So I gave this a shot and I'm enjoying it. The sharp wit and clever humor of Williamson and great Craven writing and direction are sorely missed but this show is enjoyable and so is the mystery. It takes more than mere meta writing and pop culture references to succeed at being a great Scream story.
This is my first MTV scripted show and I get it's MTV but **** -- everybody is so damn good looking. Even Noah is a very well articulate speaker with a great expository voice. They all look like models wearing designer clothes. They're all so good looking. There of course was sex appeal in the films, but they felt like real teenagers down to what they wore, 90's clothing aside. Craven directed them in a such a way where it just felt casual, and even if they weren't teenagers, in that context it worked. Here it looks like in the casting notices it said, "HIRING GOOD LOOKING PEOPLE WHO CAN READ THESE LINES BUT ALSO HAVE PERSONALITY." It's just not subtle.
The mother is late 30's but is clearly older because I don't think MTV would want certain parents to be too old.
And of course the lesbian and/or outcast is wearing black and has short hair.
And Piper looks just as young as they are. Except she's wearing glasses so I guess she's smart and she's a hip podcaster.
But all these flaws aside, I'm enjoying things. My number one suspect is Brooke. I do like the idea of the stupid blonde girl cliche actually being the killer which Scream hasn't dealt with yet.