Movie Roles that would have been amazing if someone else was Cast

[The Guard]

Eddie Murphy's Winston in GHOSTBUSTERS.

Kidding, kidding.

 

[SuperFerret]

Eddie Murphy's Winston in GHOSTBUSTERS.

Kidding, kidding.

You'd better be kidding, 'cause I'd find you.

 

[Schlosser85]

I am not saying he is ugly, but he is certainly NO model like Hayden! And, he looks like he just play Bad guys!

So Anakin could only have been played by a guy who looked like a model, regardless of the model's acting ability?

 

[Sawyer]

So Anakin could only have been played by a guy who looked like a model, regardless of the model's acting ability?

Yeah, seconded.

 

[[A]]

..this is like people asking for a wrestler to play a character, just because of their size

 

[SuperFerret]

So Anakin could only have been played by a guy who looked like a model, regardless of the model's acting ability?

Of course, didn't you see the ball of sex that was under Vader's armor at the end of Return of the Jedi?

 

[bullets]

If he hadn't had died, Brandon Lee would've been a great 'Neo' in the Matrix flims.

Nothing against Reeves but that would of been amazing.


Topher Grace would of been a good Peter Parker and Bryce Howard as Mary Jane.



I think Jonathan Brandis would of been a good Anakin . I'm glad Leo turned it down , he is a good actor , I just didn't see him in that role. Neither would Bale or Ryan Phillippe worked IMO. I thought Hayden's acting was the misdirection of George Lucas mainly . Definately would of preferred Brandis. I dont think Aaron Stanford was known at the time or would of been possible but i'm not agaisnt that Idea.

 

[bullets]

You guys just don't get Anakin who he REALLY was meant to be, in GEORGE LUCAS' head. NOT yours, NOT any Fanboys, but the Star Wars CREATOR's own!

George Lucas didn't make this movie just so he could sit alone at his Ranch and watch it.

 

[gazi]

I'd recast and rewrite the whole film, but Patrick Stewart as Mr. Freeze instead of Arnold.

 

[Schlosser85]

..this is like people asking for a wrestler to play a character, just because of their size

Like Tyler Mane as Sabertooth?

Tyler Mane as Creed vs. Liev Schreiber as Creed should be proof enough that looks aren't everything.

 

[TheFuture]

I am perfectly aware that that's how Lucas intended Anakin, but the combination of Christensen's wooden as a board acting and Lucas' ridiculously melodramatic and corny dialogue is what people are complaining about, not the character itself.

Not even a change of actors in the second SW trilogy could have saved the day due to Lucas's incredibly inept dialogue.

 

[Eggyman]

I hate fanboy moaning. It's course and gets everywhere