I wish there had been a poll for this thread. Something with 5 options ( because I love 5 option polls ) like:
Potential Deadshot Solo ?
1) Great idea, could re-establish WB/DC's credibility, make big bucks and be a highly entertaining film.
2) Good idea, already has a bankable star and the character has a lot of potential. Could be the start of good things for the DCEU, a good world builder at least.
3) Fair idea, could go either way, but something that WB/DC should consider given Will Smith's star power and the fan base of Suicide Squad.
4) Bad idea, Smith's the wrong guy for the role and WB/DC's current line up of directors have all failed to make the darker grittier characters engaging with audiences.
5) Terrible idea, do you own any stock in WB, if so sell now. Wrong on every level.
That's just off the top of my head
Something like that perhaps -although perhaps with less sarcasm. It would be neat to see where the balance of opinions lie. While I'm probably a 4, on the above scale, I've seen a lot of folks strongly defend the idea.
While I'm not shy about disagreeing with people, I try to never dismiss people's opinions out of hand - rather I try to respect them (and recently I've been told I'm sounding a bit condescending, which is totally unintentional, as I'm genuinely interested in what people have to say, no matter how strongly I disagree).
Anyway, I think it would be interesting to see if there's a strong majority for either end of the spectrum, and how many people are neutral. How significant would that be in terms of the general audience, probably not very.
But, I believe in the power of word of mouth, and that often starts with the fans.