Comics Official Fans of Reilly Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok, I know why Diablo was there, he made a potion that covered the knife that killed Mattie (am I the only one who liked her), the potion mixes with the Spider-Blood and helps restore Vladimir.
Electro is there to "jumpstart" Vladimir so that he can live again.
What was Mysterio's purpose????

Also, why wasn't the knife used on Kaine? or Electro used to help bring him back?
no consistancy....
 
It's really hard to tell when a character will click with the public. I, for instance, dug Sleepwalker but he fell till limbo until two revival attempts. Mattie, however, had some serious taint on her character. Not only was she created by John Byrne doing his infamous Chapter One reboot days, but there was that painful moment where she tried to put the moves on Spidey. Given that climate it's not strange she fell to limbo only to be revived as plot devices.

It takes a really good writer with a real love for a character to give them a decent redemption. It also takes Marvel WANTING said redemption enough to allow it to happen.
 
Is my new Background...
Now i just want one like that of the Scarlet outfit...
 
Yeah, I saw him mention this other series someplace else. I'm very interested in knowing what it is now, especially since he mentions that "if Marvel promotes it". Heh. Sounds like he's pretty ticked off at a person or persons there.
 
Well... I'll wait and see before having a fangasm. Been let down many times before.

Additionally, that's some harsh treatment of Tom DeFalco's Spider-Girl run. Why not just use a new name for a new character and an unrelated series? Anyone remember when 'Thunderbolts' became an unrelated book (with the Fight-Club bolts)? It lasted all of 5 issues or so. Stupid business move and spiteful personal move.
 
Well... I'll wait and see before having a fangasm. Been let down many times before.

Additionally, that's some harsh treatment of Tom DeFalco's Spider-Girl run. Why not just use a new name for a new character and an unrelated series? Anyone remember when 'Thunderbolts' became an unrelated book (with the Fight-Club bolts)? It lasted all of 5 issues or so. Stupid business move and spiteful personal move.

What is harsh treatment? :huh:

The fact that they saved the Spider-Girl book from cancellation for years? When Marvel had great book after great book getting cancelled after like six issues to eleven issues and meanwhile here is Spider-Girl continuing onward through like four or five chances of cancellation when that books sales were just as worse, if not worse, than those other books sales.

So that's harsh treatment?
 
Send in the clones!!!

So, Spidey on 2 Avengers teams, and Spidey possibly in the FF. Sounds to me like he could use an extra set of hands...
 
I think he'll be off the main Avengers book after 6 issues, but will stay with the New Avengers... which is a better fit for him...

:o
 
What is harsh treatment? :huh:

The fact that they saved the Spider-Girl book from cancellation for years? When Marvel had great book after great book getting cancelled after like six issues to eleven issues and meanwhile here is Spider-Girl continuing onward through like four or five chances of cancellation when that books sales were just as worse, if not worse, than those other books sales.

So that's harsh treatment?

Take your blinkers off. Why use the 'Spider-Girl' name for an unrelated character that is not Tom DeFalco's baby? Why not use a different name for a different character? It can't be to cash in on the name, since sales are so dismal for Spider-Girl. Rather the intent is to marginalize the original MC2 Spider-Girl, so when people hear the name they don't think of DeFalco's creation that he took so much pride in, but instead this new SG who has nothing in common with the original. As I already mentioned it didn't work when they completely changed Thunderbolts into something that no longer resembled what the book used to be. It won't work this time. I give this series 6-12 issues. Fans of the original SG will percieve it as a slap in the face and it will never build a base. This could have easily been avoided if they used an original name.
 
Take your blinkers off. Why use the 'Spider-Girl' name for an unrelated character that is not Tom DeFalco's baby? Why not use a different name for a different character? It can't be to cash in on the name, since sales are so dismal for Spider-Girl. Rather the intent is to marginalize the original MC2 Spider-Girl, so when people hear the name they don't think of DeFalco's creation that he took so much pride in, but instead this new SG who has nothing in common with the original. As I already mentioned it didn't work when they completely changed Thunderbolts into something that no longer resembled what the book used to be. It won't work this time. I give this series 6-12 issues. Fans of the original SG will percieve it as a slap in the face and it will never build a base. This could have easily been avoided if they used an original name.

And you really think that most of the comic fans who read Spider-Girl for years upon years are so ignorant and stupid to not be able to know the difference? :huh:

I own like 120 to 130 issues of Spider-Girl. Trust me there is going to be a big difference between Mayday and Arana.

Nobody is telling you to buy the Arana series. I'm not going to buy it either because, honestly, I'm not interested and have never been interested in Arana. It's only a slap in the face if you let it be a slap in the face. The MC2 Universe dies if you LET IT die. Apparently there weren't enough readers or letters to save the book from another cancellation. Spider-Girl ran a VERY long course and told a lot of really fun stories. It's the longest running female character series Marvel has ever had.

I will agree that Arana's book will probably only last a a year, maybe two, and then be cancelled. And who is to say that Mayday won't come back in some capacity down the line again? Maybe someone else besides Tom Defalco will pick it up in the future. No character is dead unless the fans let them stay dead.

Take this thread for instance. Fans of Ben Reilly. The guy died in Peter Parker Spider-Man # 75 and, honestly, when I read that I thought I was never going to see or hear this character referenced in a Spider-Man comic ever again. Guess what? Kind of got proven wrong on that one because there are writers and creators coming up that were long time fans of the character themselves.

I'm a huge fan of Mayday and the MC2 universe. I would LOVE to see the character continue on forever but if the sales are not there, well, what can you do? And, no offense, it's not like Mayday has a copyright on the Spider-Girl name. Marvel does. :oldrazz: Seriously, you are taking it a little too hard and I know you're not the only one. Dead is never dead...unless you let it be...so don't let it be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,265
Messages
22,075,538
Members
45,875
Latest member
shanandrews
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"