MTV developing Scream series

[smallville fan]

Oh look it's another Charles DiLaurentis situation all over again.

 

[BH/HHH]

Poor episode that one, the whole visions thing with Emma was ridiculous and convenient way for them to move the plot along.

I'll admit my theories aren't panning out right now because if it us say Kieran then he's banged his sister and how would the Sherriff not know?

 

[Sithborg]

Didn't think about the incest stuff. Would be funny if they went there though.

Kieron probably isn't Brandon James' kid, but that doesn't mean he isn't one of the murderers. Piper, Brooke, and Kieron are my top picks for the killers.

 

[BH/HHH]

Didn't think about the incest stuff. Would be funny if they went there though.

Kieron probably isn't Brandon James' kid, but that doesn't mean he isn't one of the murderers. Piper, Brooke, and Kieron are my top picks for the killers.

Funny? Suppose that's one way to look at it t:

I don't think it's Brook at all, I still think Jake stabbed himself and is one of the killers.

 

[Sawyer]

Weird that they still haven't circled back to Audrey having a picture of Brandon James on her wall.

 

[BH/HHH]

Weird that they still haven't circled back to Audrey having a picture of Brandon James on her wall.

Oh yeah I forgot about that

 

[Matt]

Didn't think about the incest stuff. Would be funny if they went there though.

Kieron probably isn't Brandon James' kid, but that doesn't mean he isn't one of the murderers. Piper, Brooke, and Kieron are my top picks for the killers.

You know, don't rule it out. The show's head writer, Jill Blotevogel was also a writer and producer on Harper's Island and they basically used this exact plot (old killer had a child with main character's mom, child was someone who once slept with and was in love with his half-sister).

That said, I'm not sure Brandon's child is the killer. I think it is reporter girl, but I don't think she is killing people. If she is, it is basically Harper's Island Redux.

I am starting to get suspicious of Emma's mom and the sheriff. We know she genuinely believes that Brandon did not commit the murders. So if Brandon didn't do it all those years ago, it means the real killer got away. Who are the suspects?

Sheriff, Emma's mom, Emma's dad. Emma's dad can safely be ruled out, I think (especially since he is a suspect on the show). Sheriff seems to at least encounter the killer next week. Emma's mom would be quite a twist and no one would see it coming.

I think IF Brandon's child is the killer, it is because Emma's mom essentially framed Brandon years ago. Sleeping with him was probably a way to further incriminate him.

 

[Doctor Jones]

Yeah, I think I'm on the Piper train. Still like Brooke as the second killer. She has been key to a lot of the set ups/mental torture. The auditorium attack was waaay to convenient to set up Bransen.

Went a little Nightmare on Elm Street with this episode. So, they didn't spare us the gore of last week's kill. And I'm liking that it is still a very personal vendetta. Not betting on Emma's dad surviving.

I've been saying the same thing. I think Piper is the mastermind (possibly daughter of Brandon James) and Brooke the accomplice. I mean for God's sake, Brooke got a way for the third ****ing time with that slash. Before that I thought for sure my whole Brooke theory was done until... she only got slashed. I think she set up Branson.

Piper is just so extra helpful and good and the least ****ed up of all of them her telling the Sheriff gives them a distraction and if necessary, can frame things on Brooke.

 

[Sevprince]

I think the podcast lady is Daisy and Brandon's kid not Emma. The killer seems invested and has emotional response about the Brandon James/Daisy stuff. I don't take Emma's father would want to raise BJ's kid. Jake might be the second one although he seems very obvious. Maybe Emma's new creepy bf is another suspect.

I don't care for any of these characters except maybe Noah and Audrey so the faster they die the better.

Got that one right and I'm sticking with the fact she is killer number one specially after her actions this episode. Pointing out the second killer is hard though. Brook, Jake, Noah, Audrey, creepy boyfriend, the cop all seems suspect to me.

 

[Broseph44]

This is still tough for me right now to choose who I think the killer or killers are. I think Brooke is definitely part of this though.

 

[Sawyer]

Yeah I really feel like that whole thing with Brooke getting slashed was a set-up against Branson.

 

[BH/HHH]

This is still tough for me right now to choose who I think the killer or killers are. I think Brooke is definitely part of this though.

Why would she have reacted the way she did to the killer though? The teacher wasn't around at that point.

 

[Broseph44]

Why would she have reacted the way she did to the killer though? The teacher wasn't around at that point.

I dunno just in case he showed back up quickly, it would have to appear that she really was scared and in danger. Deception.

 

[TeeKay]

Brooke is hot.

 

[Naked Shia]

my cousin and I made our own version of scream in gta V, here is the video

[YT]ZQnRW4Tmw40[/YT]

We're currently thinking of making a sequel

 

[Sithborg]

I dunno just in case he showed back up quickly, it would have to appear that she really was scared and in danger. Deception.

It goes to it being a set up for Bransen. She probably knew the police was going to be looking at him, since she probably placed the knive (she does have experience with hiding things in his class). So the second killer "attacks" her, she screams to bring both Bransen AND the cops back.

Like I said, the set ups and emotional manipulation she has been involved in just makes her look like the perfect option to be one of the killers.

 

[Broseph44]

Exactly this is what I'm saying and agreeing with. She seems very involved.

 

[terry78]

Unless you actually see someone get it on this show, the opportunity for them to be in on the scheme is very high.

 

[BH/HHH]

I dunno just in case he showed back up quickly, it would have to appear that she really was scared and in danger. Deception.

Hmm possible, gotta say they're doing a good job keeping us guessing haha

Edit: something else I just thought what about the night Brooke got booty called but we know that was from the killer so if she was in on it why would she have gone for the booty call?

I think I am on the Piper/Jake bandwagon.

- Jake been stabbed by his own knife has me suspicious of him.
- Piper been a stranger really, I think she's Daisy & Brendan's kid plus the fact the killer only knocked her down and took Will and we never saw her get back up.

 

[SuperBatman]

Hmm possible, gotta say they're doing a good job keeping us guessing haha

Edit: something else I just thought what about the night Brooke got booty called but we know that was from the killer so if she was in on it why would she have gone for the booty call?

I think I am on the Piper/Jake bandwagon.

- Jake been stabbed by his own knife has me suspicious of him.
- Piper been a stranger really, I think she's Daisy & Brendan's kid plus the fact the killer only knocked her down and took Will and we never saw her get back up.

Actually we did see her get back up it was at the start of the episode on when Will was captured that's when she went to go find Emma took them to where that signs said Emma come alone.

 

[BH/HHH]

Actually we did see her get back up it was at the start of the episode on when Will was captured that's when she went to go find Emma took them to where that signs said Emma come alone.

Oh I must not have been paying attention at that point lol

 

[Broseph44]

You're right though they're definitely doing a good job making us guess haha

 

[Hunter Rider]

This weeks ep was the weakest, never a fan of hallucination stuff, but Will was channeling some T-1000 with that split melon!

I think Piper is the daughter of Brandon James but I don't think she is one of the killers, I actually think she is there to find out who the killer was that framed him, most probably The Sheriff.

I've been saying the same thing. I think Piper is the mastermind (possibly daughter of Brandon James) and Brooke the accomplice. I mean for God's sake, Brooke got a way for the third ****ing time with that slash. Before that I thought for sure my whole Brooke theory was done until... she only got slashed. I think she set up Branson.

I'd never really been on the Brooke theory but after this week, the escape yet again and the way it felt like Branson was set up, I'm definitely thinking she is part of it. Her and Jake seem too obvious, I expect one of the killers to be a surprise, like say a tandem of Brooke and Noah? Or, maybe there are 3 killers?

Brooke is hot.

 

[The Shape]

I'm enjoying this show so far. I like how they include a lot of call-back sequences and homages to the film trilogy that don't necessarily duplicate moments exactly, nor do they carry the same meaning. For instance, Emma hallucinating and then running into Kieran in the hallways was very reminiscent of Sidney running into Billy after being chased in the school bathroom. The sequence with Brooke on stage in the auditorium reminded me of the beginning of the Scream 2 finale. The idea that the killer likely has a blood/sibling relation to the main girl (Emma) and probably feels as if he/she was "thrown away", ignored, and deprived of the kind of life Emma has lived is also reminiscent of the Roman/Sydney connection in Scream 3.

I also like that the show has really broadened the scope of the mystery to include many more possible suspects than a single Scream film did, which is effective and necessary for the TV show format. The Scream films were known for introducing multiple suspects and a bunch of red herrings throughout, but this is kind of on another level. The number of possible red herrings that are tossed our way is a little absurd at times (so many lingering shots of potentially evil and shady glares), but it works overall. However, despite all of the information we've been given thus far, it's literally impossible for anyone to confidently or accurately predict or say what's what, which I guess is a good thing.

As most are, I'm fairly certain that Piper (Gale Weathers-Lite) is up to something, involved in the mystery somehow (Daisy/Brandon's child), and possibly one of the killers. It seems like there's a good chance that Jake could be the second killer, and if he is, he's likely the crazy/dumb fall guy and/or the muscle behind the murders -- a la Stu in S1 and Mickey in S2. The reason I'm hesitant to really get behind the idea that Jake is one of the killers is because the show has been pushing him as a possible suspect so heavily since the very start that it could easily just be some really poor misdirection overall.

My gut tells me that Brooke is NOT one of the killers, but there's definitely a case to be made for her as a killer, especially after the last episode (using her father as a major suspect in the case, setting up Bransen, etc). I don't think Kieran is a killer, and I kind of hope he's not. The show did a good job of subverting the Billy Loomis formula by casting a lot of suspicion towards Will (Emma's dickwad boyfriend), but then making him a hero and killing him off. Now Kieran's taken that spot in Emma's life to an extent, and if he winds up being a killer, it wouldn't be much different than the Sidney/Billy thing, with the innocent girls trusting, having sex with, and falling for the killer.

Honestly, part of me feels that there's something very suspicious about Audrey.

 

[Pokkle]

For me, the killers are

Spoiler

Piper, the lost child and Audrey.
Audrey can fight, had her dna in the mask, a picture of brandon, she was a childhood friend of emma then emma want with new friends and she hate emma's friend.