Great thread idea jmc!
After reading these posts I can see some similarities in how I felt watching Batman Begins and The Dark Knight and alot of differences, which is great. These movies are different to everyone and that's why it's great to have a forum to discuss them together.
I've been a Batman fan since the age of 4 or 5 years old. Started watching the reruns of the 60's show. In 89 I was just shy of 7 my mom took me to see Burton's Batman after much begging. We sat in the back of the theatre, I was blown away. Here was something different, something darker, something adult. Also for the longest time I didn't know if Nickolsons Joker survived the fall because I was too freaked out that he was laughing still and supposedly dead...but anyway, after that Batman would be one of the only constants in my life. I saw Returns in theatres, skipped Forever and saw Batman & Robin in the cinema as well, at 15 years old, it wasn't THAT bad, but Adam West was my first introduction to Batman after all.
In the meanwhile between B&R and BB I watched all of the animated series and was fairly content with Batman being a cartoon for the rest of my life.
I remember watching American Psycho BEFORE Batman Begins and really liking Christian Bale and told my friends I thought he would be a great Bruce Wayne, just by how he looked. (And needless to say his acting was wonderful) Then when I found out he WAS going to be playing Bruce and Batman I was very excited.
During Begins I was entranced by the respect and new vision this movie had for my beloved Caped Crusader. I felt like I did when I was 6 years old, seeing an entirely new version of Batman, one I didn't expect, but one I was always hoping for. I left the theatre with my friends elated....FINALLY someone got Batman right and oh my god, they showed a Joker card at the end!
I couldn't wait to see Begins again and for the sequel.
I was pretty heavy into following the viral campaign for The Dark Knight and my friend (and Batman Buddy) Joe and I went to Chicago for the last one. Saw TDK opening night at the IMAX and I had some kind of out-of-body experience. I remember being scared of Heath as the Joker, (the magic trick and LOOK AT ME! scenes especially) my heart broke for Bruce, Harvey, Alfred and Gordon, my jaw dropped with scenes like the Bat-pod ejecting out of the Tumbler and Batman gliding through Hong Kong. I sat stunned at the ending and then saw it again 8 or 9 times, enjoying it more and more.
I absolutely am invested into Christopher Nolan's vision of and Christian Bale's portrayal of Batman. I cannot wait to see Tom Hardy's Bane (I've been championing him since the announcement) , I am finally on board with Anne as Selina. I cannot wait to see this film and yet as excited as I am, I know that with that comes finality. And part of me doesn't want it to end. With such an amazing team of people making these GLORIOUS Batman films, I never want this echelon to be diminished by anyone else trying to carry the torch.
They will make more Batman movies, I have the hope that they will see what Nolan and the entire cast and crew have done and leave it alone to forge their own vision of The Dark Knight, he is such a multi-faceted character there is almost nothing you cannot do with him.
Nolan's films were at the perfect place and time for me as a fan of Batman. It was like reading a classic novel again and it meaning more to you now as an adult then it ever would have when you first turned those pages.
All I can say is thank you Christopher Nolan and I am so excited to see the grand finale!