby Genesis since I liked Project Superpowers so much but I don't know what I think yet. This has the makings of a good story but I'm honestly not huge on the Kirby designed characters. I'll decide if I continue the book once the next issue comes out.

And sadly, I forget what else I bought :(
 
The X-Men seem to certainly have a lot of loose ends that need tying up, is all. There was some potential with the Breakworld, at least if someone had written them beyond being knock-off Z'Nox like Whedon did. They're like Colossus' Morlocks, only aliens.
The only potential Breakworld needed was to work for the story Whedon told, which it did. That's all it ever needed to do. It never needed to be a re-used piece of canon.

If it's truly a flawed creation, that it was brought back in speaks poorly of Gillen's judgment and taste.

I've not had the chance to do my reviews this week due to work and all that, but I will say this... I thought Uncanny X-Men was the BEST of the week.

Generation Hope was also surprisingly good :up:
Generation Hope was good - better than it started out. Gillen's going somewhere with it, and he seems better with characters of his own design, even if they have little personality of yet.

But man, if you thought Uncanny was the best of the week - what crap do you read? :oldrazz:
 
Generation Hope was good - better than it started out. Gillen's going somewhere with it, and he seems better with characters of his own design, even if they have little personality of yet.

When the "Five Lights" arc of Uncanny was coming out I didn't like them. Then when they got their own title I was just bored. But around issue 3 or 4 I started getting curious and now I'm liking the team. I'm curious what comes of them.

But man, if you thought Uncanny was the best of the week - what crap do you read? :oldrazz:

Apparently the awesome smelling kind because Uncanny was fantastic! Though that might have more to do with how manure-ific the title's been since Fraction came on. Even good smelling crap is mouth watering after that years-long steaming pile of monkey turd.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"