Action-Adventure Robocop 2 & 3

It still pisses me off to this day that they changed the score for Robocop 2, I mean why? What was the reasoning behind it? Strange, I liked R2 as well but the score from the first movie being there would have made it a lot better.

I remember I saw R2 when I was younger and liked the score and wasn't bothered that Poledouris' theme wasn't used. I still do enjoy the R2 score. Hope someday some cd label is thinking about doing C&C release for it in the near future. It's missing some good stuff on the album. I believe Rosenman's score was appropriate for R2. It really isn't that bad as some are making it out to be. It's better than a lot of that MV/RC garbage we get today. *cough* TDK and IM *cough* The only reason people are so ticked about it b/c he didn't use Poledouris' theme.

This reminded me of when people were whining about Elfman not using Fiedel's Terminator theme for T4. Which was the right thing to do since T4 wasn't a Terminator movie. In my eyes anyway. Movie was a joke to Cameron's Terminator films. Back to Elfman, he did something clever instead of apeing the theme and ignoring it. He went halfway and did a variation on it. Which was appropriate since it's suppose to take place before T1. But people still complained about it.
 
I think Sarge means that it was interesting that they didn't do something more cliched, like having her end up in danger, or something to that effect. I think we all agree that it was good that it was just a quick moment in the film, and elaborating on it would have been pointless.

I think it could have led to some really good drama if they had expanded upon that scene, remember the scene had that moment where the wife says to Murphy 'I don't care what they've done to you Alex.', and Robo rebuffs her by telling her it isn't him, they just made the robocop in tribute. So you could have had her continuing to try to persuade him to be a part of her life again, much like a wife sticking by a husband who has had all of his limbs blown off in war, which is basically what Robo is, except they have given him a way to walk with extra bonus features. But given what he has been transformed into, there is a very different dimension to him, and exploring that kind of quandry is what sci-fi writing is supposed to be all about, questioning what it means to be human through an exploration of speculative situations, like the replicants in DADOES/Blade Runner.
Robo could continue to back off, she brings the son in to try and get him to see him, etc...it could have made for some interesting drama, but would have had to been written very well to be effective, perhaps the writer just didn't have the chops to take it further than that one scene, that is what I suspect anyway. Frank Miller said his original script was changed drastically by someone, so who knows what that was like. Who knows though, maybe you are right, but there definitely felt like there was some interesting ideas in there that could have went beyond the one scene. I am guessing that none of them tackled that notion much though, it would have been a difficult one to tackle, one for the Philip K ***** of this world.(funnily enough nowadays you cannot write up a speculative sci-fi writer's name in the plural on a forum without it being automatically edited for profanity lol)

I enjoy 2 as well, but it can be a little ott and grating as a result sometimes, the first one had the perfect balance between effective humour and gore, but here it tries to copy the 1st movie, but to lesser effect, as someone else said, the satirical ads are not as spot on.

Mind you, I did not like the idea that the original writers of Robocop had for the sequel before they were booted off, they wanted to put Robo in suspended animation and have him wake up a couple of hundred years in the future. I prefer a sequel taking place in the same universe with the same supporting characters, carrying on the same story.

3 *is* unwatchable, about the only scene I genuinely like in that movie is the ending when Robo shows up in the jet pack to help the citizens defend themselves, it is cheeseball, but I love it, just one of those superhero moments I like.

I have only watched a couple of minutes of the tv show before changing the channel, even worse than Robo3, I just didn't want it to besmirch my watching of the original, associating it with crap tv.
 
Last edited:
I believe that poster came with early versions of the Robocop 2 4K blu ray from shout factory
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"