Rogue One Michael Giacchino to score 'Rogue One'

Gonna be honest, I wish Alexandre Desplat stayed. I like Giacchino, for sure, but I feel we could have gotten something new with Desplat instead of sticking so close to Williams' cues.

Imagine something like this playing on the team's ride to Scarif:

[YT]https://youtu.be/4-2AM8FuI_w[/YT]

(https://youtu.be/4-2AM8FuI_w)

I kind of agree. On one hand I like the attempt to keep the music of the spinoffs in line with the rest of the music stylistically, but on the other hand I think going "all the way" in terms of giving this a different tone could've paid off nicely. Of course you could still nest in a few classic cues with this approach too, not sure if Desplat was doing that or not.
 
It’s not as memorable as any of the John Williams’ scores...but the “Your Father Would Be Proud” track is heartbreaking.

I thought it was solid and Star Warszy in style, which worked well. "Hope" is my favourite piece, but that is probably because it is one of the pieces that most directly apes Williams' musical language.

People may think I am crazy when I say this, but one of the things that I think that separates Williams' OT scores (and I guess the rest of his peak 70-80s work) from the rest is the arrangements (if that is the right term?).

His choice of different classically symphonic instruments for different parts added so much texture to the original scores. For instance, go back and listen to the original TESB version of The Imperial March and its got all those wonderful little flourishes that separate it from the more generic version used since and in particular in other media.

In contrast, the prequel scores and TFA sound more generically symphonic (for lack of a better descriptor) in some ways. They feel smoother, less dynamic, and feel like they have less texture. Rey's Theme is an obvious exception. The use of the flute and chimes in isolation as punctuation feels more like classic Williams.

Giacchino's score had some really strong moments and it is clear that he understand Williams' style, but it lacks the clarity, texture, and surprising quality of the classic OT scores.
 
That sounds very unlikely. Desplat is one of the best film composers out there, especially for emotional themes. His score for Deathly Hallows Part II is so beautiful it's almost painful. I don't think any of Giacchino's scoring here resonated emotionally to me, the movie sure did, but the score was just a backdrop.

I agree completely. DH part 1 had some amazing action music where Desplat was channeling Williams' more modern style (the brass flourishes in "Sky Battle" and "Fireplaces Escape" are very Williams-esque), where Part 2 poured on the drama and action.

Giacchino did a fine job on "Rogue One", considering the compressed schedule, and pushed the right emotional buttons. His handling of Williams' material was sloppy in places, but he tried his best. It works beautifully in the film, I don't know if I'll buy the album.

Desplat would've written a different score, the dramatic material would've been subtle but more emotional (Jyn and Cassian's final scene and Jedha's destruction, for example). The action music would be more forceful but more structured and clarity to the orchestration. I'm not sure how much of Williams' themes he would've used outside the main theme and the Imperial March. Giacchino tended to overdo the thematic references.
 
Listening to it again, I still am not crazy about it. However, Vader's slaughter track is amazing.
 
Okay, so I've been a bit down on this score but I just listened to the Star Wars: Oxygen podcast over at RebelForce Radio doing part 1 of their analysis of this score, and it's already making my appreciation for it grow. A lot of clever things Giacchino snuck in, and I'm trying to judge it as its own thing rather than comparing to Williams so much.

If you're really into the music of Star Wars I seriously recommend that podcast, go all the way back and listen to all of them. The analysis they give is pretty astounding and honestly makes you just fall in love with the saga even more.
 
I listen to music when I workout a lot, and I really grew to love TFA's score beyond belief. I will say I've warmed to it a little, not as much as the previous. I think some of the themes are good.
 
I thought it was solid and Star Warszy in style, which worked well. "Hope" is my favourite piece, but that is probably because it is one of the pieces that most directly apes Williams' musical language.

People may think I am crazy when I say this, but one of the things that I think that separates Williams' OT scores (and I guess the rest of his peak 70-80s work) from the rest is the arrangements (if that is the right term?).

His choice of different classically symphonic instruments for different parts added so much texture to the original scores. For instance, go back and listen to the original TESB version of The Imperial March and its got all those wonderful little flourishes that separate it from the more generic version used since and in particular in other media.

In contrast, the prequel scores and TFA sound more generically symphonic (for lack of a better descriptor) in some ways. They feel smoother, less dynamic, and feel like they have less texture. Rey's Theme is an obvious exception. The use of the flute and chimes in isolation as punctuation feels more like classic Williams.

Giacchino's score had some really strong moments and it is clear that he understand Williams' style, but it lacks the clarity, texture, and surprising quality of the classic OT scores.

That Williams choice, he's been going through a more dramatic period ever since Schindler's List. His music has been subdued, not as epic etc... both due to age and by choice.

And I mean the prequel scores use flutes, woodwinds, and have clear textures and clear counterpoints as well. So it's not like he hasn't forgotten how to score a Star Wars film either. It's just intentionally a bit different, not to mention that the prequel scores were also badly edited into the actual films themselves, which is something that Williams has openly acknowledged he wasn't happy with.
 
Overall I thought the music was fairly good. I think it could have been a bit more subdued though. Giacchino was clearly trying to be a bit too epic. Also the handling of Williams themes was perhaps a bit sloppy.
 
Last edited:
This was an interesting look at the score and composition:
[YT]SGVqPP-52No[/YT]
 
Last edited:
Film Symphony Orchestra - R1
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"