Star Trek - A Decent Casting Formula For JL?

bunk

superhero fan
Joined
Aug 2, 2006
Messages
9,482
Reaction score
0
Points
31
I think the team in charge of the new Trek movie has come up with a nicely balanced approach to casting that may be applied to Justice League (if it's not too late).

Surprisingly, many similarities exist between the two productions.
- 7 core members
- A "trinity", so to speak
- Possible villain duo (if one exists in JL)
- Actor "look" an important factor

What they've done on Trek, is balance the importance of actor appearance, name recognition, and talent rather well.

The "Trinity"
trektrinityxu6.jpg

Their approach seems to be keeping "unknowns" limited. They've saved their "unknown card", and used it for Kirk/Pine. Quinto is has really made an impression on Heroes and Urban is certainly not an unknown with LOTR, Bourne, Doom ect. They're not huge stars, but the audience will be familiar. A nice balance.

dctrinitycw1.jpg


Using the Trek formula, they've got one "unknown card". If they want to use it on Gale, I've got no problem with it. They should be aiming a little higher with Batman and Superman. How about a TV star and seasoned action star?

The rest of crew
trekcrew2co7.jpg


Again, no total unknowns here. Zoe from Black Pearl, Vantage Point...Pegg is arguably more known than anyone... Cho from the H&K movies... Yelchin... ok, well it does taper off.

It's a nice range they've created here from Pegg who's starred in his own films down to Yelchin.

The rest of the team:

dcleagueva5.jpg


So far, not a bad start with Common as Stewart and Adam Brody as Flash. Not sure about Brody's look, but the "starpower" is pretty comparable. I would hope for Aquaman or MM to have a little more, and the other could be a little less.

Look at the supporting cast:

treksupportingjs4.jpg


A nice range from Ryder and Greenwood down to "Scarlet". Don't know the specifics of JL's supporting cast, but this a good template for that as well.

Finally the villains.

trekvillainsio8.jpg

They've gone all out on the lead villain with Bana. Almost like the heroes are on one side of the see-saw with Bana on the other. Balance. I would truly hope Miller goes with a very strong actor for Max or whomever the antagonist is.

maxqp5.jpg


The general idea seems to be less risk with total unknowns, at the same time recruiting actors who look the part and aren't terribly expensive.

Of course all of this is based on the limited info gleaned from this production.

So - thoughts?
 
Nice. I think the cast that has been collected for Star Trek is amazing, and I really hope that the cast of JLA can match it.
 
bunk said:
If they want to use it on Gale, I've got no problem with it.

Why does she get a free pass?

If they do the casting formula like Star Trek is using she wouldn't be Diana. They'd have a low level professional film actress.
 
I agree. The cast must be a mix of very well known, to somewhat unknowns.
Superman and Batman imo should be fairly well known, ie Michael Trucco as Superman, Gerard Butler as Batman.

M.M. and Aquaman should have some star power in those roles. At least B-Listers.

W.W., G.L., and Flash could be relative unknown to somewhat known actors and get away with it.

As for the villain, that needs to be your A-list actor. It would eat up a good chunk of change, but they (W.B.) would need the star power attached to it if they want the public to take J.L. seriously.
 
Why does she get a free pass?

If they do the casting formula like Star Trek is using she wouldn't be Diana. They'd have a low level professional film actress.

That is true. I'm equating Chris Pine with Gale, and he clearly has a more impressive resume than she does. I'm just saying the Trek team seemed to have their "chance card" willing to be used once on a lead character. At this point, it seems the JL teams wants to use three on each of the three hero leads, which could prove problematic.
 
A lot of this casting might not even be valid anymore.

All the actor's options have expired and/or terminated. To get any of them back would basically mean they have to renegotiate their deals or give them new ones.

So if they ever do this movie again, they aren't necessarily beholden to all this rumored casting.
 
Vile:

True.

If Miller is still involved in JL Gale will still be WW, though.

Green:

Agreed.

You'd have to change Trucco. He's nowhere near recognizable as Butler.
 
A lot of this casting might not even be valid anymore.

All the actor's options have expired and/or terminated. To get any of them back would basically mean they have to renegotiate their deals or give them new ones.

So if they ever do this movie again, they aren't necessarily beholden to all this rumored casting.


That's what I was thinking too. If the cast was set in stone, this thread wouldn't be much fun. There's still time to get it right!!11!one
 
Vile:

True.

If Miller is still involved in JL Gale will still be WW, though.

Not necessarily either. Someone new might've visited the casting couch at this point.

I kid, I kid :grin: .
 
A lot of this casting might not even be valid anymore.

All the actor's options have expired and/or terminated. To get any of them back would basically mean they have to renegotiate their deals or give them new ones.

So if they ever do this movie again, they aren't necessarily beholden to all this rumored casting.

Fine by me. The rumored cast blew.
 
Personally, I'm extremely glad that this version ''apparently'' won't happen.
Maybe W.B. has wised up after TDK and will get a first rate cast when they try again, and you know they will try again.
 
Eric Bana actually resembles Lord pretty much! :wow:

The big problems is that, no matter who Warner choose for Superman and Batman, fanboys won't aproove. Particulary, i don't dislike Armie Hammer, he got a good voice, a god height and looks like he has the acting chopps. Now Cotrona (Obviously not casted anymore) i would't like to see, because he don't look like he has acting chopps and he doesn't resemble Superman in nothing! Hammer still got ''something'' out of Bruce, but Cotrona? Hell No! :cmad:

I Like Megan Gale. I'm actually looking foward to see if she has such amazing acting skills. And i like Common also. He looks A LOT like the animated John Stewart. Adam Brody is tricky. I Could live with that. As for Hugh-Keays Byrne. Well. He looks like the part, and would be whearing make-up all the time, so, aprooved. Santiago Cabrera also could work, but i have some grips.

Teresa Palmer is OK, but i prefered a more exotic look on Talia. And Jay Baruchel would't be playing Max Lord. He just would't. He would be the comical Henchmen, right? He could only be the comical henchmen, right? RIGHT? :o
 
Eric Bana actually resembles Lord pretty much! :wow:

The big problems is that, no matter who Warner choose for Superman and Batman, fanboys won't aproove. Particulary, i don't dislike Armie Hammer, he got a good voice, a god height and looks like he has the acting chopps. Now Cotrona (Obviously not casted anymore) i would't like to see, because he don't look like he has acting chopps and he doesn't resemble Superman in nothing! Hammer still got ''something'' out of Bruce, but Cotrona? Hell No! :cmad:

I Like Megan Gale. I'm actually looking foward to see if she has such amazing acting skills. And i like Common also. He looks A LOT like the animated John Stewart. Adam Brody is tricky. I Could live with that. As for Hugh-Keays Byrne. Well. He looks like the part, and would be whearing make-up all the time, so, aprooved. Santiago Cabrera also could work, but i have some grips.

Teresa Palmer is OK, but i prefered a more exotic look on Talia. And Jay Baruchel would't be playing Max Lord. He just would't. He would be the comical Henchmen, right? He could only be the comical henchmen, right? RIGHT? :o

They should be looking to give Lord the "Nero" treatment. I was actually thinking Orlando Bloom could pull off Max. I know a lot of people won't like that but, he has the potential to play a real ass**** villain. As far as Palmer, I think that will be ok. I would also like to see someone more exotic though. What's the deal with Cotrona? I didn't realize he wasn't definitely out.
 
I Am only hoping. I Really would't like to see Cotrona as Superman, despite the fact i want a Justice League movie REALLY BAD.
 
I keep coming back to Scott Porter for Superman.

porterus5.jpg


He's got the look, he's a solid actor, and with his television and film work he fits my - or rather Star Trek's criteria.
 
Just cast Routh as Superman. It seems silly not too. That way, we don't need any Singer sequels. ROUTH can become the JLA Superman. The fact is, ROUTH was the best part of that film, and the one actor who could make the transition. No need for Lois (as she is married).... Singer may have done us a favor, as this could allow a romance between Wonder Woman and Superman to blossom.
 
I would take Routh over anyone. Damn the continuity/universe repercussions.

I just don't think it'll happen.
 
Scott Porter is cool, but i rather watch him as the Flash (Wally West).
 
Just cast Routh as Superman. It seems silly not too. That way, we don't need any Singer sequels. ROUTH can become the JLA Superman. The fact is, ROUTH was the best part of that film, and the one actor who could make the transition. No need for Lois (as she is married).... Singer may have done us a favor, as this could allow a romance between Wonder Woman and Superman to blossom.

Maybe I'm just a Justice League Unlimited fanboy, but hell no!

Batman/WW ftw. :up:
 
YEa the new trek found the right balance of casting, hopefully if an all new start happens with jla film they can make a better cast.
 
I keep coming back to Scott Porter for Superman.

porterus5.jpg


He's got the look, he's a solid actor, and with his television and film work he fits my - or rather Star Trek's criteria.

Yeah, I remember Porter from the JL casting wars last year. I would take him over Cotrona any day of the week :hehe:
 
Honestly, I'm much more impressed with Watchmen's cast than Star Trek's cast. One real unknown, Ackerman, but with a decent track record, an Oscar nominee, a Golden Globe nominee, an actor that had a substantial part in an acclaimed Woody Allen film and is getting very good notices for his newest movie, among the principle cast. It might have been equally as "unknown", but there's definitely not a credibility problem.
 
An excellent job was done for the casting of Watchmen, I'm impressed too. Trek just happens to have a little more in common with Justice League.
 
Ackerman was in that God awful Heartbreak Kid remake.
 
Maybe I'm just a Justice League Unlimited fanboy, but hell no!

Batman/WW ftw. :up:


It isn't just the JLU fanboy in you. I don't think in any universe, comics, cartoons, or movies, that Superman and WW should get together. I like WW and Batman flirting with it - but it too should never come to fruition.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"