Superman Returns Superman Returns: Quick Observations by Pittman4Two

Pittman4Two

Sidekick
Joined
May 23, 2006
Messages
1,193
Reaction score
365
Points
73
Good morning all, I'm very excited about the new Supes film being released at the end of June and I look forward to chatting with everyone as we look forward to the end of June.


I'd like to list a couple of observations from which I've gathered from watching various trailers, clips, snippets, etc. of the new film, Superman Returns:

1. Brandon Routh as Superman - I have to admit, he's a young lad. He really looks young during the trailers. In my humble opinion, I don't think Mr. Chris Reeve can be replaced as the Man in Blue. Like I said, that's my opinion. I'll give the kid a shot, for sure. He is good looking though and that should appeal to avid Supes fans.

2. Too much CGI - I know we're in the age of the computer. I mean, look what we're doing right now...surfing the Internets, posting on message boards, etc. but I think there's a time when it's all a bit too much. The original Superman films lacked CGI but the films still looked great. Did we ever see Supes get tangled up in a wire, did we ever see the fan blowing his cape in the breeze? No we didn't. So why the need for the latest and greatest of technologicals? I'll let this slide because I know we're in the computer age.

3. The Suit - It'll take some getting used to. I was always a fan of the bright colors of red, blue, yellow, and the red cape. This rusty red and off-blue is really different, but that's what the directors and filmmakers wanted, I imagine. I like the texture of the suit though. The shield appears to be too, too small. I'll give Singer a little leeway since I enjoyed X-Men and Sin City so much.

4. Overall Thoughts - It's a great time for us Supes fans. We've waited a long, long time. We've dispelled the rumors of Nick Cage and Jason Gedrick as Superman, we've rummaged through the horrible scripts...the day is almost here! I look forward to it.

Does anyone have any thoughts they'd like to add? Thanks.
 
Welcome to the Hype Pittman...

I think a lot of people agree with you, and I think a lot of people don't...but hey that's what opinions are for.

I am with you though in being pumped!

June 30 can't get here fast enough!!! :D
 
Why does everyone seem to think that Brandon Routh is simply trying to replace Christopher Reeve as Superman ? :confused: They are not making this Movie to "replace" Christopher Reeve. This is just simply another Superman Movie & along with everthing else you either like it or you dont. It gets annoying hearing People say things like Brandon may not replace Christopher Reeve when that is not the point to this Movie or the point of casting another Superman at all.
 
Welcome to the Hype Pittman4Two! :)

indeed the costume will take some getting used to, but who knows, maybe by the next sequel they would've made some adjustments to the suit that will make it more aesthtically acceptable ;)

and yes, Chrsitopher Reeve will always have a special place in all of our hearts :supes:


btw, just out of curiosity, what did Brian Singer contribute into the making of Sin City? :confused:
 
Brandon Routh was the PERFECT CHOICE for Superman.

I don't want to think as this actor playing Superman. Superman is bigger than anybody in Hollywood.
 
I want to take th etime to thank everyone for the nice welcome. I've really enjoyed being a guest and browsing through all the threads to see some top-notch "super" discussions. ;)

GothicPowerMix1 said:
Why does everyone seem to think that Brandon Routh is simply trying to replace Christopher Reeve as Superman ? :confused: They are not making this Movie to "replace" Christopher Reeve. This is just simply another Superman Movie & along with everthing else you either like it or you dont. It gets annoying hearing People say things like Brandon may not replace Christopher Reeve when that is not the point to this Movie or the point of casting another Superman at all.

Gothic, I think this is because Chris Reeve was Superman for a long, long time and now some new guy will assume the "duties" of being the biggest superhero in the history of comic books and their history. Brandon will have a ton of pressure on his shoulders as well as the pressure of replacing such an icon of Chris Reeve's stature.

VGPOP, yes I understand that this is a continuation of the series but don't you think Routh is a tad young for the part? The last time we saw Supes was when he was facing the Nuclear Man and hurling those missiles towards the son. Reeve was an older man by then, so by logical transgression...wouldn't a middle-aged actor suffice the role?

Like I said, I don't doubt Singer's genious as far as filmmaking goes so it's probably the right choice in the long run.
 
GothicPowerMix1 said:
Why does everyone seem to think that Brandon Routh is simply trying to replace Christopher Reeve as Superman ? :confused: They are not making this Movie to "replace" Christopher Reeve. This is just simply another Superman Movie & along with everthing else you either like it or you dont. It gets annoying hearing People say things like Brandon may not replace Christopher Reeve when that is not the point to this Movie or the point of casting another Superman at all.

He never stated that he thought Brandon Routh was "replacing" Christopher Reeve. Don't overreact.

But it should expected that there will be comparisons, as he is supposed to be picking up from Christopher Reeve's Superman.
 
DogofKrypton said:
He never stated that he thought Brandon Routh was "replacing" Christopher Reeve. Don't overreact.

Whatever the intentions are though, HE IS REPLACING REEVE.
 
Chris Reeve will NOT be replaced as Superman.

Although those comparisons will be warranted since Reeve has, in fact, played the role as Superman before. Therefore, Routh will, no doubt, face comparisons to Reeve.
 
I'll give Singer a little leeway since I enjoyed X-Men and Sin City so much.

I don't follow you here.... Sin City? Singer had nothing to do with that. But i'll agree with X-Men... only cause X2 was decent... but don't get me wrong, its not that I'm not excited about SR... I just hope it holds up after multiple viewings (something X1 and X2 did not.)
 
ok thanks... nice thoughts. I agree with some of it.

Superman will no doubt eclipse all films this summer. Years from now this year will be remembered for only one movie. ha ha ha ha. This is true, I tell you.
 
Pittman4Two said:
Chris Reeve will NOT be replaced as Superman.

Although those comparisons will be warranted since Reeve has, in fact, played the role as Superman before. Therefore, Routh will, no doubt, face comparisons to Reeve.

You are... WRONG!!! ROUTH is SUPERMAN FOREVER!
 
Routh, Reeve, and sometimes Welling all embody the same being in my mind.
 
Cinemaman said:
You are... WRONG!!! ROUTH is SUPERMAN FOREVER!

I appreciate your cantor, however I do believe that Routh will be Superman for some time.

He'll just have to grow on me as Val Kilmer did as Batman. Kilmer, in my opinion, is the best Batman going...but that's for another forum.
 
Pittman4Two said:
I appreciate your cantor, however I do believe that Routh will be Superman for some time.

He'll just have to grow on me as Val Kilmer did as Batman. Kilmer, in my opinion, is the best Batman going...but that's for another forum.

What I think?

ROUTH+Suit=:supes:

BALE+Suit=:batman:
 
Pittman4Two said:
Cineman, I see your point. Routh is Superman.

Routh is A Superman, and shall be for some time, but eventually, the mantle will pass. Just like with Reeves, Reeve, Cain, and Welling.

Personally, I will reserve giving him the full mantle until I see the Movie.

BR's gotta EARN the title in my eyes ;)
 
Nice to have you on board Pitman. Glad to hear some of your opinions. I think your observations are what a majority of people are concerned with. Your post was well worded and didn't try to sound hateful towards the movie. I'm hyped for it as well and I'm glad you are looking at the movie as a whole and not worrying yourself over the minor details that you posted. Have fun at the boards.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"