Spoiled Fans

[Lily Adler]

I also remember someone analyzing a set pic of Anne Hathaway from TDKR and saying she had fat ankles, or something.

Henry Cavill having hips being too wide aka "child-bearing hips" to play Superman ranks up there with the most bizarre criticism I've heard against an actor portraying a superhero.

A hair thread was made for the first Amazing Spider-Man movie, I jokingly suggested Peter should be bald.

Alongside this one that Andrew Garfield HAD TOO MUCH HAIR to REALISTICIALLY wear his mask.

Amy and Anne had it rougher, though. Amy's too old and fat (she just had her baby before filming started) and Anne is not sexy enough to be Catwoman. She's a rail and her teeth show too much when she smiles. Also this gem: "I would have preferred it if Lady Gaga had gotten the role" (paraphrased).

 

[KevanG]

I just think all the stupidity with the most random and obscure criticisms is hilarious.

 

[Spider-Aziz]

Henry Cavill having hips being too wide aka "child-bearing hips" to play Superman ranks up there with the most bizarre criticism I've heard against an actor portraying a superhero.

Because he was fat in his youth?

Alongside this one that Andrew Garfield HAD TOO MUCH HAIR to REALISTICIALLY wear his mask.

His hair was too long, I had to see it to believe it.

Amy and Anne had it rougher, though. Amy's too old and fat (she just had her baby before filming started) and Anne is not sexy enough to be Catwoman. She's a rail and her teeth show too much when she smiles. Also this gem: "I would have preferred it if Lady Gaga had gotten the role" (paraphrased).

What KevanG said.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

Man this whole Amy Adams is "old and fat" is killin me! I SO WOULD in a heartbeat!( and probably so would alot of the ones callin her fat and old! hahaha)
Mannnnnn! i can just imagine what people would have said about Margot Kidder/ lois lane from the Superman flick if these boards was around then!
"old and fat!" sheesh!

 

[Spider-Aziz]

Margot had too skinny a face.
She looked like a 50 years old at the time.

 

[Lily Adler]

Because he was fat in his youth?

His hair was too long, I had to see it to believe it.

What KevanG said.

Nope. He, in his current physical form, has child bearing hips.

 

[Erzengel]

I liked the guy who said Hathaway was fat and posted a pic of his "gf". Of course he wasn't smart enough to make his photobucket private so no other pics of her. No pics of him and her. That's always delightful.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

Margot had too skinny a face.
She looked like a 50 years old at the time.

Et tu Spider?! Hahahahah! Everyone's a critic!

 

[CyclopsWasRight]

Of all the fan bases there are in practically everything, are there any you think are really spoiled?

Like no matter they're given with that particular product, even if it's good, they'll still complain about it. This goes for sports fans too.

Good god yes!!!!! Especially those who want a product to fail because they can't get their way