OFFICIAL: Best CBM of 2014 thread (so far)

Best CBM of 2014

  • 300: Rise Of An Empire

  • Captain America: The Winter Soldier

  • The Amazing Spiderman 2

  • X-Men: Days Of Future Past

  • Transformers: Age Of Extinction

  • Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

  • Sin City: A Dame To Kill For

  • Other.

  • Guardians Of The Galaxy


Results are only viewable after voting.
TWS vs DOFP vs GOTG is such a great argument because all three films are so great it is difficult to choose between the three. Each have great character moments, great sequences of action, and a great overall story. I am quite fond of the action in DOFP though as we really get to see X-Men being X-Men. I felt like all three movies were living comic books.
 
had better action overall with Nightcrawler, The Mansion, Magnetos prison break and Deathstrike. Battle wise they have not had anything to top Deathstrike.

I will agree one vs one wise the only fight that challenges Deathstrike is Wolverine vs Shingen, I think if that fight had been a little longer it would actually be top. But in terms of raw anger and emotion, from both characters, Wolverine vs Shingen is right up there.



Yup. Quicksilver probably had the funnest action scene of the year for me, but DOFP's action outside those two characters were not that great. It was pretty ****** choreography with those battles. Thought the X-Men fought without showing skill once again with no communication. They just blindly hit the things with their powers most the time. Blink was the only one using any sort of strategy. Then we get the pretty much redundant scene of Magneto raising and drop something, along with playing remote control Sentinels. What a waste of how to use Sentinels.

I do think the Sentinel fights should have had more to them, especially the future ones, I know they wanted to sell the bleakness of the future and how the Sentinels were an unstoppable threat, but it would have been nice to see the likes of Colossus and Warpath take at least one each down through sheer force, even Bishop could have really.

Agreed with GOTG as well. Could have used some better action itself.

The fight between Batroc and Cap alone crushes all the other battles.

Yeah the fight scenes in GOTG were disappointing, all of the space ship stuff was really good though IMO.

And yeah I loved the Batroc vs Cap fight scene, only issue for me is I dont think the fights with The Winter Soldier topped, and that was disappointing to me.

TWS vs DOFP vs GOTG is such a great argument because all three films are so great it is difficult to choose between the three. Each have great character moments, great sequences of action, and a great overall story. I am quite fond of the action in DOFP though as we really get to see X-Men being X-Men. I felt like all three movies were living comic books.

They are all great, truly great movies, that all offer something different, which means we as fans have been very lucky this year overall. When was the last time, if any, we had 3 truly great CBM's in one year? 2012 (Avengers, Dredd, TDKR) and 2008 (Iron Man, Hellboy II, TDK) are the only other years that got this IMO. And considering the CBM boom started in 1998, thats not an easy thing to do.
 
I agree about the fight scene in The Wolverine. Was more impressed with The Deathstrike fight but it was very cool. :up:

After watching all these a few more times my vote still goes for GOTG overall (not counting Snowpiercer). DOFP had my fav sequence with Quickilver, but action wise as a whole the Winter Soliders scenes I thought were just mapped out and executed more effectively. The assault on Batroc's ship, the Fury carchase, Freeway battle between WS and final battle with Cap and Falcon all just blended with the most impact and intensity for me.
 
Watched DOFP again the other night, its just ridiculous the range of emotions you go through in that movie, thats why its the best for me. There are at least 5 times throughout when I am close to tears, and then another 5 times on top of that were the hairs stand up on the back of my neck. For me, TWS doesnt stand up to repeat viewings so far, but DOFP does, lets see if GOTG does as well, I have a feeling it will.
 
A sucker for the melodrama, eh? lol
 
Watched DOFP again the other night, its just ridiculous the range of emotions you go through in that movie, thats why its the best for me. There are at least 5 times throughout when I am close to tears, and then another 5 times on top of that were the hairs stand up on the back of my neck. For me, TWS doesnt stand up to repeat viewings so far, but DOFP does, lets see if GOTG does as well, I have a feeling it will.

Wow,for me TWS has crazy replayability,but I agree DOFP is an emotional movie even if I felt more emotions in GOTG.
 
Watched DOFP again the other night, its just ridiculous the range of emotions you go through in that movie, thats why its the best for me. There are at least 5 times throughout when I am close to tears, and then another 5 times on top of that were the hairs stand up on the back of my neck. For me, TWS doesnt stand up to repeat viewings so far, but DOFP does, lets see if GOTG does as well, I have a feeling it will.
Agreed, X-Men DOFP is a well devised emotional ride.
I need to rewatch them both to see which one has a stronger replay value.
 
I guess I went on a different emotional journey than you 2.
 
I didn't agree that I have the same journey, but it is an emotional ride.
 
Watched DOFP again the other night, its just ridiculous the range of emotions you go through in that movie, thats why its the best for me. There are at least 5 times throughout when I am close to tears, and then another 5 times on top of that were the hairs stand up on the back of my neck.

Snap :up:

DOFP is the king of the CBM's for 2014 for me, and it was a superb year overall, even though TASM 2 was awful. But DOFP, TWS and GOTG more than made up for that.
 
GotG, TWS, and DoFP are all so good that their individual supporters all have valid arguments. This was probably the best year for CBMs ever with those three great films. It is very telling that none of the other options other than those three have even 2% of the vote.
 
Yeah, it's been one of the best years for film in general imo. I know people always complain about how there's nothing but CB movies and blockbusters being released. But that's really been far from the truth this year as there are just a ton of well made indie and dramas to see in theatres.

Only thing I've been disappointed in is the lack of good mainstream comedies and horror this year. Only been a handful.
 
Last edited:
I know its not based on a cb, but I cant help but include DotPotA on my list. I seem to recall a GN released in the late 70's. Yeah, that's it...

Oh, and TWS edges out the other two excellent cbs for me. Ive been clamoring for some next level hand-to-hand action from Cap, and Marvel ****ing delivered it in spades. Plus Fury finally got his badass action moment. Loved that scene.

And yeah its equal parts ironic and depressing that in a year filled with great sh/scifi/action movies, one of the worst featured Spider-Man. Even with all the past baggage, I swear to god its not that hard to make a great Spidey flick. It just isn't.
 
Last edited:
I'd just like to remind you all that Blue is the Warmest Color and Snowpiercer are both technically 2014 films in the US (both released in their home countries last year, but I'm pretty eligible for this years Oscars)...and I'd place both of them over X-Men Days of Future Past...so that would mean we SHOULD have 5 movies that can make a claim to being the best CBM of the year.

I'm still siding with The Winter Soldier though.
 
A sucker for the melodrama, eh? lol

Yep :yay:. But in all seriousness for me emotional moments are big part of what makes a movie have re-watchability value, And DOFP has it in spades. GOTG has a lot too, but for TWS only has it in fleeting moments, like all of the MCU movies I dont find they have enough personally.

Agreed, X-Men DOFP is a well devised emotional ride.
I need to rewatch them both to see which one has a stronger replay value.

Well for me I find DOFP much more re-watchable, you may find the opposite, who knows, we are all different.

Snap :up:

DOFP is the king of the CBM's for 2014 for me, and it was a superb year overall, even though TASM 2 was awful. But DOFP, TWS and GOTG more than made up for that.

:up: Great year topped off by DOFP, I think in general this has been a very good year for movies.
 
I would love to give my vote to ASM2 becaused I am biased as ****, love Spider-Man and do in fact LOVE the new Spider-Man movies BUT hats off to Cap 2. This was amazing. Not just a great comic book film but a great film in general! And I was pretty underwhelmed by the first Cap film.

But I don't think Transformers can be included, yes it has a comic but the comic came a little after the toys. Comics, movies, cartoon all made after the toys and for the toys to sell them unlike Cap or Spidey. 300? Maybe, but hell the novel it's supposed to be based off never even freakin' came out!
 
Well now that I've see BH6 I can give my final ranking.

1. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
2. Big Hero 6
3. Guardians of the Galaxy
4. X-Men: Days of Future Past
5. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
 
I would love to give my vote to ASM2 becaused I am biased as ****, love Spider-Man and do in fact LOVE the new Spider-Man movies BUT hats off to Cap 2. This was amazing. Not just a great comic book film but a great film in general! And I was pretty underwhelmed by the first Cap film.

But I don't think Transformers can be included, yes it has a comic but the comic came a little after the toys. Comics, movies, cartoon all made after the toys and for the toys to sell them unlike Cap or Spidey. 300? Maybe, but hell the novel it's supposed to be based off never even freakin' came out!


As someone who has read a lot of TF comics, I consider them comic book characters, the comics have longer runs than the cartoon or even the toys have in the end.
 
Great year for CBMs, but my vote goes to DOFP.

As many have stated, the film wins on its acting alone. Lot of great performances to enjoy throughout and some great action sequences
 
Winter soldier by a mile. I enjoyed GOTG also but it not in the same league. DOFP just didn't connect well with me and the ending fell particularly flat for me.
 
Well now that I've see BH6 I can give my final ranking.

1. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
2. Big Hero 6
3. Guardians of the Galaxy
4. X-Men: Days of Future Past
5. The Amazing Spider-Man 2


Can you explain your reasonings for putting BH6 above GOTG?

Guardians has been the best movie this year. love cap but Guardians was so much better. Can't wait to get the Blu-Ray in December.
 
I liked Guardians but too many of the rough edges kept me from loving it. I don't know how else to describe it without doing a commentary track for it so I can go little part by little part where it bugged me. I'm used to more polish on movies that I see. Now lack of polish is common with idie films, sure. But you rarely see it in $170m budgeted films. Plus I've never been a space enthusiast. Setting films there(be they Star Wars, Star Trek, Interstellar, GotG, etc.) will have the effect of the lack of familiar settings keeping me from getting as int it as I otherwise would have. Basically I don't live in space and thus I don't relate to space as a setting. It's off putting to me.

Anyway, as I said I enjoyed the film and am glad for it's success. I gave it an 8/10 but among MCU films that just means middle of the pack.

BH6 had less parts that bothered me but still wasn't enough to make me love it(a 9/10 or higher) so I gave it an 8.5/10 which still puts it above GotG, slightly.

But I gave CA:TWS a flat out 9/10 as I did love that film(so you can use that as a reference for how my thinking goes).
 
Last edited:
TWS and GOTG are on par for me even if they are two completely different movies.
 

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,268
Messages
22,077,215
Members
45,876
Latest member
Crazygamer3011
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"